Originally posted by quanchi112
No one claimed he was amped.
When Thanos was ready for the shot, we see how he did - walked right through it.
Originally posted by quanchi112You haven't covered anything. Your farcical attempts to bring Odin down to Thanos' level are absurd. Had you read a smidgeon of Odin's fights you'd know this. Odin's fights range from the nonchalant, e.g. Annihilus, Mangog, Absorbing Man, Thanos to the dramatically close, e.g. Enchanters, Surtur, Seth. As it is, you obviously haven't read much of Odin.
I already covered the collateral damage argument.What comic is that second battle from? Was he just chained up?
Please name the issues and volume for these comics so I can familiarize myself with the situation.
I wouldn't have wasted my time on such an inane argument if there weren't other posters piping up here and there trying to support that nonsense. The second battle is from Thor vol. 2 #18. He is battling the Enchanters. This takes place after he fights the Dark Gods who had chained him.
Originally posted by quanchi112Because that is what happens when Odin becomes desperate. He draws the power of all of Asgard within him to topple his foe. In his first battle with Forsung, the Enchanter, he drew the power of Asgard within him and only released it to fight Forsung out of honor. He also drew the power of Asgard against the Celestials. But of course, how would I expect you to remember that since you obviously don't know squat about Odin... Forgive me. That is an example like many others, of Odin going all out and using all his power at his disposal, which includes Asgard. Whereas you laughably try to suggest that a nonchalant Odin, who doesn't use his Scepter, or grow gigantic, or rages across space and time, or states he is using his full might or draws power from Asgard.... somehow... against Thanos, he was actually using his full power.
It's been a while since I read that. I was confused as to why he would use a less powerful Odin as proof of him going all out.
hysterical
😐
No it's not funny. It's a stupid idea. One of the stupidest I've ever heard here on KMC.
Originally posted by EnyalusHe walked right through it but in the process he ate a lot of damage.
Only reason Thanos was knocked back into Asgard from the first Gungir shot, IMO, was because he was surprised by Odin's attack. If you look at it, they're both trashtalking, then suddenly Odin summons Gungir and fires.When Thanos was ready for the shot, we see how he did - walked right through it.
Originally posted by Silent MasterThat you keep making useless statements.
What is your point?
Originally posted by OneDumbG0Ok, so Odin's comment has to do with him battling them while unshackled.
You haven't covered anything. Your farcical attempts to bring Odin down to Thanos' level are absurd. Had you read a smidgeon of Odin's fights you'd know this. Odin's fights range from the nonchalant, e.g. Annihilus, Mangog, Absorbing Man, Thanos to the dramatically close, e.g. Enchanters, Surtur, Seth. As it is, you obviously haven't read much of Odin.I wouldn't have wasted my time on such an inane argument if there weren't other posters piping up here and there trying to support that nonsense. The second battle is from Thor vol. 2 #18. He is battling the Enchanters. This takes place after he fights the Dark Gods who had chained him.Because that is what happens when Odin becomes desperate. He draws the power of all of Asgard within him to topple his foe. In his first battle with Forsung, the Enchanter, he drew the power of Asgard within him and only released it to fight Forsung out of honor. He also drew the power of Asgard against the Celestials. But of course, how would I expect you to remember that since you obviously don't know squat about Odin... Forgive me. That is an example like many others, of Odin going all out and using all his power at his disposal, which includes Asgard. Whereas you laughably try to suggest that a nonchalant Odin, who doesn't use his Scepter, or grow gigantic, or rages across space and time, or states he is using his full might or draws power from Asgard.... somehow... against Thanos, he was actually using his full power.
hysterical
😐
No it's not funny. It's a stupid idea. One of the stupidest I've ever heard here on KMC.
Odin didn't hold back. He didn't absorb the power of asgard or don his destroyer armor, but the comic clearly states that Thanos' upper limits have never been tested. Different writers see things differently. That is a point of mine that you cannot refute.
I never claimed to read every Odin appearance out there, But I've read enough of him to render an opinion. I also called you out on posting a weaker Odin against seth and explained the scenario.
I find it humorous how you used a weaker Odin against Seth as an example of him going all out.
Odin didn't prep for Thanos or absorb asgard's might, but the comic clearly showed Thanos is a peer. Read Odin's comments before he assumed Thanos was defeated.
