ROTS Obi-wan VS ROTS Mace Windu (FORCE FIGHT ONLY)

Started by Darth_noodle3 pages

ROTS Obi-wan VS ROTS Mace Windu (FORCE FIGHT ONLY)

ROTS kenobi vs ROTS windu, force fight only, no saber combat.
Who would win?

Mace would crush Obi-Wan. He's leaps and bounds ahead of Obi-Wan at this point. You should read Shatterpoint; it's pretty amazing what he can do.

Hmm, i always thought ROTS Kenobi, ROTS Windu, and ROTS Anakin were equally good with the Force. So Windu is stronger in the force than Kenobi and Anakin at the time of ROTS?

By far. Older and more experienced. He's more on Dooku's level than anything.

Yes. Mace outclasses Obi in every way

k. I just watched the clone wars cartoon, can mace really do what he did with the army of super battle droids? It was pretty amazing 🙂

No the cartoon exaggerates the powers of most of the Jedi/Sith by a large amount.

And Mace wins this, maybe it's just be but I always thought Kenobi was closer to Mace with a blade than he was with the Force. Though Mace would take the saber duel as well.

No the cartoon exaggerates the powers of most of the Jedi/Sith by a large amount.

Actually, according to Lucas, this is what he had in mind for real Jedi and Sith.

There is no clear cut answer, they both are good at diffent techniques. eg obi wan is good at force push, as you see him bouncing GG off the wall like a basketball in ROTS. but mace is a master of force crush as you see him crushing GG like a soda can in CW. so they could be there all day, throwing the force at eachother untill one of them get tired and passes out. but ay theres the rub, both of them mostly channel thier force mastery through thier blades, whether its, mace submerged into vaapad or obi wan, staying in the eye of the storm. but i have seen mace do more awesome feats without his sword such as crushing the droids. however, obi wan is seen as more resourceful if you saw how he impaled that praying mantis-lizard thing on geonosis, or how he killed GG without the blade. so my conclusion is this: if they fight in a bare enviroment 8/10 mace's way but in a crowded enviroment, ostacle course type area 7/10 obi wans way. thats my answer.

There is no clear cut answer,they both are good at diffent techniques. eg obi wan is good at force push, as you see him bouncing GG off the wall like a basketball in ROTS. but mace is a master of force crush as you see him crushing GG like a soda can in CW. so they could be there all day, throwing the force at eachother untill one of them get tired and passes out. but ay theres the rub, both of them mostly channel thier force mastery through thier blades, whether its, mace submerged into vaapad or obi wan, staying in the eye of the storm. but i have seen mace do more awesome feats without his sword such as crushing the droids. however, obi wan is seen as more resourceful if you saw how he impaled that praying mantis-lizard thing on geonosis, or how he killed GG without the blade. so my conclusion is this: if they fight in a bare enviroment 8/10 mace's way but in a crowded enviroment, ostacle course type area 7/10 obi wans way. thats my answer.
Putting this as nicely as possible: no. Mace absolutely obliterates Obi-Wan in any setting, end of story.

Except having an awesome goatee

Originally posted by Faunus
Putting this as nicely as possible: no. Mace absolutely obliterates Obi-Wan in any setting, end of story.

warrant this

Originally posted by Gideon
Actually, according to Lucas, this is what he had in mind for real Jedi and Sith.

Where did he say this? Is it in the DVD commentary or something?

This is a close Mace, in the cartoons and Shatterpoint has shown great force powers, but in the Movies, esepecially ROTS Kenobi showed how powerful he was. Mace is superior to Kenobi is sabers, but in overall force power its very close. If you take the saber out of Mace's hand, I would take Kenobi in this fight though.

Originally posted by kiddo44
This is a close Mace, in the cartoons and Shatterpoint has shown great force powers, but in the Movies, esepecially ROTS Kenobi showed how powerful he was. Mace is superior to Kenobi is sabers, but in overall force power its very close. If you take the saber out of Mace's hand, I would take Kenobi in this fight though.

Someone has reached a particular level of high with his substance abuse. Kenobi hasn't compared to Windu at all in any category, other than lightsaber defense.

Where did he say this? Is it in the DVD commentary or something?

According to Nai, the Clone Wars DVD commentary.

Originally posted by Man of Christ
warrant this
You mean "substantiate" it? I shouldn't have to.

Originally posted by Faunus
You mean "substantiate" it? I shouldn't have to.

becuase???????????? what you can just make sweeping claims with no logic to back them up?

Why? You don't want people to cut in on your non-logical monopoly?

haermm

Originally posted by Janus Marius
Why? You don't want people to cut in on your non-logical monopoly?

what?