Superman vs Thor: Pure Physical Brawl

Started by Starscream M4 pages
Starscream M Senior Member

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
You managed to gather all that?

How astute.

cut the sarcastic crap.

why would Superman completely outclass Thor melee? Wonder Woman gives him trouble and Thor is a superior melee fighter than WW. Also, Thor's held his own against pissed off Hulk...who's as good a melee fighter as they get.

I think Superman takes majority, but this is far from a stomp as you make it seem.

Kris Blaze Restricted

Originally posted by Starscream M
cut the sarcastic crap.

why would Superman completely outclass Thor melee? Wonder Woman gives him trouble and Thor is a superior melee fighter than WW. Also, Thor's held his own against pissed off Hulk...who's as good a melee fighter as they get.

I think Superman takes majority, but this is far from a stomp as you make it seem.

You're a soooooo right Master Bruce.

Please, tell me more right things about the right rights which you have accumulated after many years of being right, living in your right world of the right.

Clearly I need to get over this awful Superman bias and stop hating Thor.

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!
Originally posted by Starscream M
why would Superman completely outclass Thor melee? Wonder Woman gives him trouble and Thor is a superior melee fighter than WW. Also, Thor's held his own against pissed off Hulk...who's as good a melee fighter as they get.

Superman's faster than Thor. He's stronger than Thor. You're not allowing Thor his hammer, which means he's even weaker. On top of that, Superman has excellent MA skills. He's even pressure-point shotted Batman.

Thor loses every single time.

Starscream M Senior Member

wow, good retort Illgrok...so much evidence you bring to back your points. I'll just put you on ignore now and spare myself your brilliance.

xJLxKing Senior Member

Superman wins this because he is
-Smarter
-Stronger
-More Durable
-Faster
-More versitile

Thor makes it hard because
-More experience

Starscream M Senior Member

Originally posted by xJLxKing
Superman wins this because he is
-Smarter
-Stronger
-More Durable
-Faster
-More versitile

Thor makes it hard because
-More experience

how is he more versatile?

Kris Blaze Restricted
Originally posted by Starscream M
wow, good retort Illgrok...so much evidence you bring to back your points. I'll just put you on ignore now and spare myself your brilliance.

You're right again.

I really need to go take a good look at myself. How can I claim that Superman against a hammerless Thor without bringing any evidence to support it. I am just unbelievable.

Ten points Master Bruce

Ten points.

xJLxKing Senior Member

Originally posted by Starscream M
how is he more versatile?

Yes, he can become intangible, more in tornado-like attack and a few other stuff.

Starscream M Senior Member

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
You're right again.

I really need to go take a good look at myself. How can I claim that Superman against a hammerless Thor without bringing any evidence to support it. I am just unbelievable.

Ten points Master Bruce

Ten points.

if you think it's a stomp, fine. but I'm letting you know I didn't create this thread to be a spite.

Kris Blaze Restricted
Originally posted by Starscream M
if you think it's a stomp, fine. but I'm letting you know I didn't create this thread to be a spite.

Take two seconds to think about it Mr.Right.

They're in the same tier, most people give Superman the majority when Thor gets his hammer.....

Starscream M Senior Member

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Take two seconds to think about it Mr.Right.

They're in the same tier, most people give Superman the majority when Thor gets his hammer.....

actually I thought Thor got the overwhelming majority when he has his hammer and lightning...but eh whatever

also, taking away flight from Superman also has a huge impact on his chances imo

The Great Galen Restricted

Purly physical, SUpes 10/10

D-Block Senior Member

Thor FTW.

Avlon Godot Brew#107

Supes wins.

Thor needed an upgrade just to punch someone into space....something that Supes can do effortlessly.

Taking Thor's hammer and extra abilities away is just so...wrong.

I'm Bran Dead

Originally posted by Avlon
Supes wins.

Thor needed an upgrade just to punch someone into space....something that Supes can do effortlessly.

Taking Thor's hammer and extra abilities away is just so...wrong.

That's not why he needed the upgrade... he needed it so he wouldn't break his bones hitting Harald.

I don't see how how far you hit someone has to do with who's stronger... there's other things to show why Thor isn't as strong as him. 😬

Zack Fair Fanboy

Without super speed this would be the fight of the millenium between two titans from their respective companies.

Avlon Godot Brew#107

Originally posted by I'm Bran
That's not why he needed the upgrade... he needed it so he wouldn't break his bones hitting Harald.

I don't see how how far you hit someone has to do with who's stronger... there's other things to show why Thor isn't as strong as him. 😬

Perhaps...but it serves it's purpose as a direct comparison.

I'm Bran Dead

Originally posted by Avlon
Perhaps...but it serves it's purpose as a direct comparison.
Not really.

That's the only time Thor's ever tried to hit someone up high.

Kris Blaze Restricted
Originally posted by Avlon
Perhaps...but it serves it's purpose as a direct comparison.

Context....son

FrothByte Nailcutter Massacre

Without the superspeed i'd say thor based purely on more h2h knowledge. but with superspeed? Superman.