Super Android 17 vs Superman

Started by Avalonofthewind4 pages

Originally posted by Creshosk
Technically they're cyborg's even with the name "artificial human."

They were "constructed from a human base" as stated by Android 17 in the manga. They were runaways who were heavily fitted with cybernetics.

18 even has a daughter with Krillan: Marron.

Thanks for the assist. 🙂

Originally posted by Creshosk
Technically they're cyborg's even with the name "artificial human."

They were "constructed from a human base" as stated by Android 17 in the manga. They were runaways who were heavily fitted with cybernetics.

18 even has a daughter with Krillan: Marron.


whats his face kinda defects too, the green bulky one,
he was nice to everyone cept goku

In any case which Superman are we talking about? The one who can sneeze and destroy solar systems, or the one who can absorb galaxy destroying attacks? sly

Post-Crisis Superman.

The Superman we see in comics today, etc...

Originally posted by Harry Fingerman
Post-Crisis Superman.

The Superman we see in comics today, etc...

So the one who absorbed the energy from the Mageddon warhead, that was capable of vaporizing half a galaxy, and wasn't really harmed and even managed to smile in JLA #41?

Originally posted by Creshosk
So the one who absorbed the energy from the Mageddon warhead, that was capable of vaporizing half a galaxy, and wasn't really harmed and even managed to smile in JLA #41?
Yupperz.

Originally posted by Creshosk
So the one who absorbed the energy from the Mageddon warhead, that was capable of vaporizing half a galaxy, and wasn't really harmed and even managed to smile in JLA #41?

No, the superman who fell to his death in JSA #81

Originally posted by ExtraMision5555
No, the superman who fell to his death in JSA #81
Forum Rules
No Mentioning Events of PIS
Plot Induced Stupidity, or PIS, is when characters don't use their abilities or skills to the fullest extent as shown before, even within their personality ranges, for the sake of the story plotline.

^ the irony of using that rule against someone else while you yourself argue Superman can take half-a-galaxy buster is quite epic
they're both PIS using the "I don't like it, let's ignore it" style of debating

Originally posted by Creshosk
Technically they're cyborg's even with the name "artificial human."

They were "constructed from a human base" as stated by Android 17 in the manga. They were runaways who were heavily fitted with cybernetics.

18 even has a daughter with Krillan: Marron.

Didn't they make a wish on the dragonballs to turn 18 into a human?

Originally posted by Jack Harkness
Superman beats them all.

DBZ threads are stupid.

Originally posted by Mindset
Didn't they make a wish on the dragonballs to turn 18 into a human?

Nah. The wish was just to remove the bomb inside 18 (that allowed her to self-destruct. 16's bomb of course, was surgically removed).

As for Super 17, if you leave out his ability to absorb Ki energy, he's really no stronger than 2 Android 17's (Perfect Cell could take him).

Besides, Androids 19 and 20 (Dr. Gero) could absorb Ki energy too, but did that make them any match for Super Saiyans, or even Piccolo? Of course not.

If Super 17 can get killed by a Super Dragon Fist, Superman could easily hit through his chest or something with a powerful punch.

Anyhow, yeah. These Superman vs DBZ threads have gotten way old now. yawn
*laughs at the thought of Superman vs Naruto threads*

Originally posted by 123KID
^ the irony of using that rule against someone else while you yourself argue Superman can take half-a-galaxy buster is quite epic
they're both PIS using the "I don't like it, let's ignore it" style of debating

I used to believe in the concept of PIS, but after talking with some other posters, I no longer stand by it.

I should however, point out that Superman's feats dwarf everyone's in DBZ. doped

Seriously, put Goku or someone else from DBZ in Superman's place. See if anyone thinks they could do what he does.

