Thanos vs Thor and Superman

Originally posted by Larceny
But not to your previous statement.

Which is canon and acceptable as evidence. Luckily they fought more than once in the series. 🙂

A full bore Thor vs some characters that seemed to be holding back. Plus, I guess Thor can one-shot Surfer... which is horrible garbage. 🙂

It doesn't matter if they fought more than once... if the whole series is poorly written towards Thor and his power, then it's irrelevant to how many times they fought. 🙂

Anyway, you're going to turn this into Thor vs Surfer, I can see, so I'll just stick to Thanos beating Thor like a little pansy. 🙂

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Everyone Jobbered in that series but Thanos. And Thanos really jobbered himself when he could have just shut THor's mind down.

Apparently not... if you read the comic. 🙂 Not even Odin could beat Thor's mind. 🙂

Originally posted by Larceny
But not to your previous statement.

Which is canon and acceptable as evidence. Luckily they fought more than once in the series. 🙂

Hulk > Thor.

Shall we be accepting that as the norm too?

Originally posted by Ouallada
Hulk > Thor.

Shall we be accepting that as the norm too?

Nope because Hulk doesn't have more wins against Thor than Thor does against Hulk. That and the fact that Thor has never stated or admitted to Hulk being his superior.

Originally posted by Larceny
Nope because Hulk doesn't have more wins against Thor than Thor does against Hulk. That and the fact that Thor has never stated or admitted to Hulk being his superior.

Actually, the Hulk does have more wins against Thor than the other way round'.

Thor #385, Heroes Reborn, two wins in the Hulk 2001 Annual, Mindless Hulk was getting the upper hand in Hulk #300, and so on.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
No, it's irrelevant to everything I've said, because I was specifically talking about Thor losing to Thanos more than any other character. 🙂

A full bore Thor vs some characters that seemed to be holding back. Plus, I guess Thor can one-shot Surfer... which is horrible garbage. 🙂

It doesn't matter if they fought more than once... if the whole series is poorly written towards Thor and his power, then it's irrelevant to how many times they fought. 🙂

Anyway, you're going to turn this into Thor vs Surfer, I can see, so I'll just stick to Thanos beating Thor like a little pansy. 🙂

Which had relation to you're point that Thor had no business in the thread along side Surfer. I could be wrong, but thats what it sounded like.

Surfer wasn't holding back, as he specifically stated before getting beasted.

It actually is, because if I recall correctly the series was never retconned out of continuity which would make the evidence valid in debate.

Nope, just saying Thor has as much right in this thread as Surfer. The Thor vs. Surfer debate is already taking place in the "Can Thor beast these two characters" thread.

Thats fine. 🙂

Originally posted by Red Shift
Actually, the Hulk does have more wins against Thor than the other way round'.

Thor #385, Heroes Reborn, two wins in the Hulk 2001 Annual, Mindless Hulk was getting the upper hand in Hulk #300, and so on.

He actually doesn't, however Hulk has no relevance to this thread, thus he won't be talked about. 🙂

He's plenty relevant considering YOU brought him up in the first place.

Feel free to squirm out of what you said, though.

Originally posted by Red Shift
Actually, the Hulk does have more wins against Thor than the other way round'.

Thor #385, Heroes Reborn, two wins in the Hulk 2001 Annual, Mindless Hulk was getting the upper hand in Hulk #300, and so on.

Alternate universe.

One was when he threw him into the mountain. The other was a giant cheapshot (I can't see how anyone can count that as a win).

Mindless Hulk was getting punched around the entire time... how is that gaining the upper hand?

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
First I'm reporting you, secondly, He was refering another thread. And Bias doesn't always have to come in the form of a company bias.

Do you seriously act like a little kid every time someone offends you?

Originally posted by Ouallada
And against hulk as well.

Doesn't look like Larceny to me. 🙂

Feel free to squirm out of what you said though. 😉

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Without hammer, but that's the only reasonable win you've named.

Alternate universe.

One was when he threw him into the mountain. The other was a giant cheapshot (I can't see how anyone can count that as a win).

Mindless Hulk was getting punched around the entire time... how is that gaining the upper hand?

Er, yes. He punched him into a mountain, he was buried. Fight over.

At the time the Thor/Hulk fight left off, Hulk picked up a weapon Thor said was capable of killing him. Not to mention at that point the Hulk had already fought through and several a dozen something heroes.

Alternate universe?

616 Hulk. "Alternate" Thor created by Franklin Richards.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Everyone jobbed to Thor, I can't see how the PG can put Thor in Thanos's league, IMHO. 😬 Especially since a PG user in that series was punked bad by normal Thor, along with other heroes.

Apparently not... if you read the comic. 🙂 Not even Odin could beat Thor's mind. 🙂

Originally posted by Larceny
Nope because Hulk doesn't have more wins against Thor than Thor does against Hulk. That and the fact that Thor has never stated or admitted to Hulk being his superior.

I count 2 wins for the hulk, and none for regular Thor. Thor has only won as King Thor and in a What If as I can remember. Other posters have already given instances of their battles.

As for why he was brought up, Hulk is obviously > Thor, despite what their on-panel fights say. That logic certainly has a habit of turning around and biting you when claiming that SS < Thor simply based on on-panel battles without taking context into consideration, does it not?

Originally posted by Larceny
Which had relation to you're point that Thor had no business in the thread along side Surfer. I could be wrong, but thats what it sounded like.

Surfer wasn't holding back, as he specifically stated before getting beasted.

It actually is, because if I recall correctly the series was never retconned out of continuity which would make the evidence valid in debate.

Nope, just saying Thor has as much right in this thread as Surfer. The Thor vs. Surfer debate is already taking place in the "Can Thor beast these two characters" thread.

Thats fine. 🙂

So is Mantis one-shotting Thor, as is Thor getting taken out by a handgun. 🙂

Thor is in this thread. Surfer isn't. Thor is fighting Thanos. Surfer isn't.
Thanos is in this thread. Surfer isn't. Thanos is fighting Thor and Superman. Surfer isn't. 🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes its quite simple that Thor was more powerful than anyone else he faced in combat except Thanos. Nver doesnt want to acknowledge that maybe Thanos is that powerful when hes proven it time and time again.

He was beating Thanos as well....

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes its quite simple that Thor was more powerful than anyone else he faced in combat except Thanos. Nver doesnt want to acknowledge that maybe Thanos is that powerful when hes proven it time and time again.

What?

Ultimus has one shotted Thor. Twice.

Hulk's beaten him more than once.

Mangog's beaten him.

Originally posted by Larceny
He was beating Thanos as well....

Hahaha, Thor was beating Thanos?

When where who what?

Originally posted by Larceny
He was beating Thanos as well....

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes its quite simple that Thor was more powerful than anyone else he faced in combat except Thanos. Nver doesnt want to acknowledge that maybe Thanos is that powerful when hes proven it time and time again.

DO not mention my screen name when I'm not talking to you or about you. I dont' care if thanos is how ever powerful. Everyone jobbers to thanos period. Even odin and tyrant jobbered to thanos.