Originally posted by Digi
Heh. There's gotta be other threads like this.I figure I'm knowledgeable enough about both to assess this in a fair manner. Normally fanboy-ism might sway me one way or the other, but I like both a lot.
Spidey fights all kinds of people that are willing to kill, so "MN'er kills so he wins" doesn't really mean as much as people want it to.
MN'ers implants will allow him to see Pete's powers, so his calculative ability will be in full force.
But Spider-Man's physical stats are just plain better. Faster, stronger, etc. and 'nighter would have trouble de-webbing himself.
Lastly, MN'er can anticipate moves, but spider-sense is essentially precognition. I actually think it would be a rare trump card against MN'ers calculative abilities, because it can't account for something that literally accounts for moves before they happen or even before the other person knows it.
Assuming that Spidey realizes he's up against the real deal, and not some random dude in a costume, he'd win. No speed, skill, durability, or agility feats that MN'er has beats what Spidey can do, and spider-sense effectively neutralizes MN'ers best chance of winning. Remove spider-sense and I'd give MN'er the solid majority. But with it, Pete gets 8/10, give or take.
Ta-da! Still 100% correct.
313