Thor vs Superman

Started by Batman-Prime453 pages

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Superman ends up hearing E-2 scream Lois' name which brings him to Earth-2. E-2 snaps and starts to beat down Superman, claiming he killed his wife. Diana shows up and puts an end to the fight. During their actual fight, Metropolis is reduced to rubble and because the fight is restricted to outside the Daily Star, one could argue that they didn't even wreck the entire city.

Meanwhile Luthor is trying to mix and merge entire worlds.

In no way did Superman wreck the entire planet of Earth-2 with his breif scuffle with E-2 Superman.

The whole fight didn't happened in the IC. They fought some issues in the regular Superman comics.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
Not what happned in the first BRB Thor fight but i give up on trying to correct you 😛

You can use anything from a Handbook since it is a non-cannon source of information you can bring a MOD in on this one if you would like. And es cannon does me it is valid thus the terms cannon or non-cannon 🙁

Handbook writers consult the original or current writers when making the handbooks. Yes there are errors but most of it is true and can be used for evidence. The bios and summaries are nearly 100% true.

I'll bring a mod in then.

Originally posted by h1a8
Handbook writers consult the original or current writers when making the handbooks. Yes there are errors but most of it is true and can be used for evidence. The bios and summaries are nearly 100% true.
You'll lose this battle. You don't even know how it works around here and you've been here for years.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Superman ends up hearing E-2 scream Lois' name which brings him to Earth-2. E-2 snaps and starts to beat down Superman, claiming he killed his wife. Diana shows up and puts an end to the fight. During their actual fight, Metropolis is reduced to rubble and because the fight is restricted to outside the Daily Star, one could argue that they didn't even wreck the entire city.

Meanwhile Luthor is trying to mix and merge entire worlds.

In no way did Superman wreck the entire planet of Earth-2 with his breif scuffle with E-2 Superman.

when you go by statements they say their punches send them through both realities though.

Originally posted by h1a8
Handbook writers consult the original or current writers when making the handbooks. Yes there are errors but most of it is true and can be used for evidence. The bios and summaries are nearly 100% true.

You are correct, as I know Scott Vandal one of the handbook writers and he tells me he contacts past writers to make sure they get things correct. Also yes, the information can have errors but most of the time their pretty accurate but still should be validated to what is said in the actual comics. As here we take what the comics say over the handbooks

Its the powerlevel bars, which should be completly disregarded

Originally posted by -K-M-
You are correct, as I know Scott Vandal one of the handbook writers and he tells me he contacts past writers to make sure they get things correct. Also yes, the information can have errors but most of the time their pretty accurate but still should be validated to what is said in the actual comics. As here we take what the comics say over the handbooks

Its the powerlevel bars, which should be completly disregarded


In this case, it's in relation to the description of Thanos' powers. The old version of the powerbars.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
In this case, it's in relation to the description of Thanos' powers. The old version of the powerbars.

Disregarded then, as most of those are up for interpretation and are often filled with more errors then the bios.

Originally posted by -K-M-
Disregarded then, as most of those are up for interpretation and are often filled with more errors then the bios.

Yeah. Sometimes the bios can actually be used to validate uncertainties when it comes to whether or not a story is canon. I usually scoff at the power levels.

Originally posted by -K-M-

Its the powerlevel bars, which should be completly disregarded

they shouldn't be completely disregarded. they're useful indication of generally where a character stands.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Superman ends up hearing E-2 scream Lois' name which brings him to Earth-2. E-2 snaps and starts to beat down Superman, claiming he killed his wife. Diana shows up and puts an end to the fight. During their actual fight, Metropolis is reduced to rubble and because the fight is restricted to outside the Daily Star, one could argue that they didn't even wreck the entire city.

Meanwhile Luthor is trying to mix and merge entire worlds.

In no way did Superman wreck the entire planet of Earth-2 with his breif scuffle with E-2 Superman.

LOL, Tracks and H1A8 dont even read these comics that they are bringing up; Terrible.

Originally posted by Trackz
- the difference is we've seen thanos take on all thse characters and beat them, so we know he's stronger.

-based on that one feat it wouldn't be wrong to assume the worldbreaker hhulk maybe stronger than most other mainstream heroes

-older version is very unorganized, but most of it is thor just beating other featless character, but with big titles, he'll beat gods and such but nothing impressive about the fight, we know he has impressive striking power, but i belive supermans is better, he just has more feats to back it up, in a comic maybe they would be even but based on feats superman has the better.

