Thanos & Darkseid Vs. All-Star Superman

Started by quanchi1128 pages

Originally posted by Sirius77
So according to the annihilation writer no one could replicate that feat? No one could rip Thanos' heart out except for Drax? Not Kronos? Not Galactus? Not Eternity? Not the LT? Not TOAA?
Galactus,Eternity, and TOAA dont punch peoples hearts out. The point is that the other two characters in this thread couldnt do it. Thats all you need to know.

Originally posted by Sirius77
So according to the annihilation writer no one could replicate that feat? No one could rip Thanos' heart out except for Drax? Not Kronos? Not Galactus? Not Eternity? Not the LT? Not TOAA?

Galan, Eternity, LT and TOAA all have hands that are too big to complete the ripping out of Thanos's heart. 😛

And no to Kronos.

AS Superman is way out of his league here.

Silver that naturally is lethal to a werewolf is one thing....as the werewolf stands a defensive fair chance to avoid silver by natural means.

A silverbullet that is created and come into existance for the sole reason of killing a werewolf is another thing all together...its an exploit.

Kryptonite is lethal to Superman. Naturally Superman can avoid Kryptonite by use of his xray vision, speed, flight etc.

A Superman clone that is genetically engineered by someone that is built from Kryptonite, and has an implanted desire to kill and hate Superman....is the same. An exploit.

This is what Drax is, an exploit to Thanos.

Thanos and Darkseid in a terrible stomp

Originally posted by quanchi112
Quans post starts here.

I dont make excuses I simply give you facts.

When your back is turned its called a cheapshot. No way around it.

Darkseid and Thanos both had their hearts removed but both had it done in different ways. One was cheapshotted while the other was just physically pwned.

Thanos hasnt been turned into stone since his upgrade. Warlocks ghost accomplished this and not his regular person. Completely different friend. 😛

Thanos had an upgrade and it was mentioned while you just assume Henshaw was upgraded. Big difference. 😄

No, you just need to keep making up excuses. Thanos knew what was going on. Hell, he knew that Drax was opening up his forcefield.

There is still nothing to suggest that Thanos became immune to a stone spell. That is you assuming my friend. Whether a dead man or a living man cast it makes no difference. 🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
Well we also have the writer explaining it. So its a fact. 😉

Great. Then we can assume Superman is above Galactus level from what Joe Casey explained of the OWAW storyline. 🙂

Stomp for the team. Thanos was cheapshotted. He put up the forcefields because he wanted to free galactus BEFORE he fought Drax. Stop ignoring what happened in the story avlon.

Originally posted by Avlon
Great. Then we can assume Superman is above Galactus level from what Joe Casey explained of the OWAW storyline. 🙂

The difference, of course, is that one is simply speculation, while the other is an explanation of the logic behind an on-panel happening.

Originally posted by Ouallada
The difference, of course, is that one is simply speculation, while the other is an explanation of the logic behind an on-panel happening.

Wrong since Casey stated that is the level he's in when in the probe busting mode.

Hey, Hulk and Sentry can whoop Odin's ass too since that is how powerful the writer claimed they were during their fight.

Originally posted by Avlon
Wrong since Casey stated that is the level he's in when in the probe busting mode.

Hey, Hulk and Sentry can whoop Odin's ass too since that is how powerful the writer claimed they were during their fight.

That IS speculation by default, because on-panel evidence says otherwise and as all discussion on power levels is, even by writers.

Drax's situation was different, because there was confusion over what happened on panel.

As for hulk and Sentry, talk on power levels is, once again, speculation. A writer explaining why the hulk reverted to Banner in that fight, if there was any confusion, is akin to the Drax situation, and is markedly different from the situation(s) you brought up. That would not be speculation.

Originally posted by Ouallada
That IS speculation by default, because on-panel evidence says otherwise and as all discussion on power levels is, even by writers.

Drax's situation was different, because there was confusion over what happened on panel.

