Should the Mace/Sideous fight be redone?

If Lucas came out saying that he's going to re-release a special addition of Star Wars Episode III, but the Mace/Sideous fight would be enhanced.. maybe some actual stuntman involved, etc; would you object or prefer it the way it is now?

What movie did you watch? Ian had a stunman and it was actually fairly obvious I thought. 😐

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
If Lucas came out saying that he's going to re-release a special addition of Star Wars Episode III, but the Mace/Sideous fight would be enhanced.. maybe some actual stuntman involved, etc; would you object or prefer it the way it is now?

already was a stuntman with ian mcdiarmid's face digitally graphed on....very poorly. im sure he would be flattered, however, that you would mistake such an old man for being so limber.

That fight was a black hole of suck. Yes, I'd deeply enjoy if they reshot it. McD' and Jackson (to a lesser extent) had no business picking up a lightsaber and dueling so damn slowly.

I think Palpatine should hav used force hurrigane and Mace could hav blocked it with his force static-defence. Now how cool would that look! =O.

There would be stuff flying everywhere! =O

I would watch it...but I think I can live with it the way it is.

Yes, for sure, and Ian did at least some of the fighting himself, GL had him do it so he could get some good close-up shots of his face. But the duel sucked, Mace is like as good as Yoda with a blade, as is Palpatine, and they were moving really slow.

And the other three Jedi sucked big time. A toddler could have taken them out.

I agree Kit "Fisted severely by a dish-gloveless Palpatine" Fisto was the worst offender.

Some of those CGI mask shots REALLY need to be done.

They stood out like an ESB asteroid slug in a small bowl of cereal, and made the audience feel less comfortable than a party full of people who have to witness Luke and Leia getting WAY too drunk and getting off with each other at the annual Jedi picnics....

That fight ended exactly as it should have ended. Absolutely no need to re shot anything

Who was talking about the ending? It was the beginning that sucked big time.

The beginning was rather rediculous.

Exactly.

Mace and Palpatine should have gone faster. More offensive force maneuvers as well.

Probably the WORST scene in SW EVER!
Woeful acting,poor fx match ups and a wasted opportunity.
"HES THE TRAITOR!!! "
Jesus

Originally posted by General G
The beginning was rather rediculous.

I liked now the beginning of the fight started.

The beginning was ridiculous, but I have no issue with the rest of the fight.

Not even with Palpy's funny faces?

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
If Lucas came out saying that he's going to re-release a special addition of Star Wars Episode III, but the Mace/Sideous fight would be enhanced.. maybe some actual stuntman involved, etc; would you object or prefer it the way it is now?

It was two masters going at it, pitting their skills at swordsmanship against each other.

And they both dueled worse then that little toddler kid who took out like 5 troopers before he died during Order 66.

What's your point, silly goose?