Anti-Mxyzptlk team

Started by Galan0075 pages
Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Makes sense. 👆

Mekrob Dead

Not really, but it's fact.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

It's one of those facts that changes from thread to thread. 👆

Mekrob Dead

That's why it's called convenience.

You don't have to accept anything used against you that you normally use, as long as you can pick and choose.

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by LDHZenkai

if mxy resets reality back to what it was before he arrived,
and it's shown that most people don't remember him being there,
then why would anyone elses Bio have him in it?

That wouldn't make sense.


When did Mxy reset anything, even one person's mind let alone reality?

How can it make sense
if you're now making up scenarios that never took place in the cross-over.

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Galan007

Mxy was referenced a few times in IM's official Marvel bio. So he apparently does have something to do with Marvel cosmology, at some level (however minute it may be.)


Mxy has nothing to do with Marvel cosmology,
except for his one and only single appearance in a cross-over,
heck by that logic,
the entire justice league (or whatever nicknames were used) is part of Marvel's cosmology.

But actually,
a subtle indirect vague reference in a single bio is all Mxy has to do with Marvel,
and it isn't even Mxy, it's a nickname that alludes to it being Mxy.

Originally posted by Galan007

So now a character has to be mentioned in more than one official Marvel bio for their appearance to be canonical?


I've yet to see Mxy's name in any Marvel bio at all.

That's what I got.

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Mekrob

Do you remember Scathan?


Originally posted by Mekrob

he was only mentioned once, maybe twice.


Scathan appeared in an official canon alternate Marvel Universe. (not some cross-over)
Scathan was mentioned across an entire arc situated in an official canon Marvel arc. (not some cross-over)
Scathan was also mentioned by name again,
in the proceeding GOTG arc after the whole Protege incident.

Scathan (by name) was mentioned/referenced in the LT's official Handbook bio,
and the Celestials official Handbook bio,
and the GOTG's official Handbook bio.

(3 official Marvel Handbooks)

Unlike the other cat that only appeared in a Marvel cross-over,
and was only reference (not by name) in IM's bio,
even though Silver Surfer was part of that cross-over,
for some odd reason, nothing is mentioned in SS' Handbook bio,
not even the vaguest of allusions, yet, it's canon. 😐

This was not a good comparison B.

Mekrob Dead

lol, way to take a small example way too literally

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Mekrob

lol, way to take a small example way too literally


Nah, you were making a point addressing my point,
there's nothing wrong with that btw, (you know I value your thoughts)
it's just that your point falls short in its purpose imo according to what I just posted.

Now if you were being classic B (king of sarcasm)
then my bad for not catching that. 😛

I do love your wit though (sincerely) it's untouchable if you ask me.

Mekrob Dead

I just used the first character that popped in my head that I didn't think had many bio appearances. 😐

Which was basically in response to this implication that he has to be in more than one bio to be worthy:

"Just let me know when you find any nameless subtle indirect reference to Mxy
in any other bio aside from IM's.

Then you can make a statement like that with weight behind it."

LDHZenkai Evergreen Oldboy

Originally posted by Mr Master
When did Mxy reset anything, even one person's mind let alone reality?

How can it make sense
if you're now making up scenarios that never took place in the cross-over.


seriously? you haven't read any of the stories where mxy does something, then leaves, and no one remembers it but superman? did you read emperor joker? Where Joker kept changing reality and no one knew what was going on because he changed their memories? Then at the end of it mxy reset everything. But like I said it apparently doesn't matter whats on panel to you, you're still going to say mxy doesn't have the feats so I'm not going to bother coming back here and trying to argue with you. If you doubt what I've said go read the comic book again I guess. If you still don't understand then I don't know what to tell you..oh and for the record...the writers made up all the scenarios i mentioned. So no i wasn't making them up...i don't work for DC.

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Mekrob

I just used the first character that popped in my head that I didn't think had many bio appearances.

Which was basically in response to this implication that he has to be in more than one bio to be worthy:

"Just let me know when you find any nameless subtle indirect reference to Mxy
in any other bio aside from IM's.

Then you can make a statement like that with weight behind it."


Precisely, and using Scathan was a bad example,
since Scathan has appeared in an actual official Marvel arc (not cross-overs)
and has been referenced (by name) in three separate official Marvel Handbooks. 😛

Sheesh B, you know I'm thorough bad boy.

