Black Panther vs. Batman: H2H Only

Started by shiv19 pages

Batman has a higher level of h2h training. His sparring partners are the best of the best in what they do
Who does the Black Panther sparr with?

Bump.

Originally posted by shiv
Batman has a higher level of h2h training. His sparring partners are the best of the best in what they do
Who does the Black Panther sparr with?

With ancient warriors who defeat uber doombots with spears apparently.

Bats.

Black Panther would take the slight majority here, 5.5 maybe 6 out of 10. Batman is more skilled, but Panther is physically superior across the board which should be more than enough to over compensate for the slight skill discrepancy.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Black Panther would take the slight majority here, 5.5 maybe 6 out of 10. Batman's is more skilled, but Panther is physically superior across the board which should be more than enough to over compensate for the slight skill discrepancy.

One of your better posts. I may agree with that.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Black Panther would take the slight majority here, 5.5 maybe 6 out of 10. Batman is more skilled, but Panther is physically superior across the board which should be more than enough to over compensate for the slight skill discrepancy.

I can agree with this.

Batman.

T'challa isn't physically superior, or more skilled.

Batman FTW

Originally posted by namorsubby
T'challa isn't physically superior, or more skilled.

Batman FTW

T'challa has Cap like status.

Batman.

Originally posted by Bentley
T'challa has Cap like status.
That's all it is though, assumed status. Certainly not backed by general feats

Seriously? Batman is the best hand to hand fighter in comics with no amps or powers or special abilities like Task Master. No one can beat him hand to hand without some sort of augmentation.

Originally posted by lightyeargee
Seriously? Batman is the best hand to hand fighter in comics with no amps or powers or special abilities like Task Master. No one can beat him hand to hand without some sort of augmentation.

Except Batman ISN'T, not even in the top 10, other than that...

Originally posted by namorsubby
That's all it is though, assumed status. Certainly not backed by general feats

You think Panther has not enough feats to back up his enhanced status?

Originally posted by Bentley
Except Batman ISN'T, not even in the top 10, other than that...

You think Panther has not enough feats to back up his enhanced status?

I disagree. The only person I can see beating Batman Senseless is Karate Kid and that's because he has 1,000 more years of martial arts to draw from.

Originally posted by lightyeargee
I disagree. The only person I can see beating Batman Senseless is Karate Kid and that's because he has 1,000 more years of martial arts to draw from.

What about Mantis? She one-shotted Thor.

Originally posted by Bentley
What about Mantis? She one-shotted Thor.
She is augmented is she not? She certainly isn't human.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Black Panther would take the slight majority here, 5.5 maybe 6 out of 10. Batman is more skilled, but Panther is physically superior across the board which should be more than enough to over compensate for the slight skill discrepancy.
"slight skill discrepancy"? didn't you vote against T'Challa being in the same tier as Bruce? Or was it just that you had to choose between he and Psylocke? Anyhow, i think the difference in skill is a little more than slight.

Also, doesn't the OP stipulate no weapons? Shouldn't T'Challa have to fight without his suit? I don't know how that cannot be considered a (defensive) weapon. If that's the case and Bruce ditches his suit as well, i see Batman winning this at a 8-9/10 ratio.

Originally posted by Bentley
Except Batman ISN'T, not even in the top 10, other than that...

You think Panther has not enough feats to back up his enhanced status?

Batman could arguably be near the top, although everyone has th MA "blemishes" Bruce can at least contend and possibly take any non-uber like Temugin, Gamora, etc, IMO.

I don't T'challa has enough feats to support being Bruce's physical superior, but that's alright, no peak human does. Enhanced or Trained.

Oh, Batman can hang and compete, that's not in question. But people saying he's the best is far from the truth and quite naive.