Captain America versus Karnak

vs

Karnak should win, but Cap would win.

Not familar with Karnak. What is his deal?

Originally posted by Caps Conscience
Not familar with Karnak. What is his deal?

I was wondering if he could find the weakpoint in Caps shield and break it apart...theoretically its feasible

Cap

Speed has been a problem for Karnak in the past and Steve has plenty of that.

Originally posted by masterbruce
his unique power is finding the weakspot in anything and he's a great martial artist

I was wondering if he could find the weakpoint in Caps shield and break it apart...theoretically its feasible

The weak point in his shield was repaired after it was last broken.

Not to mention the fact that the weakest point in a totally invulnerable object is still invulnerable - check his fight against the Hulk, for example.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Cap

Speed has been a problem for Karnak in the past and Steve has plenty of that.

Cosigned.

Reference: Last two Karnak vs. T'Challa matches.

Originally posted by Soljer
Not to mention the fact that the weakest point in a totally invulnerable object is still invulnerable - check his fight against the Hulk, for example.

Is that an endorsement of Hulk?

Originally posted by Soljer
The weak point in his shield was repaired after it was last broken.

Not to mention the fact that the weakest point in a totally invulnerable object is still invulnerable - check his fight against the Hulk, for example.

everything has a flaw...nothing's perfect

Karnak will find that flaw and exploit it to destroy the shield

Originally posted by masterbruce
everything has a flaw...nothing's perfect

Karnak will find that flaw and exploit it to destroy the shield

Indeed. But when the weakest link of the chain isn't weak enough...

Well...there you go.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Is that an endorsement of Hulk?

Endorsement that Karnak can't do dick to him? Even at his WEAKEZT POINSTZ! LOLZ!

Yeah.

Endorsement that he is a totally invulnerable object? No - that would be Cap's shield, which has only even been harmed by ridiculously powerful foes.

Originally posted by Soljer
Indeed. But when the weakest link of the chain isn't weak enough...

Well...there you go.

karnak doesn't break things through being powerful...he does so by finding a weakpoint that requires only little force to affect

but this is all conjecture on both of our parts

Originally posted by masterbruce
karnak doesn't break things through being powerful...he does so by finding a weakpoint that requires only little force to affect

but this is all conjecture on both of our parts

No. It isn't.

Karnak couldn't even make the Hulk blink.

Cap's shield >>>>>>>>>> The Hulk.

Originally posted by masterbruce
everything has a flaw...nothing's perfect

Karnak will find that flaw and exploit it to destroy the shield

Soljer's point was that the weakest point isn't always sufficiently vulnerable. Karnak tried it on Hulk and it had no effect, but when he told BB where to hit it worked fine.

Karnak can easily find the weak spot but he probably won't be capable of exploiting it.

Originally posted by Soljer
Endorsement that Karnak can't do dick to him? Even at his WEAKEZT POINSTZ! LOLZ!

Yeah.

Endorsement that he is a totally invulnerable object? No - that would be Cap's shield, which has only even been harmed by ridiculously powerful foes.

Party pooper.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Soljer's point was that the weakest point isn't always sufficiently vulnerable. Karnak tried it on Hulk and it had no effect, but when he told BB where to hit it worked fine.

Karnak can easily find the weak spot but he probably won't be capable of exploiting it.

karnaks abilities seem to work better on inanimate structures (ie buildings, mountains, etc) as opposed to organic material (ie hulk) which kinda makes sense

thus he might have an easier time with cap's shield than hulk

Not to mention the fact that when the shield DID have a weakpoint - after the beyonder recreated - the weakpoint was a SINGLE SOLITARY molecule that was out of place.

And guess what?

The imperfection isn't there anymore.

Regardless, it doesn't matter as far as this thread goes - Karnak'll never get the chance. Steve one-shots him.

Karnak needs to meditate on it and find the weakpoint and hes slow!

He found a weak point on Black Panther, Panther still dodged him and took him out.

umm karnak power is useless on a human body since any skilled martial artist in tier 3 and above no were those weak points are as well.

Originally posted by masterbruce
karnaks abilities seem to work better on inanimate structures (ie buildings, mountains, etc) as opposed to organic material (ie hulk) which kinda makes sense

thus he might have an easier time with cap's shield than hulk

So, given a day with it just sitting there, could he break, say, Mjolnir? It isn't perfect, after all.

Doubtful.