As for Super 17, if you leave out his ability to absorb Ki energy, he's really no stronger than 2 Android 17's (Perfect Cell could take him).

that's not true at all
he was mopping the floor with Vegeta and Gohan and Majuub (who is stronger than Kid Buu)
Vegeta in GT and Majuub both are WAY out of Cell's league
when Majuub started to hit him repeatedly (Majuub doesn't need to transform so it's not like he's weaker to start off with like the Saiyans) S17 didn't even move and this was well before he absorbed any energy

Besides, Androids 19 and 20 (Dr. Gero) could absorb Ki energy too, but did that make them any match for Super Saiyans, or even Piccolo? Of course not.

they absorbed it through their hands and could be taken apart as long as you avoided them
17 had enough power to put up a barrier to withstand everything an SS4 Goku had (well, most of it)

I should however, point out that Superman's feats dwarf everyone's in DBZ.

we're not talking about Z though
we're talking about GT
where Base Goku can blow away dimensional walls

Seriously, put Goku or someone else from DBZ in Superman's place. See if anyone thinks they could do what he does.

he'd probably doa better job
unlike Clark Goku uses his speed in fights a lot

Originally posted by 123KID
we're not talking about Z though
we're talking about GT
where Base Goku can blow away dimensional walls

he'd probably doa better job
unlike Clark Goku uses his speed in fights a lot

GT loses by default. 🙄

🤨 You can't be serious..........Goku would get annihilated against the upper tier of Superman's rogues. Hell, even the mid tier guys would give him problems.

Doesn't use his speed? whatdur Are you kidding me? Superman is one of the best top tiers in comics when it comes to combat speed.

Hell, even the good guys Supes throws down with would wreck Goku. Example: Orion.

You can't be serious..........Goku would get annihilated against the upper tier of Superman's rogues. Hell, even the mid tier guys would give him problems.

any particular names ?
i really don't see Doomsday doing it unless its H/P

most of Superman's high-end feats are once in a couple years
the rest of the time punches from Wonder Woman hurt him
i'd like to see Superman fight Kid Buu thought...it be funny

Doesn't use his speed? Are you kidding me? Superman is one of the best top tiers in comics when it comes to combat speed.

he's pretty much right down there with the Surfer when it comes to combat speed
FYI though Goku's IT in the anime is lightspeed and S17 can react to it and get there faster than Goku can...just in case we need the "lightspeed" argument
though again Supes hardly ever "fights" at such a speed

Hell, even the good guys Supes throws down with would wreck Goku. Example: Orion.

Orion has a lot of abilities Supes does not

Originally posted by 123KID
that's not true at all
he was mopping the floor with Vegeta and Gohan and Majuub (who is stronger than Kid Buu)
Vegeta in GT and Majuub both are WAY out of Cell's league
when Majuub started to hit him repeatedly (Majuub doesn't need to transform so it's not like he's weaker to start off with like the Saiyans) S17 didn't even move and this was well before he absorbed any energy

they absorbed it through their hands and could be taken apart as long as you avoided them
17 had enough power to put up a barrier to withstand everything an SS4 Goku had (well, most of it)


Here's the thing though. Vegeta and Piccolo knew about Android 19's and 20's ability to absorb Ki energy, so they refrained from wasting Ki blasts on them. That wasn't the case when Goku and the Z-fighters fought Super 17. If Goku had known Super 17 could absorb energy blasts, he (while at SS4) would've just beat Super 17 instantly with Super Dragon Fist, rather than waste a bunch of Kamehameha Waves on 17.

Were it not for Super 17's ability to absorb Ki energy, I doubt he would've even lasted long against the Z-fighters, as he overwhelmed Vegeta only after absorbing his Final Shine attack, but whatever. I could be wrong there...

Either way, Superman wins this match by a landslide. 😬 I guess I wouldn't be surprised if there was a Superman vs SS4 Gogeta topic as well...

Originally posted by 123KID
i'd like to see Superman fight Kid Buu thought...it be funny

Heh. I guess it would be in a way...

Originally posted by 123KID
Orion has a lot of abilities Supes does not

He's got some abilities Supes doesn't have, but not a lot.

Thanks for bumping this thread, now I can close it. No DB characters, per the rules.