Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Nope I was definitely remember you saying that all Jedi were as accurate with a lightsabre as Anakin,
That's not true. You're either lying on purpose or you have a bad memory. (I think you're just taking it out of context. I've definitely cleared it up since then, though, so there's no reason for you to take it out of context now.)
You posted this:
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Are they gonna WANNA remove webbing from their eyes ears nose etc with a lightsbare...? Could be a bit dodgy.
So I replied with this:
Originally posted by dadudemon
Watch the beginning of Ep. III when Anakin frees Palpatine form his shackles. Anakin also VERY precisely killed that poisonous centipede things from off of Amadala's bed without even saber toasting the blanket.Yes, THAT precise. 😐
So you replied with this:
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
That was the one with the highest midichlorean count.I'd like to see how much face a lesser Jedi would leave her with.
And I settled it with this:
Originally posted by dadudemon
😆That's par for any jedi knight, though.
Now, you either had problems following our conversation or you are purposefully twisting my words to tear down my credibility in the discussion (by painting me as a fanboy or a lunatic.) I suspect that it's both.
It's quite clear that I indicated that cutting the centipedes off of Padme without cutting her would have been par for the course for any Jedi Knight. (At the time, I said "Jedi Knight" on purpose as to not come off as trying to claim that even padawans and younglings were as skilled in using a saver as Anakin. I chose carefully as very few Padawans were as talented as Anakin when he was a Padawan. Now, if you want to continue to believe that any Jedi Knight can't move their blade in two movements, just enough to cut two giant very giant centipedes in half, I'll direct you to any blastet bolt deflected with a light saber in the OT or PT. Surely deflecting a blaster bolt that's less than a millimeter thick is more difficult to do than cutting two 1-3 inch tall, 3-5 inch wide, and 3 foot long centipedes? I mean, really...where is the more precision required to execute? Which one has a lower margin of error before shit hits the fan?)
If you had problems understanding what I meant, the following post should have definitely cleared things up for you:
Originally posted by dadudemon
Yup. Pretty much. 😐 (I was saying "yup" to the snipping of the centipede thingies off of Padme...not that they are all as good Anakin. That's stupid.)
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
and you asserted that Maces CW feats counted in the discussion at hand.
I've asked you on multiple occasions to cite your "source" for that. Since you and I both know it doesn't exist, stop accusing me of things I didn't say. At the very least, quote me.
And, in case you wanted to try and take things out of context, this should have stopped all your comments about using EU feats for Mace.
Originally posted by dadudemon
My point is NOT to show that the EU SHOULD be used, it is to show how closely together they were tied in for Episode III. You wanted to know where force crush was used, so I indicated where it was used on Grevious and Grevious shows signs of that damage in Episode III. Since episode III is cannon, and GL and Tartakovsky made a collaborative effort to INCLUDE that in Chapter 25 and continue it in Episode III, what happened to Grevious would have to be semi-cannon, at the least. That was my only point. I do NOT want to continue to talk about something that was an aside that was only intended as an FYI.Edit-
Now, for the sake of the debate, Force Crush is cannon. I said it is, and that is final. Imp can make a ruling on that if he'd like. However, only one person can use it and that is Mace. Since Mace would make hamburger meat of Spiderman anyway, there's no need to give him one of his signature powers. If others would like to use force crush as an example, I would say that it fails to be an example of any power except for Mace's.
Double edit- I hope you know that I wasn't serous about it being cannon. 😐 However, one cannot be without the other. If Imp wants to allow Mace his force crush, that's fine, but I still think it doesn't belong in here.
That very last part is the clincher. You're continuing to literally lie about my posts.
Originally posted by dadudemon
The motive that you assert is not depicted on screen in unambiguous way.
Yes it is.
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
This is your own erroneous interpretation of the events that happened. It's simply not the case. Mace had the entire duel under control.
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
I say EU is wrong and bullshit.
What a sweeping and obviously wrong conclusion.
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
You indulge it all the way and think it has any bearing on what is or isnt in film canon.
No. 😐
I don't know how many times you're going to lie about things I have said. I kindly ask you to stop lying about things I've posted.
Here's your contradictory evidence, and all in context, too.
Originally posted by dadudemon
You can't use the EU material as canon,
Originally posted by dadudemon
Only a EU Mace Windu would be a good match of Spiderman, H2H and Mace only. That's not forum canon, so it doesn't count, as I've already pointed out.
Originally posted by dadudemon
I'm only referring to Mace Windu's use of force Crush. Not necessary to the discussion because I don't think it's applicable enough to be canon. However, Vader can use it, no problem, on a much grander scale then Mace. 😐I'm sure you'd like me to point out that it is really an EU power and it is very very hard to use and, therefore, no one can use it except Vader.
And here's how the force crush "debate" started.
Originally posted by dadudemon
Mace Windu. Mace Windu used force crush on Grievous as he was making an escape.Despite people wanting to cling to the Movies as being the only cannon, sometimes you really do have to include some "EU" stuff as cannon. However, in this VS. forum, only the movies can be used. I just thought that your point was rather good and wanted to point out that it WAS done.
Quite clearly, my intentions were the movies because of the settings in this forum. I just mentioned it as an aside because Robtard DID bring up an excellent point: someone really did reach out and use force crush on Grievous.
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
I dont call you wrong for it. Sorry if it angers you to not have someone see something the way you do, but hey, what else is the internet for...
True, true. However, your seeing it incorrectly doesn't anger me, though. stoned