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by LDHZenkai

seriously? you haven't read any of the stories where mxy does something, then leaves, and no one remembers it but superman? did you read emperor joker? Where Joker kept changing reality and no one knew what was going on because he changed their memories? Then at the end of it mxy reset everything. But like I said it
apparently doesn't matter whats on panel to you, you're still going to say mxy doesn't have the feats so I'm not going to bother coming back here and trying to argue with you. If you doubt what I've said go read the comic book again I guess. If you still don't understand then I don't know what to tell you..oh and for the record...the writers made up all the scenarios i mentioned. So no i wasn't making them up...i don't work for DC.


hum

What does any of this have to with Mxy in the Marvel cross-over?

You think you're slick,
you specifically were trying to say
that Mxy erased reality's memory in the Marvel cross-over,
and you know you were trying to say this by adding ...
actually ... see for yourself ...

... right here below:

Originally posted by Mr Master

Just let me know when you find any nameless subtle indirect reference to Mxy

in any other bio aside from IM's.


Originally posted by LDHZenkai

if mxy resets reality back to what it was before he arrived,

and it's shown that most people don't remember him being there,

then why would anyone elses Bio have him in it?


Nice try.

Mekrob Dead

Originally posted by Mr Master
Precisely, and using Scathan was a bad example,
since Scathan has appeared in an actual official Marvel arc (not cross-overs)
and has been referenced (by name) in three separate official Marvel Handbooks. 😛

Sheesh B, you know I'm thorough bad boy.

Jesus... it was an off the top of my head example.

So what exactly is the point of bringing up the amount of bio appearances if you have to be in an official Marvel arc?

No amount of bio appearances will mean anything if we're using your new (?) logic.

Also... wut... at your last part.

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Mekrob

Jesus... it was an off the top of my head example.


Cool, I won't condemn/insult/or patronize you for it,
I told ya, I value your thoughts. 🙂

All I said was, it was a bad example.

Originally posted by Mekrob
So what exactly is the point of bringing up the amount of bio appearances if you have to be in an official Marvel arc?

No amount of bio appearances will mean anything if we're using your new (?) logic.


Right again, you're on a roll true debater.

My point of bringing up the Scathan bio references is for differential purposes,
you mentioned Scathan, comparing him to the allusion that signifies Mxy in IM's bio,
I mentioned how Scathan has actually been reference by name in 3 Marvel bios,
and how Scathan has actually appeared in official Marvel canon arcs.

My point was to illuminate the vast difference between the two,
why one can be/is considered canon,
while the other, can't be/isn't considered canon,
and rightfully so for said reason in our little discussion good friend.

Originally posted by Mekrob

Also... wut... at your last part.


I'm all about the details.

Xplosive Restricted

Some of you are bringing crossover and why are you even debating that (it doesn't mean anything in this battle). The point is that Mxy can't win this battle, not even close, doesn't stand a slight chance.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

lol @ this page.

LDHZenkai Evergreen Oldboy

Originally posted by Mr Master
hum

What does any of this have to with Mxy in the Marvel cross-over?

You think you're slick,
you specifically were trying to say
that Mxy erased reality's memory in the Marvel cross-over,
and you know you were trying to say this by adding ...
actually ... see for yourself ...

... right here below:

Nice try.


So then we come back to it only counts are official if you think it does? Despite it being in an official bio, it's not official? And as to your comment about him calling mxy mixed pickles....go look at the mxy respect thread. And yea i know i said i wouldn't come back, but i had to. I never knew you apparently worked at dc/marvel and were allowed to decide whats official for them. Also, even if you disregard world funnest as not being canon did Mxy show powers in there that he hasn't in other comics? No...i didn't think so.

Mekrob Dead

Originally posted by Mr Master
Cool, I won't condemn/insult/or patronize you for it,
I told ya, I value your thoughts. 🙂

All I said was, it was a bad example.

Right again, you're on a roll true debater.

My point of bringing up the Scathan bio references is for differential purposes,
you mentioned Scathan, comparing him to the allusion that signifies Mxy in IM's bio,
I mentioned how Scathan has actually been reference by name in 3 Marvel bios,
and how Scathan has actually appeared in official Marvel canon arcs.

My point was to illuminate the vast difference between the two,
why one can be/is considered canon,
while the other, can't be/isn't considered canon,
and rightfully so for said reason in our little discussion good friend.

I'm all about the details.

K, you already said that, and I know.

But you're creeping me out on another note.

Philosophía "The devil made me do it"
Originally posted by Mekrob
But you're creeping me out on another note.

Overall, or just this part ?

Originally posted by Mr Master
Sheesh B, you know I'm thorough bad boy.