Silver Surfer vs Thor: Melee Battle

No energy attacks, matter or energy manipulation. Everything else goes (ie Surfer can amp).

Both fighters are blood-lusted.

Surfer gets his board and Thor gets his hammer.

I thought a slugfest was with hands only.

Thor.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
I thought a slugfest was with hands only.

With his hammer Thor would win. In a fight with no hammer though, I see Surfer's durability/speed giving him more of an edge than Thor's strength.

Originally posted by Starscream M
well maybe as its common usage...I just use slugfest for battles that only involve physical attacks

Oh I would've said Melee only then to fight confusion.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Oh I would've said Melee only then to fight confusion.

Thor for the stomp. Even sans hammer, once he gets a hold of Surfer, which he would eventually, it's likely over for him.

With the hammer, Thor.

Afterall, SS is weak to magic. 😖hifty:

Originally posted by darthgoober
With his hammer Thor would win. In a fight with no hammer though, I see Surfer's durability/speed giving him more of an edge than Thor's strength.

Originally posted by Starscream M
ok, I'll take that into consideration for future threads I make. I can't change thread title.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Yes you can. Hit "Edit" on the opening post and select "Advanced Options". Then just change the title when it brings up your post. Not saying you have to do that here, just letting you know it's an option...

thanks

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Thor for the stomp. Even sans hammer, once he gets a hold of Surfer, which he would eventually, it's likely over for him.

Originally posted by Starscream M
surfer could use his board offensively as well though

Originally posted by darthgoober

Doesn't pack nearly as much wallop. He could get in some good shots with it and it'd be useful as a shield, but it's not anywhere near the Offensive Marvel that Thor's hammer is...

but as you said, it would surve as a pretty effective shield

plus Surfer has mental command over it and can use it during the fight to constantly distract thor (ramming it in thor's back while they fight)

Originally posted by Starscream M
right...I understand it isn't nearly as powerful an offensive tool as thor's hammer

but as you said, it would surve as a pretty effective shield

plus Surfer has mental command over it and can use it during the fight to constantly distract thor (ramming it in thor's back while they fight)

SS is more durable (notch above Superman & Capt. Marvel etc.) and also has superspeed. he has the advantage
(plus he's not vulnerable to magic...???)

Thor would try to get in a few hits with the hammer but SS is too fast

Ok so this is SS pretty much trying to win only via H2H?

So pretty much Handicap SS vs Thor

Thor for the easy win

When u consider the things that thor has smashed with his hammer, SS is in serious trouble.

Originally posted by SoulDevourer
SS is more durable (notch above Superman & Capt. Marvel etc.) and also has superspeed. he has the advantage
(plus he's [b]not vulnerable to magic...???)

Thor would try to get in a few hits with the hammer but SS is too fast [/B]

Surfer does have an speed advantage but what good is speed when he can not use energy blasts.

Surfer will get in few hits but Mjolnir is to powerful.

If Surfer pours all his energy into amplifying himself, odds are he could knock out Thor. I'd give Thor a nod in the long run, but what if Surfer put ALL his energy into a single punch?