i wished they coulda made the mustafar fight longer....

i believe episode 3 is 2nd best next to esb. i was kinda dissapointed a bit with the mustafar obiwan vs anakin battle. only beef i have with it it wasnt long enough. i was curious if anyone else agrees

It was long enough, I just wish they didnt use so many close ups of their face where we couldnt see the damn fight.

Originally posted by @st
It was long enough, I just wish they didnt use so many close ups of their face where we couldnt see the damn fight.

it coulda been longer

Originally posted by @st
It was long enough, I just wish they didnt use so many close ups of their face where we couldnt see the damn fight.

It was less about the fight and more about why they were fighting. The emotion was more important than choreography.

The fight scene was as it should've been and good

I wish the first half of that film existed as something more than shit.

Originally posted by P23
it coulda been longer

And more boring.

There was some more dialogue between obiwan and anakin that I wish were present, but other than that it was fine.

Originally posted by exanda kane
I wish the first half of that film existed as something more than shit.

It was fine for what it was. Remove those feckin' droids though. That random one which hovers by them while their balancing on the catwalk is so bloody annoying. I blame Alliance for pointing it out.

The Temple invasion should have been longer, in more detail. Actually show Vader killing Jedi, instead of implying that all he was good at was butchering kindergartners.

It lasted what it lasted.

It was a documentary after all.

1. ROTS kind of sucked.

2. No, the fight should not have been longer. Since half the damn movie was lightsaber fights anyway, the 15 minutes we spent on the Mustafar duel was way too long as it was, not to mention it was annoying to have it split up by the noobish Yoda v Sidious fight.

Originally posted by Tangible God
It was fine for what it was. Remove those feckin' droids though. That random one which hovers by them while their balancing on the catwalk is so bloody annoying. I blame Alliance for pointing it out.

😂

Originally posted by exanda kane
I wish the first half of that film existed as something more than shit.

So hatefull. 😐

All in all, however, The movie was good, and the fight was what it needed to be. The only real problem was the Yoda part cutting into the Anakin and Obiwan battle.

Originally posted by Kapton JAC
So hatefull. 😐

All in all, however, The movie was good, and the fight was what it needed to be. The only real problem was the Yoda part cutting into the Anakin and Obiwan battle.

That isn't a problem you t.i.t. Might hurt your delicate sensibilities, but when you consider that it is a film and not the mystical projections of your orgasmic-geek-EU-boy mentallity on 35mm, you're wrong.

I found it a problem. Separate the fights and maybe give Anakin and Obi-Wan some lines. The Yoda vs. Sidious was irritating, I always fast forward through it.

i wish the Yoda-sidous fight had been longer. which was actually more important? be honest.... if Obi-wan dies, and Yoda kills Sidious, its just a matter of time before vader dies too, there is no Galactic Empire, and everything gets put back to normal eventually. But obi wan beating vader obviously wasn't a good enough reason for the Jedi to stick around.

Vader living would have been a bigger threat in the long run. Even Sidious recognized that.

Originally posted by Tangible God
I found it a problem. Separate the fights and maybe give Anakin and Obi-Wan some lines. The Yoda vs. Sidious was irritating, I always fast forward through it.

No

Originally posted by exanda kane
No

I don't.