Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Other than Rosario Dawson, the casting was dead on, it was as close to 100% accurate as one can get. Wonder why this was done?
I assume because the producers saw merit in a very close to accurate portrayal of the Comic Books. Possibly because Frank Miller was closer involved, too. And because the source material is very easy to turn into movie.
Now, Batman Begins, also being an excellent movie, did not go as close as possible to story at least. Because it doesn't matter how exact the transition is, it matters how good the movie is. You can obviously see that Batman Begins was influenced by Year One...there are similar traits in it, but, it is not a panel for panel copy...it's a standalone movie, with a standalone story. In fact, a stand alone universe.