Eternal Idol
Lono, "The Dog"
Originally posted by Phantom Zone
I dont know about the end justifies the means, people who follow that philosophy kill innocent people.
I'm talking about the Punisher here, not real-life psychopaths; but even in comics, Castle will kill vigilantes whose sloppy methods result in civilian casualties or who operate out of self-interest and personal vendettas.
Originally posted by willRules
Ah well as long as Frank accepts he's guilty, then every thing's ok. That's like a thief admitting he is one and then going out and mugging someone. At least the important thing is that he accepts it right? 🙄And end justifies the means? What a load of crap!!! Even by comic book standards that's delusional. He'll stop once he has killed EVERY criminal right?
The Punisher's a cool character and I've got nothing against him. I'm just making it clear that his whole ideology is hypocritical and unjustifiable ✅
In the case of the Punisher, the ends do justify the means. How often does he kill innocent bystanders either through recklessness or callousness? I can't think of one example. How many drug-dealing, murdering douche-bags has he killed? Thousands, and thousands more lives were changed for the better because of it, regardless of whether it was directly or indirectly.
That quote is great because it shows that American Judicial System is a failure, at least in Frank's perspective-- it's a revolving door; if it worked, he'd be in prison along with the same people he's out to kill, and he wouldn't have it any other way. However, despite being a criminal in the eyes of the law, Castle is a hero because his actions have positive outcomes. He doesn't simply kill for amusement; he does it to eliminate threats to civilians. That's what's important.
Frank himself is a little delusional. He is a traumatized man who lost his family, and is now fighting to eliminate crime-- it's the classic formula for a friggin' superhero. NONE of them will ever stop every criminal-- not Daredevil, nor Spider-Man, nor Batman-- but that's not the point of it all. The point is to make a difference, no matter how small. He'll stop once he is killed or no longer able to carry on with his work. Until then, he'll keep on at it.