As for hulk and Sentry, talk on power levels is, once again, speculation. A writer explaining why the hulk reverted to Banner in that fight, if there was any confusion, is akin to the Drax situation, and is markedly different from the situation(s) you brought up. That would not be speculation.

It's just as much speculation that a decent energy manipulator couldn't recreate the energy wielded by a low level being.

It's all writers opinion, regardless of how many want to argue semantics around it.

Originally posted by Avlon
It's just as much speculation that a decent energy manipulator couldn't recreate the energy wielded by a low level being.

It's all writers opinion, regardless of how many want to argue semantics around it.

The possibility of that situation being recreated by any existing being has only been speculated on these boards and similar boards. A writing team stating that Drax is a unique situation is not speculation. It is a statement saying that at said point in time, Drax was an anomaly, rather than the norm. Until I see evidence showing otherwise, I don't see how anyone can logically argue against that.

Originally posted by Ouallada
The possibility of that situation being recreated by any existing being has only been speculated on these boards and similar boards. A writing team stating that Drax is a unique situation is not speculation. It is a statement saying that at said point in time, Drax was an anomaly, rather than the norm. Until I see evidence showing otherwise, I don't see how anyone can logically argue against that.

And Superman's writer said that at the moment in time Superman channeled virtually limitless power. That is the reason's he was 1 shotting probes with ease. Hulk and Sentry were stated to be above Skyfather level.

It's all a writers opinion regardless on all ends. You take one, you take them all.

Originally posted by Avlon
No, you just need to keep making up excuses. Thanos knew what was going on. Hell, he knew that Drax was opening up his forcefield.

There is still nothing to suggest that Thanos became immune to a stone spell. That is you assuming my friend. Whether a dead man or a living man cast it makes no difference. 🙂

Quit ignoring the context. Thanos resisted reality warping and battles with a matter manipulator. Warlock only accomplished this as a ghost against the weakest Thanos we saw who was shocked he was back.

Oh and they stomp in this thread.

Originally posted by Avlon
Great. Then we can assume Superman is above Galactus level from what Joe Casey explained of the OWAW storyline. 🙂
Supes could hang with Imperiex but I have always though Galactus was greater than Imperiex so your theory doesnt fly.

Originally posted by moonknight11
Stomp for the team. Thanos was cheapshotted. He put up the forcefields because he wanted to free galactus BEFORE he fought Drax. Stop ignoring what happened in the story avlon.
QFT.

Originally posted by Ouallada
That IS speculation by default, because on-panel evidence says otherwise and as all discussion on power levels is, even by writers.

Drax's situation was different, because there was confusion over what happened on panel.

As for hulk and Sentry, talk on power levels is, once again, speculation. A writer explaining why the hulk reverted to Banner in that fight, if there was any confusion, is akin to the Drax situation, and is markedly different from the situation(s) you brought up. That would not be speculation.

Agreed.

Originally posted by Ouallada
The possibility of that situation being recreated by any existing being has only been speculated on these boards and similar boards. A writing team stating that Drax is a unique situation is not speculation. It is a statement saying that at said point in time, Drax was an anomaly, rather than the norm. Until I see evidence showing otherwise, I don't see how anyone can logically argue against that.
Exactly.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Quit ignoring the context. Thanos resisted reality warping and battles with a matter manipulator. Warlock only accomplished this as a ghost against the weakest Thanos we saw who was shocked he was back.

Big deal, so have Surfer and Superman. Thanos was one shotted by a stone spell. Killed. Embarrassed. Pwned. He lost. Get over it.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Oh and they stomp in this thread.

LOL...at attempting inflammatory comments. How Fanboish. 🙂

Originally posted by Avlon
And Superman's writer said that at the moment in time Superman channeled virtually limitless power. That is the reason's he was 1 shotting probes with ease. Hulk and Sentry were stated to be above Skyfather level.

It's all a writers opinion regardless on all ends. You take one, you take them all.

Virtually limitless power is not limitless power. 😐