mavel ares vs wolverine

Started by Creshosk11 pages
Creshosk Senior Member

Originally posted by K-Dog
Wolverine should get his limbs ripped off (ligaments hold the limbs on, not adamantium or bone)
In this case Comics overrides real world anatomy. Wolverine has had his flesh burned off down to the bone and remained in tact on many occasions. People have tried to cut between the bones and failed. Hulk in 616 even tried to pull his arms off and failed.

The mainstream 616 Wolverine is held together even without ligaments. So unless Ares can break adamantium, this tactic is a waste of time and since it brings wolverine in close, might not be such a good idea.

Battlehammer Senior Member
Originally posted by lando005
it's not about the weight not at all if you do not apply what i've said then yes one hit from even a class 10 would send bricks like hulk flying so obviously weight has nothing to do with the matter. What i've said is the truth and fundamentals of both physics and basic combat even a novice fighter knows that, but let me turn this around on you cap, if my theory is wrong like you think then what keeps them in place you say it's weight so prove it

..............It comics.

Your logic is awful. Your trying to use some real world logic and not other in order to prove your point.

Your whole point controdicts comics and real world logic.

weight would be the defining factor if some flew away when hit with 100 ton force in the real world

Now in the comic world it does not matter. Durability, weight what ever have nothing to do with it.

so to say Logan would go flying away is rediculous when he majority of times he goes no ware and at best 20 feet.

lando005 Senior Member

Originally posted by Battlehammer
..............It comics.

Your logic is awful. Your trying to use some real world logic and not other in order to prove your point.

Your whole point controdicts comics and real world logic.

weight would be the defining factor if some flew away when hit with 100 ton force in the real world

Now in the comic world it does not matter. Durability, weight what ever have nothing to do with it.

so to say Logan would go flying away is rediculous when he majority of times he goes no ware and at best 20 feet.

first off can you not put soo much space between your sentences there doesn't seem to be a need for it. Secondly my logic is not flawed. Yes not all real world rules apply to comics but some more basic principals do. the writters tend to try to keep within the parameters of actual logic and use it as a bas starting point and only stray from that with the more exotic things that you only would find in a comic like a 6' 5'' 600lb man picking up a 6 story building, but the more base things like what i have been describing is a part of comic logic as well. The writers have no need to be elaborate and make things up with this the dynamics are already there so why both to make false logic when actual logic would do just fine in that instance. In other words things like fights with heavy hitters while taken to a great degree can still be explained within the boundaries of real world logic so the dont have to use the "just cause" rule. If there's no possible way to explain it that's when comic rules take over. So before you go bashing my logic again please come up with some of your own other than "it's a comic" because that trick just wont work this time.

lando005 Senior Member

just cause i saw the other one up.... bump