Midnighter vs. Spiderman

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Heh. There's gotta be other threads like this.

I figure I'm knowledgeable enough about both to assess this fairly...normally fanboy-ism might sway me one way or the other, but I like both a lot.

Spidey fights all kinds of people that are willing to kill, so "MN'er kills so he wins" doesn't really mean as much as people want it to.

MN'ers implants will allow him to see Pete's powers, so his calculative ability will be in full force.

But Spider-Man's physical stats are just plain better. Faster, stronger, etc. and 'nighter would have trouble de-webbing himself.

Lastly, MN'er can anticipate moves, but spider-sense is essentially precognition. I actually think it would be a rare trump card against MN'ers calculative abilities, because it can't account for something that literally accounts for moves before they happen or even before the other person knows it.

Assuming that Spidey realizes he's up against the real deal, and not some random dude in a costume, he'd win. No speed, skill, durability, or agility feats that MN'er has beats what Spidey can do, and spider-sense effectively neutralizes MN'ers best chance of winning. Remove spider-sense and I'd give MN'er the solid majority. But with it, Pete gets 8/10, give or take.

I'm still backing Spidey, though it would be a fight to see!

I want to say Midnighter, but something tells me Spidey will win.

Its the webbing.

might swing it for spidey

if Midnighter forgets how to use a lazer torch to rip it off.

Spiderman just makes a deal with mephisto to win the battle

Mephisto will respect Nighter's Authoritae 🙂

Hey digi, does Spidey still win with the current downgrade?

to quote Digi: "nyet Trikkster 😉"

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Hey digi, does Spidey still win with the current downgrade?

Well current is now classic. So..... 😐

This was made before his downgrade.

Spidey would kick MM ass.

Originally posted by Peek
Well current is now classic. So..... 😐

Really, I think it is the pre-cog that messes up Midnighter here more than Peter's other superhuman attributes.

Originally posted by Priest
This was made before his downgrade.

Spidey would kick MM ass.

I've always seen this as Pete's fight to lose srug

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Classic Spidey had a billion appearences, so he did everything from dodge Upper tier metas for pages on end to lose to street levelers. But the forums assume peak abilities, and the former of those examples outnumber the latter by quite a bit anyway.

I dont see how this is relevant, im sure there are examples of street levelers doing the same and doing similar feats. Hell MN high kicked a tank shell. Spiderman caught two bullets but got messed up in the process. Since tank shells move faster than bullets and its harder to kick more accurately I would put Mners feat above Spiderman.

Originally posted by BUSTER1
Sorry Alfheim but Pete's Spider Sense even in Classic days was able to guide him when it came to avoiding danger. In stories where this didn't happen , it was down to the writer not understanding the nature of the Spider Sense.
With that said i don't know anything about Midnighter, so i don't know wether he should beat Pete.-hey that last bit rhymed

Ok. *shrug*

Originally posted by Peek
Hes been downgraded to classic. 😐

If u like make a new thread with "current" spidey.

Originally posted by Priest
I know, but the thread starter had the mentality to use Spiderman before he was downgraded 😐

If u like make a new thread with "current" spidey.

Why? Current and classic are now the same. Whats the point in a new one when theres not really much difference now accept with experience.

Who would win?

midnighter

spiderman

The Midnighter

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=417981&highlight=Midnighter+vs.+Spiderman+forumid%3A77