Origin of Hobbits and Sauron's Powers?

Started by Captain REX2 pages

Origin of Hobbits and Sauron's Powers?

The Silmarrilion emphasizes the beginning of Middle-earth, the birth of the Elves, the birth of Men, and the birth of Dwarves, and al that other stuff, but it never says one word about where Hobbits originated or when.

And Sauron dies at least twice in the Silmarrilion. How so?

em..Sauron dies twice in hte Simlarillion?

Don't be confusing big, even seemingly total, defeats of Sauron with his actual, genuine death. Evenm after the Ring is destroyed his essence is only permanently dispersed, not destroyed.

I think so...

Sauron gets pulled into the void that the Valar make in the sea, or something like that, in the destruction of the Numanorean's city.

hmm..must finish the book first. Can't talk about what i don't know...yet

Originally posted by Dexx
hmm..must finish the book first. Can't talk about what i don't know...yet

Why not? IT,s never stopped me LOL.
yes sauron lost his phiycal form a few times but as ush. said(typed) his spirit lives on. 😠 😈
as for hobbits I just don,t know 😱
I think they just turn up. after all the dwarfs were held back so as the elves would be first born, then came the dwarfs, then men then hobbits?? 😛

cronology's something else....it's how they appeared that's confusing/

every one has to start somewhere.

Must finish the book firts. I'm only at the "beren and Luthien" chapter ( amaising🙂 ) But it would be strange not mentioning the hobbits.
About sauron's powers...he was Morgoth's closest and most powerfull servant. Morgoth makes his own ...staff, so he's responsible for all of sauron's abillities

sorry morgoth does not make his own staff.... they are corrupted by him ,he is not able to make new life only ERU can do that 😄

Maybe the Hobbits are nothing but a cross breed of Elves and Dwarves

😄 that would be something

Dwelves.

the movie would have to be an 18 or x 😮‍💨

didn't mean "make" as in create...

sorry what did u mean?

i mean morgth's servants became that way through his actions. He didn't literally create life....only bend it.

that must hurt

Like bending my finger back until...OWW!!!...it snaps off like this?

*holds up finger*

Re: Origin of Hobbits and Sauron's Powers?

Originally posted by Captain REX
The Silmarrilion emphasizes the beginning of Middle-earth, the birth of the Elves, the birth of Men, and the birth of Dwarves, and al that other stuff, but it never says one word about where Hobbits originated or when.

And Sauron dies at least twice in the Silmarrilion. How so?

So since the "in" thing now is to be drudging up old threads..I thought that I would do my part in helping getting this Forum back to it's roots...

I found this thread and it asks a very interesting question...

Where did Hobbits come from and when ? Can anyone field this answer ?