Now tracks and H1A8, I dont want to be putting this up for nothing. You asked for striking power and I'm going to give it to you BUT I want you to do the same thing for me. Show me some scans of some STRIKING POWER similar or better.

Here ya go.

Thor hits the ground so hard that it opens a dimension to helas gate.

http://s989.photobucket.com/albums/af17/RageOfOlympus/Thor/?action=view&current=BreaksIntoHell1.jpg
http://s989.photobucket.com/albums/af17/RageOfOlympus/Thor/?action=view&current=BreaksIntoHell2.jpg

H1A8, this is mainly for you since you asked for it but tracks, you can look at it also.

Thor destroying a moon with hits while fighting gardner.

http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/King%20Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsGardner9.jpg
http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/King%20Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsGardner8.jpg

You're turn.

Originally posted by carver9
Now tracks and H1A8, I dont want to be putting this up for nothing. You asked for striking power and I'm going to give it to you BUT I want you to do the same thing for me. Show me some scans of some STRIKING POWER similar or better.

Here ya go.

Thor hits the ground so hard that it opens a dimension to helas gate.

http://s989.photobucket.com/albums/af17/RageOfOlympus/Thor/?action=view&current=BreaksIntoHell1.jpg
http://s989.photobucket.com/albums/af17/RageOfOlympus/Thor/?action=view&current=BreaksIntoHell2.jpg

H1A8, this is mainly for you since you asked for it but tracks, you can look at it also.

Thor destroying a moon with hits while fighting gardner.

http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/King%20Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsGardner9.jpg
http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/King%20Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsGardner8.jpg

You're turn.

where's that moon thing from? issue number would be nice 🙂

Originally posted by gogogadgetgo
where's that moon thing from? issue number would be nice 🙂
Thor V2 issue#58

Originally posted by carver9
Now tracks and H1A8, I dont want to be putting this up for nothing. You asked for striking power and I'm going to give it to you BUT I want you to do the same thing for me. Show me some scans of some STRIKING POWER similar or better.

Here ya go.

Thor hits the ground so hard that it opens a dimension to helas gate.

http://s989.photobucket.com/albums/af17/RageOfOlympus/Thor/?action=view&current=BreaksIntoHell1.jpg
http://s989.photobucket.com/albums/af17/RageOfOlympus/Thor/?action=view&current=BreaksIntoHell2.jpg

H1A8, this is mainly for you since you asked for it but tracks, you can look at it also.

Thor destroying a moon with hits while fighting gardner.

http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/King%20Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsGardner9.jpg
http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/King%20Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsGardner8.jpg

You're turn.

Odinforce Thor..?
I don't believe that's current for him any longer.

Originally posted by Juntai
Odinforce Thor..?
I don't believe that's current for him any longer.
True Thro deosn't have the Odinpower any more however if your read the comic this is Thor when he just gained the Odinpower and didn't use it "didn't accept it or just plain didn't know he had i forgot which one as it has been a while. It is not until the end of the comic after the fight. That Thor realises he can use the Odinpower and then he recreates the moon using it. It was in the narrations this is explain. So no Odinpower when fighting on the moon

Originally posted by DarkOdin
True Thro deosn't have the Odinpower any more however if your read the comic this is Thor when he just gained the Odinpower and didn't use it "didn't accept it or just plain didn't know he had i forgot which one as it has been a while. It is not until the end of the comic after the fight. That Thor realises he can use the Odinpower and then he recreates the moon using it. It was in the narrations this is explain. So no Odinpower when fighting on the moon

So the Odinpower inside Thor doesn't boosts his stats "passively" without him realising it? Does he have to use the Odinpower knowingly to boost his stamina and his strength?

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
So the Odinpower inside Thor doesn't boosts his stats "passively" without him realising it? Does he have to use the Odinpower knowingly to boost his stamina and his strength?
Like i said you have to read the comic b/c Thor didn't except the fact that he had the Odinpower he couldn't tap into it the narration at the end discloses this. This is before the whole lord of asgard stuff. So yes if doesn increase stats but not here has Thor didn't have any access to it

Originally posted by Juntai
Odinforce Thor..?
I don't believe that's current for him any longer.

None of those are odin powered feats. In both the odin power wasnt even awakened so this feat was under his own power.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
So the Odinpower inside Thor doesn't boosts his stats "passively" without him realising it? Does he have to use the Odinpower knowingly to boost his stamina and his strength?
It's clear you don't read Thor.