Delph's League of Champions Stats, Standings, and Transactions Thread · Battlezone

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Same goes for you Smurph. You're clearly not the instigator here, and are returning in kind, but it doesn't make the vulgarity any more acceptable. If I need to, I'll have Bada temporarily close this until ill can rule on it, then re-open it when there's nothing left to discuss. If it comes to that, at least one person will be receiving a warning, which I'd rather not have to resort to.
This isn't evidence. It does nothing to allay Smurph's fears. An actual discussion is possible, but won't be if you simply answer his high-end feats with his low ones.

There isn't anything to rule on. you can't rule someone out becuz of one feat that NO one has on panel. If that were the case, almost all of the high meta tier would be listed as herald due to one uber feat.

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by Cavalier
"In Amazing-Man's case, Mist tricked him into mimicking glass and then shattered him."
Absorbing Man has had the same thing happen to him by Hulk.
And it was trickery, not the mist powerset that you're trying to imply. Joker's pulled similar tricks in his time... doesn't mean that each meta he's toyed with is lesser in power to a clown.

And Amazing Man is dead. Absorbing Man pulls himself back together. Hence Amazing man is no where in absorbing man's class. Thank you. Good night.

illadelph12 aka Rakim Illa

We're going to need more specifics on Amazing Man Fangirl. The circumstances of his killing Overmaster and other issues need to be addressed. I'm not banning the character without a judicious review first. I'm not going to assume the character is beyond caps due to having similar powers to a Herald Level character. We have until Sunday to have this matter settled for use in Week 4.

Cavalier tu quoqumber

Originally posted by fangirl101
And Amazing Man is dead. Absorbing Man pulls himself back together. Hence Amazing man is no where in absorbing man's class. Thank you. Good night.

Completely irrelevant.

If you continue to dodge, it just becomes more and more apparent that this is probably an illegal pick.

You said that you have a ton of low meta characters that can do the same thing that you need Amazing Man for?

Draft them then.

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by illadelph12
We're going to need more specifics on Amazing Man Fangirl. The circumstances of his killing Overmaster and other issues need to be addressed. I'm not banning the character without a judicious review first. I'm not going to assume the character is beyond caps due to having similar powers to a Herald Level character. We have until Sunday to have this matter settled for use in Week 4.

If he's banned, I'm going to quit and cry holy hell becuz I bitched about Miss martian having the exact same powers as martian manhunter. To which I was told it's the feats that count. Really. Period. I won't talk about it any more. I even talked about how miss martian stalemated Supergirl and was told it was a ONE TIME thing. Polaris has The same powes as magneto. And Even manged to put the screws to VULCAN. Need I say more? She's on the Meta List and He's on the herald list. See my point?

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by Cavalier
Completely irrelevant.
If you continue to dodge, it just becomes more and more apparent that this is probably an illegal pick.
You said that you have a ton of low meta characters that can do the same thing that you need Amazing Man for?
Draft them then.

I'm going to just put you on my ignore list. Have a nice night.

DigiMark007 Forum Leader

Supergirl's only low herald, and a stalemate doesn't mean she has equal power. It means she hung with her for a while. I don't think anyone would give M'gann the majority over supergirl just because she didn't die instantly against her. A lot of high metas would stalemate Supergirl for a bit. Doesn't mean they're > or = to her though. It's means they're close enough to give her a fight for a while.

MM has never done anything > high meta. Ever. I read Titans. But if your boy has absorbed "vast" amounts of energy and become it (again, I'm going off of wiki because no other info was posted) then it exceeds high meta.

So yes, it is about feats. What we're trying to do is determine what his feats are and aren't. Your tantrums aren't helping.

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Supergirl's only low herald, and a stalemate doesn't mean she has equal power. It means she hung with her for a while. I don't think anyone would give M'gann the majority over supergirl just because she didn't die instantly against her. A lot of high metas would stalemate Supergirl for a bit. Doesn't mean they're > or = to her though.
MM has never done anything > high meta. Ever. I read Titans. But if your boy has absorbed "vast" amounts of energy and become it (again, I'm going off of wiki because no other info was posted) then it exceeds high meta.
So yes, it is about feats. What we're trying to do is determine what his feats are and aren't. Your tantrums aren't helping.

