Should the Mace/Sideous fight be redone?

Started by singe_1019 pages

Now now, hate leads to suffering.

Yeah Palpatine's so weak and unprepared that he created the Galactic Empire before being FOUND by the Jedi as the Sith lord.

Palpatine knows what is going on and what will happen. He can sense the future, as Yoda is asked to and Anakin can more on instinct. Palpatine has telepathy and influences others subconsciously, dreams and fear, etc.

How is Anakin going to culminate his turn to the dark side other than striking Windu? There aren't many better ways.

I think you miss the point that Palpatine does not see everything he can and has been suprised before. This has been proven in the films.

I might be wrong, true. But I think it was set up and if Yoda couldn't vanquish him then Mace couldn't.

stop sniffing paint, man.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
He got the first two by surprise. Kit Fisto was able to counter, but if you watch closely, he had little room to work with. Had they been in an open area, Kit would have lasted a bit longer.

That is such a lame assesment for defending bad direction and bad blocking. They came in with drawn lightsabres to arrest a SITH!!!!! If they can't 'mind their surroundings' they suck as Jedi.

Originally posted by queeq
That is such a lame assesment for defending bad direction and bad blocking. They came in with drawn lightsabres to arrest a SITH!!!!! If they can't 'mind their surroundings' they suck as Jedi.
sure, why not.

Which is sad for a character like Fisto. But then, Palpy showd us he sucks as a Jedi.

the office had one way in and one way out, what were the Jedi supposed to do, call to him from the next room? they HAD to enter through the narrow hallway, and when there were four of them in confined quarters, it limited their movements. Anyone with a grade school education can see that.

But any Jedi Master would know what to do expecting heavy opposition, even in a little space like that. These aren't grade schoolers. Look at OB1 and Anakin at the end of ROTS, they fight each other on two square feet of lava droid.

Originally posted by queeq
But any Jedi Master would know what to do expecting heavy opposition, even in a little space like that. These aren't grade schoolers. Look at OB1 and Anakin at the end of ROTS, they fight each other on two square feet of lava droid.
well, if you were there, would you expect Sidious to jump straight at you attacking? I would expect him to fight, yes, but what he did caught them totally off guard, even Mace.

how would you have filmed it? this should be fun.

Palpatine would have planned for the encounter so the narrow hallway was definitely designed with that in mind, had to be. As Rogue says sith choose their battlegrounds better than jedi.

BS. You're going to arrest the first Sith in a 1000 years, one you can't even detect with your Jedi senses. You'd better be prepared for something..

And how to film it? You'd be surprised. For one Sidious would have some major movements, he should definately look surperior. Now everything goes slow and the other Jedi just stand and watch until it's their turn to be shish kebabed. No one defends each other, they just stand there. Old Palpy moves around in the small crowded space like he's in a stadium, why can't the tree uberslow Jedi do that?

Besides, it's a movie. The director chooses a small space, he better makes it work.

Maybe when you make your own hit movie we might listen to you.

Originally posted by queeq
BS. You're going to arrest the first Sith in a 1000 years, one you can't even detect with your Jedi senses. You'd better be prepared for something..

And how to film it? You'd be surprised. For one Sidious would have some major movements, he should definately look surperior. Now everything goes slow and the other Jedi just stand and watch until it's their turn to be shish kebabed. No one defends each other, they just stand there. Old Palpy moves around in the small crowded space like he's in a stadium, why can't the tree uberslow Jedi do that?

Besides, it's a movie. The director chooses a small space, he better makes it work.

I'd have had the battle range from room to room, with Sidious retreating, lopping off body parts and using force lightning as he tried to escape, but then gets cornered by Mace.

I did.... so listen.

Originally posted by queeq
I did.... so listen.
you did what? listen to what?

Pay attention, Rogue

Originally posted by queeq
Pay attention, Rogue
well, I like the scenario I presented. makes for a much more entertaining fight.

Wow using your Mod ship to erase my posts because you can't take as good as you give.

I didn't erase anything. Are you imagining clever answers to my posts that aren't there?