galactus/darksied vs inbetweener/phoenix

Originally posted by LordKaos

The shattering was a result of the Shi'ar weapon,

not what Xorn did.

False.

Xorn killed Jean and shattered the Phoenix Force itself into Billions of pieces:

......................................................................................

(From the Official Marvel Universe Handbook 2005 - PF - bio)

"Jean Grey was Killed by an Electromagnetic Pulse,

this shattered the Force into Billions of PIECES"

......................................................................................

(From the X-Men - Messiah Complex - Mutant Files 2008 - PF - (Jean) bio)

"Jean opposed the faux Magneto but was seemingly killed by a lethal EMP,
that shattered the Phoenix Force into Billions of pieces"

......................................................................................

Originally posted by LordKaos

The Phoenix was not shattered until Endsong.

False.

The very first page, of the very first issue of Endsong
is where the PF is recounting being obliterated into billions of pieces by Xorn:

So how you figure it happened in that issue?

Originally posted by LordKaos

There was no mention of having to find her pieces during HCT
which was caused by Xorn killing Jean Grey.
She was whole at the end of HCT as White Phoenix

That's because HCT took place 150 Years in the Future. (in an alternate reality)

HCT isn't even acknowledge as EVER happening in 616 Jean's Bio.

Originally posted by LordKaos

then the Shi'ar caused a force resurrection
which was responsible for the shattering not the stroke.

Actually they not only forced the PF's resurrection,
but they also shattered the PF itself into pieces partially due to the "Event Horizon"
as Tenebrous pointed out.

So canonically, the PF has been shattered TWICE!

Into Billions of pieces by an EMP at the hands of Xorn.

By a Shiar device as well.

......................................................................................

On Panel proof:

Here's the PF again, being shattered, this time by the Shiar:

In fact, Jean Grey was STILL DEAD, since Xorn's EMP!

Here's the Shiar at the end of the issue,
explaining the "Eleka'an Event Horizon" they used on the PF.
The PF survived by escaping at the last moment,
but it was still injured, dying, meh, literally shattered AGAIN!

......................................................................................

Bio confirmation of said on panel proof:

"The Force was later ripped back to reality by a Shiar device
that forcibly reconstituted it. Injured, the Force fell ....
searched for Jean and, finding her DEAD, resurrected her ..."