Originally posted by Soljer
You mean about the non-canon Thanos scan?Meh, I meant to imply that it should be up to Trickster, rather than the judges, but whatever.
If he wants it gone, get rid of it. Like I said, it's not like a very big case was staked upon it for either participant.
Originally posted by SnazzySmurphdamn straight.
Nvr, let Trick do the debating... this "That doesn't count"/"Yes it does" crap should be kept to the match.And Trick agreed to the rules, and has been boasting from the beginning about how this would be easy, so "goober set up the rules to be very hard on tricks" is completely false... if Trick can't win under these circumstances, it's his own damn fault.
"There is only one Darkseid" Goober's own words.
I'm laying down using the GDS feats as per my agreement, not because they don't count.
And Quan? Even Goober admits Thanos cannot take Darkseid for a majority. The debate is whether he can get 1-2 wins. 😉 My goal is to prove Darkseid's power and skyfather status. Goober's goal, is to prove that Thanos can hang with skyfathers and occasionally take a win.
Of course even if I lose, the forum will have acknowledge that Thanos can take a win from Odin, and that Darkseid is out of Thanos's league in general.
And if I win, Darkseid will get even more props and people will see that Darkseid is out of Thanos's league in general.
Either way, I win. evillaugh
Originally posted by TricksterPriestwell i disagree and definitely think thanos wins VAST MAJORITY. he is winning the debate and one thing i can see happening from all of this. people will still stick to their guns on who wins but superman beating ds will not be pis anymore. once it happens a few times like i have said before it isnt pis and isnt a fluke.
"There is only one Darkseid" Goober's own words.I'm laying down using the GDS feats as per my agreement, not because they don't count.
And Quan? Even Goober admits Thanos cannot take Darkseid for a majority. The debate is whether he can get 1-2 wins. 😉 My goal is to prove Darkseid's power and skyfather status. Goober's goal, is to prove that Thanos can hang with skyfathers and occasionally take a win.
Of course even if I lose, the forum will have acknowledge that Thanos can take a win from Odin, and that Darkseid is out of Thanos's league in general.
And if I win, Darkseid will get even more props and people will see that Darkseid is out of Thanos's league in general.
Either way, I win. evillaugh
just becuz darkseid is a skyfather doesnt mean hes greater than thanos. not at all. that logic makes no sense. thanos>darkseid.
odin would crush ds. he oneshots people like silver surfer. ds cannot defeat superman all the time. let alone surfer has no prayer but superman has crushed ds before. see the diff.
😛
Originally posted by King_Mungigds feats have never counted unless specifically referring to gds darkseid.
To me using alternate reality showings of characters is dumb, when I was told that I could ude that for a character I basically lost all interest in the battle zone. However, if that's the rules people agreed with so be it.
but this battlezone i guess u make ur own rules and agree to them. works for me.
I'm not talking specifically about alternate reality showings of Darkseid or Thanos, but in general.
I was tempted to use Talisman for the battle zone, but one alternate reality Talisman was so strong her and Dr.Strange took on Mephisto, Dormammu, Nightmare and their armies at the same time and won. How can you really debate with that? Some AR versions are simply stronger then their main universe counterparts or vice versa.
Originally posted by King_Mungii get what u are saying. its best just to stick with the mainstream versions but if u throw in a badass alternate version u can match them up with someone more powerful that they previously might not have had a chance against. feel me.
I'm not talking specifically about alternate reality showings of Darkseid or Thanos, but in general.I was tempted to use Talisman for the battle zone, but one alternate reality Talisman was so strong her and Dr.Strange took on Mephisto, Dormammu, Nightmare and their armies at the same time and won. How can you really debate with that? Some AR versions are simply stronger then their main universe counterparts.
Originally posted by King_Mungi
I'm not talking specifically about alternate reality showings of Darkseid or Thanos, but in general.I was tempted to use Talisman for the battle zone, but one alternate reality Talisman was so strong her and Dr.Strange took on Mephisto, Dormammu, Nightmare and their armies at the same time and won. How can you really debate with that? Some AR versions are simply stronger then their main universe counterparts or vice versa.
but from my understanding, you and whoever you debate set the rules on what you can and cannot use
also, depending on the character, it might be reasonable to use all versions for some and completely ludicrous for others
Originally posted by masterbrucegood point. thats why when u decide on the rules really think it through cuz chances are the other guy is trying to screw u over. damn tricky internet people.
but from my understanding, you and whoever you debate set the rules on what you can and cannot usealso, depending on the character, it might be reasonable to use all versions for some and completely ludicrous for others
Originally posted by quanchi112
i get what u are saying. its best just to stick with the mainstream versions but if u throw in a badass alternate version u can match them up with someone more powerful that they previously might not have had a chance against. feel me.
I understand, but if your using the badass alternate version then I feel you should stick with just that version as it's basically a different character all together.
However, if the people agree on the rules and let basically a free for all in showings then it's their concern.
Originally posted by masterbruce
but from my understanding, you and whoever you debate set the rules on what you can and cannot usealso, depending on the character, it might be reasonable to use all versions for some and completely ludicrous for others
I know I said you can pick the rules, but the general rule for the battle zone is you could use AR feats and showings.
Originally posted by King_Mungii do agree that badass character is a different person altogether.
I understand, but if your using the badass alternate version then I feel you should stick with just that version as it's basically a different character all together.However, if the people agree on the rules and let basically a free for all in showings then it's their concern.
but yes whatever they decide on the rules let them debate based on those parameters. its their problem not ours. we get to sit back and enjoy the show. il tell u this much i want in this battle forum. eventually im sure ill be in there. if not who the hell cares right?
😆
Originally posted by King_MungiMy understanding was that you do just that. For instance, if you rep Superman, and you choose to rep KC Supes, then you have ONLY him for the match. Only KC showings count.
I understand, but if your using the badass alternate version then I feel you should stick with just that version as it's basically a different character all together.
The only differentiation is with Darkseid, because supposedly there is only one DS. With the exception of future timelines, there are no alternate reality DS's. It's all the same guy.
That's the argument.
Originally posted by SnazzySmurph
My understanding was that you do just that. For instance, if you rep Superman, and you choose to rep KC Supes, then you have ONLY him for the match. Only KC showings count.The only differentiation is with Darkseid, because supposedly there is only one DS. With the exception of future timelines, there are no alternate reality DS's. It's all the same guy.
That's the argument.
Co-sign.