Hell. The story is so old. He didn't become energy. He's never been able to do that. That is number one. They were in a battle with overmaster. So OM wasn't at his peak. And if you are saying he has a similiar power set to someone one tier above him, then I'm going to argue holy hell about miss martian and polaris. Both of whom have similiar power sets to someone above them. And even have high end feats. Can you not see the DOUBLE standard?

DigiMark007 Forum Leader

I'm NOT saying he's low herald based on power set similar to Creel. I'm saying that we need to determine what his best feats are so that we can determine his power level. As before, your angry rants aren't giving us information. They're only giving us the impression that you either don't know what his highest feats are, or you're dodging the question....why else would you fail to answer?

So yeah, I see the double standard....good thing that isn't my argument.

I'm gonna PM Val. He reads a ton of JSA. Maybe he can help us.

Cavalier tu quoqumber

Originally posted by fangirl101
I'm going to just put you on my ignore list. Have a nice night.

Then my work here is done.

And I plan to, thanks. 🙂

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by DigiMark007
I'm NOT saying he's low herald based on power set similar to Creel. I'm saying that we need to determine what his best feats are so that we can determine his power level. As before, your angry rants aren't giving us information.
So yeah, I see the double standard....good thing that isn't my argument.

Outside of the Overmaster thing, You won't get much in the way of uberness. Firestorm, Maxima, and Captain Atom were the big guns of EJ. Hell even the Wonder Twins seemed more powerful. I dont' think I've ever seen AM2 even fly. I could be wrong. But I think maxima had to fly him around. I didn't want him anyway. I don't have the comics with him. I wanted Am3. But He's got nine appearances until later this month. So I'll just do with Am2.

illadelph12 aka Rakim Illa

Amazing Man isn't banned, he's pending a review.

Cooler heads people.

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by illadelph12
Amazing Man isn't banned, he's pending a review.
Cooler heads people.

I don't have those appearances. I honestly Can't remember him doing any thing great. I wanted the new guy. But they made such a fuss about him. My pics always getting a fuss. then later on people wanna pick them up. What is that all about? 🙁

DigiMark007 Forum Leader

I have a PM in to Val, KMC's resident JSA expert. I also have a bye week, and will try to get around to some cursory research on him. No promises. But we'll see.

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by DigiMark007
I have a PM in to Val, KMC's resident JSA expert. I also have a bye week, and will try to get around to some cursory research on him. No promises. But we'll see.

If you do, please send me some scans. As i've stated a million times that I didn't want him. I don't have anything on him. you forced my hand. By the time I woud have used the new Guy, it would have been ten. As I have a bye week next week.

illadelph12 aka Rakim Illa

Originally posted by fangirl101
I don't have those appearances. I honestly Can't remember him doing any thing great. I wanted the new guy. But they made such a fuss about him. My pics always getting a fuss. then later on people wanna pick them up. What is that all about? 🙁

There's an appearance quota for all picks. You have to have 10 active appearances (10 books in which the character is an integral part of the story and engages in some action, not simply an appearance on a splash page or something). That's the issue with the latest incarnation of Amazing Man; his number of full appearances.

Cavalier tu quoqumber

Originally posted by DigiMark007
I have a PM in to Val, KMC's resident JSA expert.

Jon left KMC...

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by illadelph12
There's an appearance quota for all picks. You have to have 10 active appearances (10 books in which the character is an integral part of the story and engages in some action, not simply an appearance on a splash page or something). That's the issue with the latest incarnation of Amazing Man; his number of full appearances.

Well, The best we gone get on Amazing Man 2 from what I can remember is Extreme Justice and something Young all stars and Justice league europe I think. And I dont' own anything but the EJ and that's at my mother's house. I dont' know how to use DC ++ plus so I'm stuck with really no way to use him as it is.

fangirl101 Restricted

Originally posted by Cavalier
Jon left KMC...

That's too bad.

DigiMark007 Forum Leader

Originally posted by Cavalier
Jon left KMC...

Really. Hmm. That's a shame. I always liked him, even though he never seemed to care for me much. And he knew a bunch.

Gads, then. Who's our next JSA expert?