SMP Vs Thanos

Started by Enyalus13 pages

Originally posted by Omega Vision
What are you dense? He's a Kryptonian from before the Crisis, ergo PC Kryptonian.

That kinda all falls apart with Johns' retcon of him being on our Earth.

Originally posted by Enyalus
That kinda all falls apart with Johns' retcon of him being on our Earth.

Eh?

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Eh?

Him being from Earth Prime, IE, our Earth. Reading comics about himself, etc? Breaking into the DC Comics office in New York.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Him being from Earth Prime, IE, our Earth. Reading comics about himself, etc? Breaking into the DC Comics office in New York.

But clyde wincham reads comic books too, so he could stop SMP as that makes him the mutant from 'our' earth.

Yeah, Clyde could stop SMP. Doesn't have anything to do with anything.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Yeah, Clyde could stop SMP. Doesn't have anything to do with anything.

Im making fun of the idea that he is from our earth as they both simply belong to realities where comic books depicting the 616 and dcu mainstream happen to exist and that doesnt make said realities in-comics portrayals of 'our' earth.

Originally posted by 753
Im making fun of the idea that he is from our earth as they both simply belong to realities where comic books depicting the 616 and dcu mainstream happen to exist and that doesnt make said realities in-comics portrayals of 'our' earth.

He broke into the DC Comics offices in New York and Dan Didio and other DC staff were shown being threatened by him. So yes. Its our world he exists in.

Marvel makes comic books out of their actual comic books, shown in She-Hulk books among other things, so Clyde's thing doesn't matter.

DC sometime does the same, as shown just this week in Power Girl #10.

Originally posted by Enyalus
He broke into the DC Comics offices in New York and Dan Didio and other DC staff were shown being threatened by him. So yes. Its our world he exists in.

Marvel makes comic books out of their actual comic books, shown in She-Hulk books among other things, so Clyde's thing doesn't matter.

DC sometime does the same, as shown just this week in Power Girl #10.

I did read these issues because they had Prime in them and it was ok. I hope they don't continue to do this stuff as it will get old.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on what?

Based on the fact that Thanos sucks. 💃

Originally posted by shokosugi
Based on the fact that Thanos sucks. 💃
That's an example of how not to debate.

Originally posted by shokosugi
Based on the fact that Thanos sucks. 💃
Originally posted by quanchi112
That's an example of how not to debate.
And it's an example of how to get warnings and bans.

Originally posted by Badabing
And it's an example of how to get warnings and bans.
You're giving nicamarvin ideas.

Originally posted by Enyalus
He broke into the DC Comics offices in New York and Dan Didio and other DC staff were shown being threatened by him. So yes. Its our world he exists in.

Marvel makes comic books out of their actual comic books, shown in She-Hulk books among other things, so Clyde's thing doesn't matter.

DC sometime does the same, as shown just this week in Power Girl #10.

There should be a near endless number of realities with dan didio an dc comics in them in the DC/wildstorm multiverse. Same goes for marvel.

Originally posted by 753
There should be a near endless number of realities with dan didio an dc comics in them in the DC/wildstorm multiverse. Same goes for marvel.

Come again?

Originally posted by Enyalus
Come again?

I don't know how to make it any more clear. What makes you think SMP's reality is the only one that has a publisher called DC comics and a Didio? The idea behind the alternate realities used in comics is that any conceivable story and variation of it can be found in some reality. This has been shown again and again, and just like there are alternate versions of superman and no-name characters, there should be alternate versions of Didio and DC comics in the DC fictional multiverse.

Winchan's reality isnt the only one in the marvel omniverse to have comics depicting the 616 either.

It's 4th Wall shit, 753. Johns said as much. Give it up. In the other 51 universes that comprise the DC Multiverse, nothing of the sort has been mentioned or even hinted at.

Originally posted by 753
Winchan's reality isnt the only one in the marvel omniverse to have comics depicting the 616 either.

616 universe has comics depicted events that happened in 616 reality. Marvel has nothing to do with DC.

Originally posted by Enyalus
It's 4th Wall shit, 753. Johns said as much. Give it up. In the other 51 universes that comprise the DC Multiverse, nothing of the sort has been mentioned or even hinted at.

616 universe has comics depicted events that happened in 616 reality. Marvel has nothing to do with DC.

Yes it is 4 wall shit, which is why it's not 'our' earth, it's the same as she-hulk beating her writers or deadpool killing his readers in the 616, but I'm tired of this.

Originally posted by 753
Yes it is 4 wall shit, which is why it's not 'our' earth, it's the same as she-hulk beating her writers or deadpool killing his readers in the 616, but I'm tired of this.

The instances you refer to, the writers being beaten up or Deadpool tying up his editors, etc, occur on 'our' Earth, not in the 616 reality. The character from 616 supposedly breaks the '4th Wall' and comes to 'our' Earth do that those things. A lot like Mxy in World's Funnest.

Superboy Prime is a 4th Wall character per the Johns retcon, not really a PC Kryptonian.

this is what I'm trying to say

"In the original DC Multiverse, Earth-Prime was presented as the "real" Earth, the actual reality where the readers lived, DC Comics operated as a publisher and all superheroes are fictional. However, Earth Prime became an alternate reality in its first appearance in Flash #179 (May, 1968), when the Flash (Barry Allen) accidentally travels there from Earth-One by been pushed by a creature called The Nok. The Flash, stranded, contacts DC Comics editor Julius Schwartz, who helps him construct a cosmic treadmill to return to Earth One. Eventually it was stated that the writers of DC Comics of Earth Prime unconsciously base their stories on the adventures of the heroes on Earth-One and Earth-Two."

My point is that if it were really supposed to be 'our' earth, it wouldn't have superhumans in it. 4th wall awareness doesnt make a character from our earth.