Batman vs Wolverine

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
I really never expected this thread to grow into anything more than Wolverine gets stomped.... does anyone remember when Logan was stripped of his HF back in Genosha? Let me refresh your memory. Wolverine was punched by a normal security officer, and nearly KO'd. Batman will win this.

1. Logan smokes
2. Without HF he's over 75 yrs old.
3 Without HF he tires far faster.

Batman wins.

1. I agree with Jinzin, his body already healed from the nicotine and tar damage when he had his healing factor. He would be like a brand new smoker if it went away.

2. They already said he would be at his peak performance in the original post so that doesn't matter.

3. Yeah, if you mean he can't fight for 18 hours of course. But think about it, this guy could practically run 100 miles in a day if he wanted to. Not to mention he trains in the danger room constantly. You don't think that he would still be the pinnacle of human endurance given his body has been succumbed to that type of training his whole life? Much more training than Batman could endure I might add. If anyone tires faster, it will still be Batman.

Originally posted by Mindset
Care to point out where I said it was?

I was just saying. It wasn't a personal attack. Sorry if you took it that way.

Wolverine wins. He is one of the best martial artists in marvel from what ive heard on like every other thread. Yes Im a fanboy, but I dont let that change my judgement. He has had far more fighting experience. I beleive better training as well. Still, Hes no dumb without his claws. In my opinion hes better than batman in ma.

Come on guys, Batman is legendary for his MA skills.

Wolverine is known for being the tireless killing machine that doesn't stop. Although theres obviously alot more to him, such as being a very good MA, but I just don't see him taking the DCU cream of the crop in pure H2H.

Don't you guys think saying Batman losing to a depowered, adamantiumless Wolvie is an injustice to his character? I mean Bats really wouldn't be good for anything if he lost this battle or at least not take it 5/10.

Wolverine is one of the very best in ma in marvel. I say 5/5. They are both the best.

Wolverine fights dirty...he'll just hit Bruce with a steel chair over and over until Bruce is a bloody mess on the floor then he'll get a bottle..smash it over his own head and then kill Bruce and then he'll have sex with Aunt may in front of Pete

Originally posted by steverules
Wolverine fights dirty...he'll just hit Bruce with a steel chair over and over until Bruce is a bloody mess on the floor then he'll get a bottle..smash it over his own head and then kill Bruce and then he'll have sex with Aunt may in front of Pete

Originally posted by DeathKap
What the hell is with aut may?

Lmao, I thought the same. Priceless, however.

To put this in simplicity:

Wolverine is best at MA.

Batman is the best of the best of MA. He perfected his body, mind and MA skills and talents.

Originally posted by DeathKap
What the hell is with aut may?

I thought I'd just throw her into the whole mix...she's wolverines age

Originally posted by steverules
I thought I'd just throw her into the whole mix...she's wolverines age

Originally posted by steverules
Wolverine fights dirty...he'll just hit Bruce with a steel chair over and over until Bruce is a bloody mess on the floor then he'll get a bottle..smash it over his own head and then kill Bruce and then he'll have sex with Aunt may in front of Pete

lol... Why a steel chair though. Why not an adamantium sword or something.

Originally posted by Placidity
lol... Why a steel chair though. Why not an adamantium sword or something.

Steel chair seemed funnier than a sword 😄

Originally posted by The Heap
Lmao, I thought the same. Priceless, however.

To put this in simplicity:

Wolverine is best at MA.

Batman is the best of the best of MA. He perfected his body, mind and MA skills and talents.

I'm not disagreeing that Bats is a top tier MA, however there are others in DC who are better than or just as good as him. Firstly there is Karate Kid, but he is ridiculously good and is probably better than everyone in Marvel too.
Then there is Richard Dragon who referred to Batman as, "a talented amateur". Bronze Tiger who has both defeated and stalemated Batman I think. A character called the Sensei ( I might be wrong about this though) who Batman defeated after a long and brutal fight. However I do believe it was stated Batman only won because the Sensei was old and physically not good enough.Therefore meaning he was more skilled than Batman. Then there is the whole Lady Shiva v Batman debate with Batman's two 'victories' over her being called into question because of interference by Robin and in the second case her being apparently mind controlled.Then there are Batman's remarks where he doubts whether or not he could defeat Shiva. Connor Hawke could also be argued to be just as good as Batman as well since he lost a very close fight with Lady Shiva. Add Batgirl (Cassandra Cain) to that list since many people think she is better than Batman or at least his equal and she has defeated Lady Shiva before. Though Batman did get the better of her in a sparring match when he pulled what would have been a killing blow at the end.
In short Batman in my opinion is one of DC's premier martial artists, but he is not the best of the best. Others like in this case Wolverine are probably better.

Originally posted by Warrior18
I'm not disagreeing that Bats is a top tier MA, however there are others in DC who are better than or just as good as him. Firstly there is Karate Kid, but he is ridiculously good and is probably better than everyone in Marvel too.
Then there is Richard Dragon who referred to Batman as, "a talented amateur". Bronze Tiger who has both defeated and stalemated Batman I think. A character called the Sensei ( I might be wrong about this though) who Batman defeated after a long and brutal fight. However I do believe it was stated Batman only won because the Sensei was old and physically not good enough.Therefore meaning he was more skilled than Batman. Then there is the whole Lady Shiva v Batman debate with Batman's two 'victories' over her being called into question because of interference by Robin and in the second case her being apparently mind controlled.Then there are Batman's remarks where he doubts whether or not he could defeat Shiva. Connor Hawke could also be argued to be just as good as Batman as well since he lost a very close fight with Lady Shiva. Add Batgirl (Cassandra Cain) to that list since many people think she is better than Batman or at least his equal and she has defeated Lady Shiva before. Though Batman did get the better of her in a sparring match when he pulled what would have been a killing blow at the end.
In short Batman in my opinion is one of DC's premier martial artists, but he is not the best of the best. Others like in this case Wolverine are probably better.

Quoted for truth.

Except I think Batman is atleast as good as Wolverine if he isn't better.

Originally posted by Placidity
Come on guys, Batman is legendary for his MA skills.

Wolverine is known for being the tireless killing machine that doesn't stop. Although theres obviously alot more to him, such as being a very good MA, but I just don't see him taking the DCU cream of the crop in pure H2H.

Don't you guys think saying Batman losing to a depowered, adamantiumless Wolvie is an injustice to his character? I mean Bats really wouldn't be good for anything if he lost this battle or at least not take it 5/10.

Injustice to get beaten by a master MA with countless years of experience and training that vastly outnumber his own? No that's not an injustice. I'm not saying he'll lose every time I just think Logan wins more often. something like 6/10 Logan.

Plus logans felt worse things than a punch from batman so he'd be able to take it

Originally posted by steverules
Plus logans felt worse things than a punch from batman so he'd be able to take it

True that. He's pretty much lived his life in pain.

Everytime his claws pop out it hurts like hell...heck even that probably hurts more than a punch from batman.

Originally posted by steverules
Everytime his claws pop out it hurts like hell...heck even that probably hurts more than a punch from batman.

Yeah I'll take a punch in the face over metal ripping through my muscles and skin any day. 😂

Originally posted by jinzin
He's a constantly reincarnating Worrior soul... This was outlined in the Weapon X novel and supported by the Gehenna Stone affair that revealed Wolverine as the reincarnation of the Hand of God, by Loebs arc where Wolverine's spirit has been part of a lupin heritage since the age, and furthered by Wolverine's spirit's exploits in Netsuke where he was hinted at being at least 4 different men of Japanese heritage in the past.

You might be right but theres a good chance that you are probably blowing things out of proportion per usual.