KC Gog vs. Thanos

Started by cyber tuff guy!8 pages
Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
IT's one story arc. He's the same guy as far as I'm concerned. And as far as I"m concerened. The battle could go either way.

No it isn't and he isn't

Originally posted by Galan007
One could kill various Supermen with a gesture...

One could not.

One could kill myx with a gesture, the other gave Superman his best shot and merely pushed him back. Although Supes was so hot he told Wonderwoman not to touch him.

Originally posted by cyber tuff guy!
One could kill myx with a gesture,
If by kill, you mean Mxy had to return back to the 5th dimension because of the hole Gog blasted in his gut.... I agree. 🙂

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
IT's one story arc. He's the same guy as far as I'm concerned. And as far as I"m concerened. The battle could go either way.
Gog from 'The Kingdom' would destroy Thanos effortlessly.

Originally posted by Galan007
If by kill, you mean Mxy had to return back to the 5th dimension because of the hole Gog blasted in his gut.... I agree. 🙂

Yeah. Mxy has been banned from Death by Mike Carlin.

Originally posted by Galan007
If by kill, you mean Mxy had to return back to the 5th dimension because of the hole Gog blasted in his gut.... I agree. 🙂

I do indeed and as far as that reality goes Mys died we see him fall over after the hole is blasted as I remember it's years since I read it, we don't see him return.

yeah you really don't kill Mxy. He just disappears for a while to come back later.

Originally posted by cyber tuff guy!
No it isn't and he isn't

One could kill myx with a gesture, the other gave Superman his best shot and merely pushed him back. Although Supes was so hot he told Wonderwoman not to touch him.

It's kind of confusing. I have to reread. ONe version in the kingdom Come was the gy who destroyed captain atom and cracked his previously uncrackable shell. The other was the five God powered one. And If i'm not mistaken, the lord of Hypertime is some alterversion of Gog right? It's been a long time. Help me out. I cna't remember all the details. I read the Kingdome come like ten years ago I think lol.

Originally posted by Superherovandal
yeah you really don't kill Mxy. He just disappears for a while to come back later.

As far as Gog is concerned nothing is certain. Remember he killed Superman hundreds of times more than Doomsday.

Originally posted by cyber tuff guy!
I do indeed and as far as that reality goes Mys died we see him fall over after the hole is blasted as I remember it's years since I read it, we don't see him return.

Only one Mxy.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
It's kind of confusing. I have to reread. ONe version in the kingdom Come was the gy who destroyed captain atom and cracked his previously uncrackable shell. The other was the five God powered one. And If i'm not mistaken, the lord of Hypertime is some alterversion of Gog right? It's been a long time. Help me out. I cna't remember all the details. I read the Kingdome come like ten years ago I think lol.

Yes Mangog and the two Gogs are seperate from each other. The first Gog from Kingdom also used Hypertime hence how he kept killing Superman without rupturing Space/Time. Mangog never had an Origin. Gog Wars had a grudge.

Originally posted by cyber tuff guy!
I do indeed and as far as that reality goes Mys died we see him fall over after the hole is blasted as I remember it's years since I read it, we don't see him return.
Mxy uttered his name backwards before he hit the ground.

Just because he didn't return, doesn't mean that blast killed him.

It reminds me of the Ruin incident.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Only one Mxy.

Not in Hypertime. Hence all the different versions of Supes and the ending when you realise the Byrne Era is Over and if we want a space faring Superman we'll get one.

Originally posted by cyber tuff guy!
Yes Mangog and the two Gogs are seperate from each other. The first Gog from Kingdom also used Hypertime hence how he kept killing Superman without rupturing Space/Time. Mangog never had an Origin. Gog Wars had a grudge.

OK so why do I keep remembering Clark and Diana's son as Gog. Like he was stolen as a baby and turned into Gog or magog. DIdn't Gog take him and train him to be magog or something like that. I know something linked the first story and the 2nd together. I have a headache trying to remember.

Originally posted by Galan007
Mxy uttered his name backwards before he hit the ground.

Just because he didn't return, doesn't mean that blast killed him.

Although that's how the writer wanted us to interpret it.

Originally posted by cyber tuff guy!
Although that's how the writer wanted us to interpret it.
In your opinion.

Not in mine. 🙂

I personally don't think the writers ever want us to believe Mxy can die. 🙂

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
OK so why do I keep remembering Clark and Diana's son as Gog. Like he was stolen as a baby and turned into Gog or magog. DIdn't Gog take him and train him to be magog or something like that. I know something linked the first story and the 2nd together. I have a headache trying to remember.

No the son just had the power of Hypertime, Gog kidnapped him yes, but he was retrieved. His adult form we thought was Rip Hunter most of the story.

Originally posted by cyber tuff guy!
Not in Hypertime. Hence all the different versions of Supes and the ending when you realise the Byrne Era is Over and if we want a space faring Superman we'll get one.

nah. still only one mxy. too much evidence shows that there is currently one mxy.

Originally posted by Galan007
In your opinion.

Not in mine. 🙂

I personally don't think the writers ever interpret us to believe Mxy can die. 🙂

I think it depends on the writer. DC was very different at the time. Remember Hypertime was to complex for other writers and I admit most of us readers to get our hears round. What was Waid up to. The Kingdom was an awful series.

Originally posted by cyber tuff guy!
The Kingdom was an awful series.
You think so?

I rather enjoyed it. 🙂

Mxy cannot Die. He tried to commit Suicide. He made a Doomsday more powerful than any version and when it "killed" him, he pierced the 4th viel and met God. Who happend to be Mike Carlin, the editor of the superman books. Mike banned him from death and sent him back.