Originally posted by Red Nemesis
No, that's me.Proof please.
Note that I agree with you- I just don't like inaccuracies.
happy to.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wg_YVkU2zDo
thier blades first met in 1:27 i count that as the start of the duel, in just 10 seconds later at 1:37 already obi wan has taken one of his many hands off then again around in the 1:50's he takes yet another off, so he took 2 of grevous' hands off in 30 seconds, i say obi wan wins hands down pun intended lol
Obi-Wan definetely wins. In TPM novel Qui-Gon is said to himself believe that one day Obi1 would become a better Jedi than Qui-Gon Had Ever Been..
but still it wnt be ridiculously easy or anything for Obi1. Qui-Gon used to draw with TPM Mace in sparring sessions.. and was said to be not only one of the best swordmen not only of his time but of the past few centuries! I think we're talking ROTS Agen Kolar league for TPM QuiGon..
Also Kenobi took down Greivous easily because : 1. He was injured from Mace.. and 2. Soresu was the form best suited to face GG.
As for Obi-Wan having a better stamina, im not sure how much that would help, considering it would be mostly Qui-Gon doing the attacking at his own pace, with Obi-Wan just blocking and parrying until he gets an opening. Also Qui-Gon showed he could fight a long drawn out fight when hes ready.
But still it should be Qui-Gon in his prime vs. ROTS Obi-Wan. But Obi1 would still win, but with difficulty.