Silver Surfer's Blast vs Superman's punch

Started by carver913 pages
Originally posted by Delta1938
Stop Abhi. Knowing that would require reading the series!!

With that said, I'm sure you have that scan where it says he didn't read the final pages. Since you read the story and all. Also, it doesn't matter where the book was read from, if the pages are infinite then no source should be able to read until the FINAL chapter aka last page.

Lol.

Let me ask you this.

Are you applying real world logic to comics now? Cuz las time you said, you couldn't apply real world logic to comics.

So what is it now?

Apply real world logic or not? Make up your mind.

Or are you going to keep flip flopping, just to suit your argument?

How much are you willing to pay for sex with the famous Carvdingo, salsa?

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
How much are you willing to pay for sex with the famous Carvdingo, salsa?

Hahahaha, ewwwwww! nothing I'll pass. You pimp!

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Lol.

Let me ask you this.

Are you applying real world logic to comics now? Cuz las time you said, you couldn't apply real world logic to comics.

So what is it now?

Apply real world logic or not? Make up your mind.

Or are you going to keep flip flopping, just to suit your argument?

So if I ran into a bunch of ants called infinite ants but I was able to step on every last of those ants leaving nothing but one, what do we take into consideration here, the name of the ants or the fact that there is only one still standing.

Answer the damn question double standards

Apply real world logic or not?

I think real world logic actually has to be used, but only up until a certain point. So for instance if a character has a feat and is said to be going 5 times the speed of sound, we are using "real world" logic to determine the speed in a way, right? Just like how we know lightspeed is fast because in the real world it is fast.

You just don't go overboard. Like saying Superman can't fly because it doesn't make any sense. Or in a sense trying to say someone else's powers would realistically kill them or injure them when they used them, etc.

Originally posted by Surtur
I think real world logic actually has to be used, but only up until a certain point. So for instance if a character has a feat and is said to be going 5 times the speed of sound, we are using "real world" logic to determine the speed in a way, right? Just like how we know lightspeed is fast because in the real world it is fast.

You just don't go overboard. Like saying Superman can't fly because it doesn't make any sense. Or in a sense trying to say someone else's powers would realistically kill them or injure them when they used them, etc.

Exactly. It depends entirely on the situation. Example, here Galactus is going all out trying to take out Tenebrous and the planet is still intact. Hell, the ground they are fighting on doesn't have a dent.

But yet Surfer and Morg fight destroys planets and moons.

http://i.imgur.com/704Tkq2.jpg

If we used real world logic, which fight displayed more power? And which characters would you deem as more powerful?

So...we SHOULDN'T use real world logic?

So...if the scan says infinite pages, we take it at face value?

Carverbot, is your programming faulty?

Originally posted by carver9
Exactly. It depends entirely on the situation. Example, here Galactus is going all out trying to take out Tenebrous and the planet is still intact. Hell, the ground they are fighting on doesn't have a dent.

But yet Surfer and Morg fight destroys planets and moons.

http://i.imgur.com/704Tkq2.jpg

If we used real world logic, which fight displayed more power? And which characters would you deem as more powerful?


That's why space cheese is meaningless. Creating black holes? Destroying planets? Who the **** cares?

Only fight with characters is indicative of power. Surfer can destroy a galaxy and will still get smacked around by Thor. That's just how comics work.

Energy discharge enough to make a black hole or vape a planet without even fully charged is far more than supes can do in 1 punch....

Funny how carver can't answer a simple question.

According to him only use real world logic when it suits your own argument otherwise use double standards 👆

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So...we SHOULDN'T use real world logic?

So...if the scan says infinite pages, we take it at face value?

Carverbot, is your programming faulty?

😐 read everything that has been said here, not my last post. All of it please.

Originally posted by Genii96
Energy discharge enough to make a black hole or vape a planet without even fully charged is far more than supes can do in 1 punch....

Exactly.

Originally posted by Genii96
Energy discharge enough to make a black hole or vape a planet without even fully charged is far more than supes can do in 1 punch....
Originally posted by Surtur
Exactly.

Punching so hard that it destroys the barriers of space and time or punching your way out of source wall is more than Surfer can ever hope to do.

Exactly.

Originally posted by abhilegend
That's why space cheese is meaningless. Creating black holes? Destroying planets? Who the **** cares?

Only fight with characters is indicative of power. Surfer can destroy a galaxy and will still get smacked around by Thor. That's just how comics work.

Right on point. There's a time to use real world logic and then there's a time we use common sense. Surfer has created Black Holes on a whim and even with that, given the chance, Superman, Thor and Hulk would punch his face clean off.

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Funny how carver can't answer a simple question.

According to him only use real world logic when it suits your own argument otherwise use double standards 👆

Originally posted by abhilegend
Punching so hard that it destroys the barriers of space and time

Provided you have a villain mucking with with space time and multiple realities.

Originally posted by abhilegend

or punching your way out of source wall

Provided you have a staff of "unimaginable power" made from the source to help pull you out.

Still better than surfer's feat. Imo

Originally posted by carver9
So if I ran into a bunch of ants called infinite ants but I was able to step on every last of those ants leaving nothing but one, what do we take into consideration here, the name of the ants or the fact that there is only one still standing.

Go back to work, Carvdingo.

I don't pay you for online posting on comic book forums, ffs. San Francisco glory hole awaits.