Although i don't like this particular EU story, Luke fought a solid+immortal force ghost/hologram of Darth Maul and won, i don't know if it was just after RotJ or what but that gives him the upper over Qui-Gon first off...
Anakin, RotS, non-Vader or Vader? assuming he's non-Vader he's gonna be smarter and more mindful of the fight, so he won't try and get the upper hand on anyone before he knows he can. Though, Obi-Wan could break Anakins strategy pretty quickly, considering Obi-Wan taught Anakin most of what he knows.
Qui-Gon, though in the TPM novelisation suggested Maul was better, was on the verge of Jedi Master Council level, he only didn't become a Master because of his recklessness (and no doubt some other things that people may have said already). Qui-Gon could observe Lukes sloppy/untrained saber skill and possibly get the upper hand over him...
It's a toughy, but i think Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan could get this one, not indefinatly, but it would be close...
Originally posted by CadoAngelus
Although i don't like this particular EU story, Luke fought a solid+immortal force ghost/hologram of Darth Maul and won, i don't know if it was just after RotJ or what but that gives him the upper over Qui-Gon first off...
Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Qui Gon beats Luke (he's a jedi MASTER that rivaled Mace, and Luke isn't really a jedi yet, or at least according to the anti luke fanboyism around here)
How is there anti Luke fanboyism when we all acknowledge him of being the most powerful jedi ever and not to mention he is a beast from DE and beyond.
Originally posted by Eminence
Before RotJ? And do they compare to Qui-Gon Jinn or Darth Vader?Yes, but the novel makes it very clear that there's more to it than that.
Kenobi hesitated. He had both weapons, and then he simply did nothing. Anakin mocked him for his "compassion," and then Force-pushes him back and proceeds to nearly break his arms.
Was that in the revenge of the sith novel? (when Anakin mocked him)
i havent read it and it sounds pretty interesting.
Yep.
You can read most of them right here. Good site.
It depends how the battle is sectioned.
Anakin & ObiWan in one location
and Luke and quigon in another
if they are seperated then i believe kenobi and quigon would win because they are a distinguished team so they have startegies
but i think if anakin keeps a cool head he is the strongest jedi in that battle
luke and qui gon i think are roughly equal because they are both good saber duelests but hey both have poor force skills
Originally posted by kamikasiwill****in Necro.
It depends how the battle is sectioned.
Anakin & ObiWan in one location
and Luke and quigon in anotherif they are seperated then i believe kenobi and quigon would win because they are a distinguished team so they have startegies
but i think if anakin keeps a cool head he is the strongest jedi in that battle
luke and qui gon i think are roughly equal because they are both good saber duelests but hey both have poor force skills
I call first dibs on its rotted orifices. 😱 💃 😘