Ganthet vs. Galactus

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
Galactus fought Phoenix in Excalibur. More then once too.

Hold on I'll get scans.

Originally posted by quanchi112
We agree.

Are you really that much of a two year old you need the last word? if your universe will collapse without it, then go ahead.

Originally posted by quanchi112
What does that have to do with this thread?

Just correcting something stated between me and another poster that does not concern you.

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
Just correcting something stated between me and another poster that does not concern you.

Good

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix

Galactus fought Phoenix in Excalibur. More then once too.

and ...

Galactus was starving:

"I have need of sustenance"

So this doesn't count.

Galactus has never battled a Phoenix avatar again, this was the only time.

The 'What if' (although nothing happened) doesn't count, because they're not 616 characters.

Originally posted by Mr Master
because Galactus has never battled Phoenix.

This was your statement, I was just showing it was wrong.

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix

This was your statement, I was just showing it was wrong.

Rachel Summers is not Dark Phoenix. 🙂

My previous post, not the selective crop you pointed out.

Originally posted by Mr Master

Galactus has never lost to Dark Phoenix, because Galactus has never battled Phoenix.

Hmm ... In a 'What if' ... heh, where Galactus was hungry,
they had a quick scuffle, stalemated, and then Galactus got bored, that's it.

btw. In that 'What if' issue ... Phoenix considers Galactus her equal:

But Galactus said, that ... he would eventually destroy Phoenix if they continued:

Doesn't really matter though, cause these are not 616 characters.

Originally posted by Mr Master
Actually, it's 100% right.

Rachel Summers is not Dark Phoenix. 🙂

Your statement was that he never battled Phoenix. He did and I proved it. You didn't say he never battled Dark Phoenix, you said Phoenix.

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix

Your statement was that he never battled Phoenix. He did and I proved it.

You didn't say he never battled Dark Phoenix, you said Phoenix.

Originally posted by Mr Master

Galactus has never lost to Dark Phoenix, because Galactus has never battled Phoenix.

Originally posted by Mr Master

That wasn't Dark Phoenix, that was Rachel Summers, Excalibur #61

and ...

Galactus was starving:

You said and I quote
"Galactus has never battled Phoenix."

This is not true. I provided scans. Maybe you meant to say Dark Phoenix. But you didn't.

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix

You said and I quote
"Galactus has never battled Phoenix."

This is not true. I provided scans.

Maybe you meant to say Dark Phoenix. But you didn't.

What I wrote and I'll quote myself:

Originally posted by Mr Master

Galactus has never lost to Dark Phoenix, because Galactus has never battled Phoenix.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=492340&pagenumber=6 (18th post)

If you're just being silly, cool, I can take a joke. 🙂

No I get that it was a grammatical error. You meant to say

"Galactus has never lost to Dark Phoenix, because Galactus has never battled Dark Phoenix."

Correct?

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix

No I get that it was a grammatical error. You meant to say

"Galactus has never lost to Dark Phoenix, because Galactus has never battled Dark Phoenix."

Correct?

Anyhow, as to the argument:

Galactus has never battled Dark Phoenix.

Galactus has only battled one Phoenix avatar, and that was Rachel Summers,
and, it's very important to point out ... Galactus was starving.

That's for the record. 😄

No problem. We're good.

Edit

Aster do you have to argue about every little thing, no matter how trivial it is?

And you say Quanchi is petty...

Originally posted by Mindset
Aster do you have to argue about every little thing, no matter how trivial it is?

And you say Quanchi is petty...

Do you have to come into a thread where no one is fighting and try to start one up? Talk about petty.

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
Do you have to come into a thread where no one is fighting and try to start one up? Talk about petty.

I'm not trying to start a fight, it's annoying to see every thread you get involved in degenerate into debates about insignificant matters.