Eminem

Originally posted by BackFire349
i dont think so tim. its a guy talking with a beat behind. nothing more, nothing less.

it is talking rhyme with a beat

its not just talking in rhyme. its about doing it rythmatic in connection with the beats and background meldody.

still talking

no. its closer to singing

it is not singing at all, cause when you sing you alter your voice into higher and lower tones, so rapping is far from singing.

many rappers do too

do what?
Rap is a slang of a talk, conversation, or discussion.
It has also been labeled as a debate informally of beat-driven rhymes.

Cleaning up my closet- Eminem

listen to it, that's singing

then it is not rap

at least HEAR it, before you jump to conclusions

I have heard it, and it sucks

so, it's rap

no the song just sucks

I dare you to make a rapsong and to publish it worldwide

why, Im not found of rap besides this song is not rap.

to show eminem doesn't have talent, like you say

have you heard the song finti? he's only not rapping in the chorus.

Ok, look, let's get this sorted... is rap, by definition, something that cannot be at different pitches and/or notes or not? If so, then Finti's claim that singing like that is not rap is valid, regardless of what his opinion of the quality of it is.

Originally posted by mah
he's only not rapping in the chorus.