Originally posted by Silent Master
My argument is that the comic doesn't say he is going all out, Though I do find it funny how people keep trying to shift the topic by going off on tangents and acting like it's the other person's job to disprove speculation.
Normally, you should bring something to your argument.
Until you bring something that prove that Odin wasn't all out, you are wrong.
Originally posted by Bouboumaster
Normally, you should bring something to your argument.Until you bring something that prove that Odin wasn't all out, you are wrong.
My argument is that the comic never stated he was going all out, therefore my proof is the comic itself. BTW, even you have admitted that the comic never said he was going all out.
Silent you never answered my question. Show me a comic where Odin said he was going all out giving it all his might. Find me the comic where he's fighting someone and says this and then you have a valid argument. If you can't by him saying he's trying to kill Thanos, the destruction the fight caused to Asgard and him pulling out his spear I think it's pretty safe to say he was bloodlusted and giving it all or pretty close to call his might
Originally posted by KuRuPT ThanosiHe wont answer any questions,but will troll to no end ranting and raving about Odin holding back when the comic tells us differently.
Silent you never answered my question. Show me a comic where Odin said he was going all out giving it all his might. Find me the comic where he's fighting someone and says this and then you have a valid argument. If you can't by him saying he's trying to kill Thanos, the destruction the fight caused to Asgard and him pulling out his spear I think it's pretty safe to say he was bloodlusted and giving it all or pretty close to call his might
Originally posted by skyfather
so do you think odin set out not to harm thanos.
Why must it either be Odin was "going all out" or "not trying to harm"?
Originally posted by quanchi112
Have there been any comics concerning Odin, that have stated that he was going all out?
What does that have to do with the topic at hand?
Originally posted by Silent MasterBecause you stated that as your only reason. It would seem a bit silly to me to state that as your only reason,when Odin has never been stated as going all out before. Dont you think?
Why must it either be Odin was "going all out" or "not trying to harm"?What does that have to do with the topic at hand?
So,I guess you have nothing in the actual comic to support you at all.
Wrong because ths is implying he does do so and therefore since it didn't specifically state he was like previous times he wasn't. You see your conclusion assumes he has stated so otherwise yet you can prove no such thing. Wouldn't the more logical assumption be that since he doesn't EVER say such a thing therefore in this fight he wouldn't as well? That is the more reasonable assumption. Your is well he didn't say it so therefore it's not possible even though you have no evidence supporting that premise and conclusion that he usually does. It's quite simple and the more you argue that it has no relevance the more you look like silly
Originally posted by quanchi112
Because you stated that as your only reason. It would seem a bit silly to me to state that as your only reason,when Odin has never been stated as going all out before. Dont you think?So,I guess you have nothing in the actual comic to support you at all.
That doesn't mean that Odin wasn't trying his damnedest because that much was obvious from the dialog, but actually unloading with everything they have is a rarity for pretty much any character because it leaves them completely spent afterwards(see Sentry/WWH). As someone already pointed out, there are more options available than "Odin was toying with him" and "Odin unloaded with everything he had". Odin was unable to put down Thanos despite his best efforts(that much is true), but the fact that both were still standing and ready to go at it again means that they both still had some power left in them.