Han Solo versus Captain Kirk.....

Fistfight. No weapons, at night in the swamps of Dagobah, knee deep in muck.....who wins?

Is there anyone around for Kirk to feel as though he needs to impress?
If not, then i say Solo.

What age group is Kirk in? Is he evenly matched with Han?

I'd say Kirk in the first Star Trek movie.

Han whips his ass.

Not because I'm a die hard Warsie, as opposed to Trekkie, but I just feel that Han has more experience, what with his being in the Imperial Navy, and being a space smuggler. After all, a smuggler has to have some degree of down & dirty skills. Just look what at what Han did to Greedo.

And, yes, Han DID fire first.

No Blasters!!! No Blasters!!! haermm

Yeah, Han takes this one easily.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I'd say Kirk in the first Star Trek movie.

If you have to gimp Kirk with older age, then Han wins/has the definite advantage.

Make them both in their prime, Kirk kicks the shit out of Solo, easily.

Kirk handled his own against Klingons, Vulcans, Gorns and a slew of other more powerful/larger foes. Solo relies on the wookie to fight his hand-to-hand battles.

Originally posted by Robtard
If you have to gimp Kirk with older age, then Han wins/has the definite advantage.

Make them both in their prime, Kirk kicks the shit out of Solo, easily.

Kirk handled his own against Klingons, Vulcans, Gorns and a slew of other more powerful/larger foes. Solo relies on the wookie to fight his hand-to-hand battles.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
do some research on Solo.

Has solo fought (and beat) aliens who were 2-4 times more physicaly powerful in a hand to hand duel? Done this consistantly?

Gimmee a sec, looking for it now.

"A sec" has an entirely different meaning to you, obviously.

😂 I had to sleep, man. I forget which novel it is, I think it is the trilogy of "Han Solos adventures", but there is a part where Boba Fett is recalling the first time he saw Solo ever.

Han was a prisoner and was pitted like against three or four beings of varying species, and he won.

i read a comic book where han ran away from a pissed off jedi once, whatever that is worth.

well, it IS a Jedi.....

A smuggler vs. a military soldier.

Kirk takes it.

Han has military training, he was a prosperous officer in the Imp navy, he just couldnt follow orders.

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
A smuggler vs. a military soldier.

Kirk takes it.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Han has military training, he was a prosperous officer in the Imp navy, he just couldnt follow orders.

True, but I think Kirk takes by a very slim margin.

Han, in my opinion, has the edge because, as a smuggler, he has to be more ruthless than Kirk, and, most likely, has fewer morals than a "do-gooder" like Kirk. Han would probably fight dirty.

Indeed....the circle that Han runs in, he is by far harder than Kirk.

"[Han Solo, as a teenager], fought against three other human fighters much larger than himself. Solo somehow managed to defeat the other gladiators in unarmed combat... "

Wookiepedia.

And that was before he joined the Empire and recieved military combat training. So... yeah.

I know nothing about Kirk though, so I'll withhold judgment.