Superman vs Thor: Pure Physical Brawl

Started by Raoul4 pages

Originally posted by Enyalus
Kal, easily.

WTH?

wow, i agree with you, imagine that...

Originally posted by Starscream M
No Mjolnir. No powers allowed. Bloodlust on.
Does this mean two "peakers" duke it out? If so...

Superman is said to be about 6'3, 225 lbs.
Thor is said to be about 6'6, 640 lbs (yowza).

Will Thor be slowed done by his extra mass? Or will he have a naturally higher level of strength in order to move that mass as effectively as his smaller opponent? I'm inclined to think the latter, since whenever Thor had been stripped of his powers in the past, he's never seemed weighted down.

Thus, with an almost 3:1 advantage in mass/strength: Thor ftw.

Originally posted by Mindship
Does this mean two "peakers" duke it out? If so...

Superman is said to be about 6'3, 225 lbs.
Thor is said to be about 6'6, 640 lbs (yowza).

.

So Thor is a super duper heavy weight? Interesting, because side by side there's isn't much difference in size between the two.

Why is Thor so heavy? since Supes is also super dense (at the subatomic level).

Originally posted by Raoul
wow, i agree with you, imagine that...

I try to be fair when its due. 😛

Originally posted by Allankles
Why is Thor so heavy? since Supes is also super dense (at the subatomic level).

Thor eats his Wheeties.

Originally posted by Enyalus
I try to be fair when its due. 😛

woot

Originally posted by Mindship
Does this mean two "peakers" duke it out? If so...

Superman is said to be about 6'3, 225 lbs.
Thor is said to be about 6'6, 640 lbs (yowza).

Will Thor be slowed done by his extra mass? Or will he have a naturally higher level of strength in order to move that mass as effectively as his smaller opponent? I'm inclined to think the latter, since whenever Thor had been stripped of his powers in the past, he's never seemed weighted down.

Thus, with an almost 3:1 advantage in mass/strength: Thor ftw.

Wait, what?

Supes with our without Superspeed.

supes >>> thor

Originally posted by Allankles
So Thor is a super duper heavy weight? Interesting, because side by side there's isn't much difference in size between the two.

Why is Thor so heavy? since Supes is also super dense (at the subatomic level).


Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Wait, what?

I first learned this in the DC/Marvel crossover in the 1990s (which I know wasn't canon). But it's popped up in other places since. Eg...

http://www.marvel.com/universe/Thor_(Thor_Odinson)

http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Thor_Odinson_%28Earth-616%29

"Superhumanly Dense Tissue: Thor's skin, muscle, and bone tissues have 3 times the density of the same tissue in the body of a human being, contributing somewhat to his superhuman strength and weight."

Originally posted by Allankles
So Thor is a super duper heavy weight? Interesting, because side by side there's isn't much difference in size between the two.

Why is Thor so heavy? since Supes is also super dense (at the subatomic level).

His Asgardian physiology.

I think I would give it to Supes but it would be close

thor is a excellent fighter but physically can stay with supes for a short time but in the end its supes. This is regular thor no suped up version of thor.

Furthermore this thread totally benifits supes becasue we are giving supes most all of his abilities. He has no special abilities minus heat vison which in the past has don nothing to captian marvel ba or thor.

So this particular thread basically just stripped thor of 3/4 of his abilities next to none for supes and even though thor is going to loose more often then not. He will still put up a fight. Thats saying alot for thor.

Remember people, Superman caught Thor hammer in their encounter. I don't think he would have problems catching his fists. The only problem is, how long is Thor going to stay in this fight?

If Thor can get into WM than he wins.

Originally posted by Anti-Monitor
Trolling
Originally posted by Anti-Monitor
Trolling

Originally posted by shokosugi
Supes with our without Superspeed.

supes >>> thor

yep and

supes against thor with his magical abilities and hammer

thor >>> supes in most cases.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
Remember people, Superman caught Thor hammer in their encounter. I don't think he would have problems catching his fists. The only problem is, how long is Thor going to stay in this fight?

If your refering to the cross over, crossovers mean nothing. there is no way superman can catch that magical hammer when the same damm hammer was used by thor to actually casue a dent in the armor of a celistial.

Superman catching taking a blunt hit from thors hammer is

BAD WRITING and everyone knows it.

A HAMMER IS BUT A TOOL, EVEN MJOLNIR!

To think I actually forgot about that battle.

Originally posted by zeel
If your refering to the cross over, crossovers mean nothing. there is no way superman can catch that magical hammer when the same damm hammer was used by thor to actually casue a dent in the armor of a celistial.

Superman catching taking a blunt hit from thors hammer is

BAD WRITING and everyone knows it.

Considering the crazy strength feats of Superman it's not hard to believe he can catch Mjlonir especially with the lack of any great momentum behind the blow. Simple physics if Thor's hammer blow didn't carry sufficient force, if he didn't carry enough momentum no big surprise that Supes catches it.

It's not like he's rocking planets with every blow. In FC Supes is able to stop a ship that is 70 miles long and that was travelling with crazy momentum through the Bleed, not much of a stretch if that guy can stop hammer blows.