Wolverine vs. Lizard and Scorpion

Started by Alfheim6 pages
Alfheim Junior Member
Originally posted by Battlehammer
yes to my knowledge the issue is cannon as is any cross over with top cow with wolverine since the 90's.

OK can you prove this?

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Alfheim
OK can you prove this?

I guess. I can simply give you the issue number were wolverine enters top cow reality using a portal by the firm L and L which he been a part of since at least WW1

but that will take a bit, im not at home im at school.

Alfheim Junior Member

Originally posted by Battlehammer
I guess. I can simply give you the issue number were wolverine enters top cow reality using a portal by the firm L and L which he been a part of since at least WW1

but that will take a bit, im not at home im at school.

Yeah but that doesnt prove that its canon.....

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Alfheim
Yeah but that doesnt prove that its canon.....

actaully it does. it gives a detail explination on how he eneters the top cow reality and even shows you how he does it.

starlock Team Authority

Wolverine for the win

I dont see these two taking out logan i dont think they will even K.O him,maybe for a victory or two....Logan for the majority

Alfheim Junior Member
Originally posted by Battlehammer
actaully it does. it gives a detail explination on how he eneters the top cow reality and even shows you how he does it.

So what you're telling me is that something explained in a non-canon source makes it canon?

Apolloknight Your rule is at an end
Originally posted by Alfheim
So what you're telling me is that something explained in a non-canon source makes it canon?

Thats what I was thinking......

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Alfheim
So what you're telling me is that something explained in a non-canon source makes it canon?

but it is cannon..........

just like the latest marvel dc cross over...........

why would they explain how wolverine got there in a non cannon source.........does that even make senses to you?

Alfheim Junior Member
Originally posted by Apolloknight
Thats what I was thinking......

You know what I mean? Im like "Am I hearing thiings or is it just my imagination?"

Apolloknight Your rule is at an end

Originally posted by Battlehammer
but it is cannon..........

just like the latest marvel dc cross over...........

why would they explain how wolverine got there in a non cannon source.........does that even make senses to you?

Lots of Non-cannon books have cannon ties, or cannon history's of the characters within them.

It still doesn't make them cannon.

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Apolloknight
Lots of Non-cannon books have cannon ties, or cannon history's of the characters within them.

It still doesn't make them cannon.

really like what book?

also has any of them ever in full detail explained how a character got to the reality? nope I think not.

Alfheim Junior Member

Originally posted by Battlehammer
but it is cannon..........

just like the latest marvel dc cross over...........

why would they explain how wolverine got there in a non cannon source.........does that even make senses to you?

Well ok as far as I know there have actually been some canon DC marvel crossovers but by default I was under the impresion that comic company crossovers are not canon unless specified, so you should assume that its not canon.

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Alfheim
Well ok as far as I know there have actually been some canon DC marvel crossovers but by default I was under the impresion that comic company crossovers are not canon unless specified, so you should assume that its not canon.

here the thing there never specified.

There made cannon by certain events such as having a detailed explination on how the character was able to get into the others reality.

Apolloknight Your rule is at an end

Originally posted by Battlehammer
really like what book?

also has any of them ever in full detail explained how a character got to the reality? nope I think not.

But it still doesnt make it cannon..........

Alfheim Junior Member
Originally posted by Battlehammer
here the thing there never specified.

Exactly so its non canon.

Originally posted by Battlehammer

There made cannon by certain events such as having a detailed explination on how the character was able to get into the others reality.

Since when?

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Alfheim
Exactly so its non canon.

Since when?


please tell me were there ever flat out stated any cross over was cannon?

never.

Alfheim Junior Member

Im confused.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
please tell me were there ever flat out stated any cross over was cannon?

Mmmmm never as far as I know apparently one poster stated that there was a canon DC/Marvel crossover but as far as I know no company comic crossovers are ever canon but the poster is quite knowledgeable..ask Hercules.

Originally posted by Battlehammer

never.

Right ok isnt that my point?

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Alfheim
Im confused.

Mmmmm never as far as I know apparently one poster stated that there was a canon DC/Marvel crossover but as far as I know no company comic crossovers are ever canon but the poster is quite knowledgeable..ask Hercules.

Right ok isnt that my point?


marvel and DC was cannon..........they gave good reasons for why they enter eachothers reality.

The authors clearly ment for it to be cannon.

thats the whole thing.

Alfheim Junior Member

Originally posted by Battlehammer
marvel and DC was cannon..........they gave good reasons for why they enter eachothers reality.

The authors clearly ment for it to be cannon.

thats the whole thing.

Yeah but still dont see how that makes it canon..Maybe you're right but I think the writers need to say explicitly or the comic companies need to say that their canon, for example you'll never seen in a marvel bio such and such fought Superman

Battlehammer Senior Member

here the thing though comci companies dobn't think about cannon and non cannon.

were the ones who amde up that crap. Thats why you will never here a comic company say it