Thanos vs. Flash, Black Adam, Captain Comet(Classic) and Wonder Woman

Started by KuRuPT Thanosi10 pages
Originally posted by fangirl101
I gave my reasoning with examples. Now refute my reasoning with examples of your own or shut the hell up.

Fangirl, by your own words the Drax incident proves that his personal shields can cover his whole body. Your choosing to say it's amis and doesn't mesh with prior showings, but it's still canon and can only be seen as a personal shield which covered his WHOLE body. That instance alone flies in the face of what your claiming. You have no proof what so ever that the drax instance was just a mistake. You have no proof that Thanos can't erect a full body personal shield without tech as the drax scene already proves. You choose to not accept it but it happened.

Fangirl?

Slight problem here. Fangirl's opinion actually has logic and consistent showings behind it.

Now, I'm not saying Thanos can't make shields around his whole body, his powers easily allow for that. But there is another solution.

That Drax was going to go through any kind of barrier to get to Thanos. That it was just a general energy barrier busting field.

Either that or Fangirl is right and the writer missed the memo. Haven't read enough on those 2 to be sure.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Fangirl, by your own words the Drax incident proves that his personal shields can cover his whole body. Your choosing to say it's amis and doesn't mesh with prior showings, but it's still canon and can only be seen as a personal shield which covered his WHOLE body. That instance alone flies in the face of what your claiming. You have no proof what so ever that the drax instance was just a mistake. You have no proof that Thanos can't erect a full body personal shield without tech as the drax scene already proves. You choose to not accept it but it happened.

His whole arguement is conjecture and has nothing to support it. Hes basing his belief that thanos cant create full body energy of the fact that prior to the drax incident he hadnt seen it done and hence has manufactured a bogus theory never ever shown in comics. First of all the whole idea that :

""just because he hasnt done it prior to that incident it must hve been a mistake"

is entirely fallacious. The assumption is made that thanos not creating full body energy shields prior to that incident was as a result of his inability to do so rather than his choice not to. This laughable assumption cannot be proven by anything on panel as it has never been stated, implied or otherwise suggested. So already the crux of the entire argument is baseless.

The other huge flaw in that arguement is the belief in itself that

"thanos hasnt erected a full body energy shield before"

As i showed earlier, he did erect a full body shield around vision. Therefore that incident is unequivocal proof that thanos has infact erected a full body shield and thus is capable of such. Consequently him not doing it to himself prior to the Drax incident was obviously a matter of choice and not do to his inability.

The whole argument is simply a result of the refusal to accept whats explicitly shown on panel because it doesnt fit his own rationalizations.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Slight problem here. Fangirl's opinion actually has logic and consistent showings behind it.

Now, I'm not saying Thanos can't make shields around his whole body, his powers easily allow for that. But there is another solution.

That Drax was going to go through any kind of barrier to get to Thanos. That it was just a general energy barrier busting field.

Either that or Fangirl is right and the writer missed the memo. Haven't read enough on those 2 to be sure.

No, it is completely irrational to buy into her theory especially considering the fact that the one instance where it covers his backside that she wants to throw it out.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Team stomps him.
How so?

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Fangirl's opinion actually has logic and consistent showings behind it.

Haven't read enough on those 2 to be sure.

How would you know that?

Originally posted by Mindset
How would you know that?
I told him 😉

Originally posted by Mindset
How would you know that?
👆

Thanos created one in the Galactus instance, and in the Omega instance...

I don't know though... Trick said FG's argument was based off of facts.

teams wins

Originally posted by quanchi112
How so?
ask fangirl

Originally posted by kgkg
ask fangirl
Why? I have heard her argument and now I'd like to hear yours.

Originally posted by Mekrob
Thanos created one in the Galactus instance, and in the Omega instance...

I don't know though... Trick said FG's argument was based off of facts.

IMO those were both prep shield Thanos was planing for Omega/Galactus in both cases he knew an attack would occur by someone more powerful than himself.

Originally posted by kgkg
IMO those were both prep shield Thanos was planing for Omega/Galactus in both cases he knew an attack would occur by someone more powerful than himself.

Against Galactus? He went to talk. He was anticipating Galactus being reasonable...those were standard.

Originally posted by kgkg
IMO those were both prep shield Thanos was planing for Omega/Galactus in both cases he knew an attack would occur by someone more powerful than himself.
Not against Galactus. He didn't go there to attack him and when he decided to do so he put up his available shielding.

Originally posted by kgkg
IMO those were both prep shield Thanos was planing for Omega/Galactus in both cases he knew an attack would occur by someone more powerful than himself.
Interesting...

Seeing as he only had a second to activate all his personal shields in the Galactus scenario, and iirc, he activated his shields after Omega was throwing his spirit bomb.

Explain how this means he can't create a full body shield though. 🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
Not against Galactus. He didn't go there to attack him and when he decided to do so he put up his available shielding.
Just because he went to talk does not mean he didn't gave back up. It could be his normal shield but my point was that he knew that he could get attack.

It was random well nothing is really random with thanos is it's hard to gauge what is prep tech and what is not

Originally posted by kgkg
Just because he went to talk does not mean he didn't gave back up. It could be his normal shield but my point was that he knew that he could get attack.

It was random well nothing is really random with thanos is it's hard to gauge what is prep tech and what is not

Can you explain the relevance of your point?

He knows he's coming to fight a team...

Originally posted by Mekrob
Interesting... Seeing as he only had a second to activate all his personal shields in the Galactus scenario, and iirc, he activated his shields after Omega was throwing his spirit bomb.
and you can't prep for powerful shields? Taking a second to activate doesn't mean prep was not involved

[QUOTE]Explain how this means he can't create a full body shield though. 🙂

Am not arguing that :/ imo he can