The Cave Scene!

Started by Jedireaper4 pages

No.. because if he hadnt had a son or daughter. Vader would still exist!

That makes no sense. He did learn from his mistakes and he DID give up his life for the lightside of the force. You can say it was for his son, but a Sith wouldn't care about that. He experienced both, saw the ultimate error in his ways and then fulfilled his destiny as the Chosen One. He destroyed the Sith and brought balance to the force.

Like i said before, everything he did in secret is what Luke allowed in his, more powerful, Jedi Order. So its not that Anakin was always power hungry, cause he wasn't - not until Padme's soon to be death, he was actually mapping out the blueprints for the next generation of Jedi. Luke saw the wrong in Anakin and the Jedi Order, and fused them together to make a new and improved version.

Say what you will, but Anakin is the Chosen One and did everything he had to do throughout his destiny to fulfill the prophecy.

You're a true GL croney boy.

No one is denying that Anakin is the Chosen one. I just think the prophecy doesn't make much sense since Anakin is not a very good chosen one. There's nothing in his ways that is worth following. And yes, he did give up his life to bring balance. But als Palpy said, it was like this: "Young fool, only now at the end do you understand." I think Anakin thought Palpy was talking to him.

How would he think he was talking to him? That makes no sense. Everything that happens throughout someones destiny is just that...destined. He had to go through all that to fulfill the prophecy.

It was joke, Subjekt.... a joke. I was ridiculing the whole Chosen One business...

Originally posted by queeq
There's nothing in his ways that is worth following. And yes, he did give up his life to bring balance. But als Palpy said, it was like this: "Young fool, only now at the end do you understand." I think Anakin thought Palpy was talking to him.

I wouldn't say he was vrey young anymore...

*Vader's thoughts on seeing Luke attacked by his master:*
"Hey....I've been a ruthless monster for over twenty-years: I've probably killed thousands, if not millions, of people; I nearly single-handedly eradicated my Jedi brethren....but....killing one man will atone for it all!" 😱

And did it?

Not in my opinion, if the EU is to be considered....didn't seem to change the state of the galaxy very much. ❌
Poor Vader....no sympathy from this quarter.

Then it is a good thing this is the OT section. 😉

😛

More like OTF....there's not much actual discussion here. 😛

Well, if people bring in good discussions, we discuss, but until then...

That's the thing, innit? Nothing to discuss, really....

Well, think of something, the movies have been out quite a while.

Originally posted by queeq
It was joke, Subjekt.... a joke. I was ridiculing the whole Chosen One business...
I thought jokes were meant to be funny? 😛

People with a sense of humor will get it.

I found it slightly amusing. Not as far as funny though.

I find funny things funny. ✅

So then what did you think of the comment made by queeq?

Do I have to think too? 😕