Originally posted by Air Legendhes an on panel creation. he could interact with the fantastic four. he could interact with thanos and would be absorbed.
There you have it. God cannot beat God, quit being silly.
his pencil couldnt do a thing to him.
im arguing about on panel stuff not a writer vs thanos.
k. thanos stil wins here as he could definitely interact with kirbys avatar.
its not thanos vs a writer here but thanos vs his avatar who can be defeated on panel.
Originally posted by quanchi112
hes an on panel creation. he could interact with the fantastic four. he could interact with thanos and would be absorbed.his pencil couldnt do a thing to him.
im arguing about on panel stuff not a writer vs thanos.
k. thanos stil wins here as he could definitely interact with kirbys avatar.
its not thanos vs a writer here but thanos vs his avatar who can be defeated on panel.
If you're going to say Thanos is greater than God and that Thanos would win, I'm going to side with nvr.
According to your logic, the avatar would win because Thanos is just a drawing on a piece of paper to him. How is Thanos going to absorb the avatar when the avatar himself is the one who drew him. I suppose he's going to try and paper cut him lol. If the avatar didn't want Thanos around he would simply erase him with his pencil or throw him in the trash. Thanos w/HOTI would just be a peice of paper to the avatar.
Originally posted by Air Legendsee ur trying to make this a writer vs thanos. if thats the case and which i dont believe it is its a stalemate. its like two different writers against each other.
If you're going to say Thanos is greater than God and that Thanos would win, I'm going to side with nvr.According to your logic, the avatar would win because Thanos is just a drawing on a piece of paper to him. How is Thanos going to absorb the avatar when the avatar himself is the one who drew him. I suppose he's going to try and paper cut him lol. If the avatar didn't want Thanos around he would simply erase him with his pencil or throw him in the trash. Thanos w/HOTI would just be a peice of paper to the avatar.
but if we argue on panel i think thanos can defeat kirbys avatar becuz he is a character on panel.
'
this argument is silly to begin with. i hate arguing characters vs writers its absolutely silly.
Originally posted by quanchi112
see ur trying to make this a writer vs thanos. if thats the case and which i dont believe it is its a stalemate. its like two different writers against each other.but if we argue on panel i think thanos can defeat kirbys avatar becuz he is a character on panel.
'this argument is silly to begin with. i hate arguing characters vs writers its absolutely silly.
If we argue on panel it's a stalemate as well because they are the same.
If we argue using your logic, the Avatar would win.
Originally posted by Air Legendon panel he had to use a pencil. he has limitations on panel. real world limitations.
If it's writer vs writer (which technically it really is) then it is a stalemate.If we argue on panel it's a stalemate as well because they are the same.
If we argue using your logic, the Avatar would win.
writer vs writer is silly to me.
Originally posted by quanchi112
hes an on panel creation. he could interact with the fantastic four. he could interact with thanos and would be absorbed.his pencil couldnt do a thing to him.
im arguing about on panel stuff not a writer vs thanos.
k. thanos stil wins here as he could definitely interact with kirbys avatar.
its not thanos vs a writer here but thanos vs his avatar who can be defeated on panel.
Quanchi...the most intransigent poster on KMC
Originally posted by Erik-Lensherrno thanos defeats a comic book character. he doesnt beat the real jack kirby. on panel thanos was supreme. he beats the one with a pencil who worked in a place where comic book characters can affect him.
Did he just say that Thanos beats The One Above All ?crazy
Wtf ?!
Originally posted by quanchi112
on panel he had to use a pencil. he has limitations on panel. real world limitations.
Originally posted by quanchi112
writer vs writer is silly to me.
Originally posted by quanchi112
also how can u have a jack kirby avatar when he doesnt write or draw comics anymore.
Originally posted by quanchi112
the writer has passed away.
Originally posted by quanchi112
see how silly this gets.
And in case you try to say "we're not talking about real world writers, we're talking about comic book characters!" I'll post this again because I already explained the matter with all the above :
Originally posted by Air Legend
If it's writer vs writer (which technically it really is) then it is a stalemate.If we argue on panel it's a stalemate as well because they are the same.
If we argue using your logic, the Avatar would win.
If you say Thanos would win because we are talking about comic characters again, you will prove KMC_Drifter right when he said you are the most intransigent poster on KMC.
Originally posted by Air Legendlook this is beyond ridiculous. this is so silly its laughable. i have told u my stance on this.
What the hell are you talking about? "God" chose to use a pencil and the reason he did that was because the real world writers wanted to imply that they are the ones in control and the best way they could do this was by drawing an avatar of them as God who acted in the same manner as a real world artist would.Well that is how this match would technically come down to, the way the authors want to write it.
The avatar wasn't just representing Jack Kirby, the avatar was representing the God of Marvel who acted in the same manner that a real world artist would. He looked like Jack Kirby to the FF4 because that was how they perceived him and fittingly so since he created the FF4.
http://img127.imageshack.us/my.php?image=fantasticfour51118yp4.jpg
[B]That's what my creations do. They find the humanity in God.
Did you even read the scans? They are posted on this thread for everyone to read.That doesn't matter. The avatar didn't just represent Jack Kirby, he represented the God of Marvel (the artists). The collaborator who works with God is presumably TOAA (the writers).
Call it silly but that's what it is. The outcome of this match is however the real world artists and writers want it to happen.
And in case you try to say "we're not talking about real world writers, we're talking about comic book characters!" I'll post this again because I already explained the matter with all the above :
If you say Thanos would win because we are talking about comic characters again, you will prove KMC_Drifter right when he said you are the most intransigent poster on KMC. [/B]
if i take this real world crap and apply it to this battle i have told u its a stalemate. its writer vs writer.
i dont come here to debate writers and real world people vs drawings.
Originally posted by rico777i never said he could defeat TOAA. he became that in the story or hadnt u noticed.
yes, he believes that Thanos /w HOTI can beat the TOAA, THe Presence and every other supreme being from other comic books...And he claims not to be a Thanos Fanboy... 🙄
ps the presence isnt supreme in comics.
