Batman vs. Jango Fett

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth

Man if we were debating wookies right now, you'd be citing The holiday special as canon right here.

Ha.

Depends how into EU you are, RJ.

No John Williams + No scroll opening x Messing with canon = No canon.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Depends how into EU you are, RJ.

No John Williams + No scroll opening x Messing with canon = No canon.

Released as a movie...? yes. No argument there.

Three luke warm episodes tacked together at the last minute..? Sure.

Canon...? No.

And it wouldnt surprise me if if your double HAD directed it to be honest. 😛

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Released as a movie...? yes. No argument there.
.

Then your argument may become conflicted by the differing angles presented by the difference. Oh well, thats your lookout.

I as a fan though will never regard it as canon.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
This is really the only one that matters. It had a theatrical release, this is a movie versus forum, a movie is a movie, even if it totally destroys the storyline if its predecessors.

So "if it's in the movies it counts no matter what" is held to it's strictest, and all logic be damned?

Originally posted by Robtard
So "if it's in the movies it counts no matter what" is held to it's strictest, and all logic be damned?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
If that's how you wanna see it.

I'm asking you, as you think the animated movie has many faults (Anakin's padawan etc) and does not follow [live] movie canon, yet think it should still be included despite said logical faults.

So, what say you?

In a thread where Spiderman fights SW characters. :/

Originally posted by Robtard
I'm asking you, as you think the animated movie has many faults (Anakin's padawan etc) and does not follow [live] movie canon, yet think it should still be included despite said logical faults.

So, what say you?

OKay the Anakin has to get saved by his little girlfriend during it.

Spidey dont need a 13 yr old girl to save HIS ass.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I havent seen it, but its a movie, and even if it makes me puke I will acknowledge it has a place here, IMO.

Edit: Then "in the movies" is how you should always debate, not matter how illogical or stupid a certain scene/instance might be compared to the rest of the film.

I dropped the 'flies wings' as just went with the dodging of the punch, as Spider-man having 5-times the reaction speed of a human is fairly reasonable compared to the rest of the film, while the wings bit was a bit too much. You should accept that fly scene as the 'greatest feat' though; logic be damned.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
In a thread where Spiderman fights SW characters. :/

Indeed.

Are we discussing the credibility of movie canon here, guys? What seems to be the argument?

Wotcha, Impediment. 🙂

Conflicts in Clone wars with the rest of proper SW movies.

And EU being cited as evidence in this discussion by the pro-Jedi folk, (not so much RJ, admittedly, in this instance, he seems to be trying as best as he can to go movie canon like us pro-spideys.)

Alas, I have never seen the recent Clone Wars movie because, well, I've really no interest to be even more disappointed than I already am by George Lucas with the current prequels.

Your fears sir, are entirely justified.

AVOID! AVOID! AVOID!

lolz

The series is actually a fair bit better.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Wotcha, Impediment. 🙂

Conflicts in Clone wars with the rest of proper SW movies.

And EU being cited as evidence in this discussion by the pro-Jedi folk, (not so much RJ, admittedly, in this instance, he seems to be trying as best as he can to go movie canon like us pro-spideys.)

You're saying that the EU has been used for reference in this thread?

You'll have to excuse my being misinformed here, but I just got off of work and am just now sitting down after a shower.

No probs.

Its more in the Spiderman vs Jedi thread, but a comparison of logics lead into this debate in this thread too.