You don't have to read every Odin story to figure out what happened in the blood and thunder fight. 😂
Originally posted by quanchi112What in god's name are you talking about? Odin was shackled and freed in Thor vol.2 #12. That scan against the Enchanters is from Thor vol.2 #18. Did you not read that arc at all? Oh wait. Obviously, you didn't and yet you feel like you can talk with this specious confidence as if you actually had a point. No, that statement has nothing to do with him being just unshackled. That statement is him realizing that he was being overpowered and had to fight with everything he had left.
Ok, so Odin's comment has to do with him battling them while unshackled.Odin didn't hold back. He didn't absorb the power of asgard or don his destroyer armor, but the comic clearly states that Thanos' upper limits have never been tested. Different writers see things differently. That is a point of mine that you cannot refute.
I never claimed to read every Odin appearance out there, But I've read enough of him to render an opinion. I also called you out on posting a weaker Odin against seth and explained the scenario.
I find it humorous how you used a weaker Odin against Seth as an example of him going all out.
Odin didn't prep for Thanos or absorb asgard's might, but the comic clearly showed Thanos is a peer. Read Odin's comments before he assumed Thanos was defeated.
You don't have to read every Odin story to figure out what happened in the blood and thunder fight.
You have no point to refute. Just a farcical and outlandish statement that doesn't have a single grain of truth or support within it. You've been utterly proven wrong that Odin wasn't holding back. Thus you are left with a holding back Odin who whipped on Thanos like he was a mule.
You didn't call out anything because I posted that to show what Odin going all out does. One of which is to draw Asgard's power within him and/or to grow immensely large. Neither of which he bothered to do with Thanos, because it was completely unnecessary. And here you are posturing like you've rebutted something? EPIC LULZ.
Why don't you read the fight and look at how Odin was nonchalant throughout the fight and too busy pontificating to bother bringing out his full power. A power we've seen demonstrated before clearly. And thus, Odin held back. And while holding back, he stomped on Thanos. What does that prove? They're not peers. And what do your statements suggesting they were peers prove? That your arguments are idiotic and ass-backwards. And what does your continuing posturing prove? That you'd actually keep extending this trainwreck of an argument and further exposing the utter lack of logic or credibility you ought to possess because you can't admit that Odin is far superior to Thanos. Why do you do this? Who cares. You've got nothing.
You don't need to read every Odin fight to know what happened in Blood and Thunder, only two or thee of them to know that Odin was holding back. And he still stomped on him. Peers? Epic. Phail. Nuff. Said.
Originally posted by quanchi112
I never said it wasn't.
Good. then you'll have no need to respond to this
Correct me if I’m wrong, but since Gungnir doesn’t amp Odin’s power, that just means that Odin was using more of his power after summoning it.
At the end of the day, it was still a un-amped Odin that was winning the fight.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0I never said I read the arc. I may give it a read in the coming months.
What in god's name are you talking about? Odin was shackled and freed in Thor vol.2 #12. That scan against the Enchanters is from Thor vol.2 #18. Did you not read that arc at all? Oh wait. Obviously, you didn't and yet you feel like you can talk with this specious confidence as if you actually had a point. No, that statement has nothing to do with him being just unshackled. That statement is him realizing that he was being overpowered and had to fight with everything he had left.You have no point to refute. Just a farcical and outlandish statement that doesn't have a single grain of truth or support within it. You';ve been utterly proven wrong that Odin wasn't holding back. Thus you are left with a holding back Odin who whipped on Thanos like he was a mule.
You didn't call out anything because I posted that to show what Odin going all out does. One of which is to draw Asgard's power within him and/or to grow immensely large. Neither of which he bothered to do with Thanos, because it was completely unnecessary. And here you are posturing like you've rebutted something? EPIC LULZ.
Why don't you read the fight and look at how Odin was nonchalant throughout the fight and too busy pontificating to bother bringing out his full power. A power we've seen demonstrated before clearly. And thus, Odin held back. And while holding back, he stomped on Thanos. What does that prove? They're not peers. And what do your statements suggesting they were peers prove? That your arguments are idiotic and ass-backwards. And what does your continuing posturing prove? That you'd actually keep extending this trainwreck of an argument and further exposing the utter lack of logic or credibility you ought to possess because you can't admit that Odin is far superior to Thanos. Why do you do this? Who cares. You've got nothing.
You don't need to read every Odin fight to know what happened in Blood and Thunder, only two or thee of them to know that Odin was holding back. And he still stomped on him. Peers? Epic. Phail. Nuff said.
Odin never whipped on Thanos like he was a mule. Thanos laughed off blasts, ran through blasts, challenged him for control of gungir, etc. Odin demolished the Surfer, but held Thanos in high regard before the fight even stopped.
He admitted he was out to kill him and didn't even beat him into submission. If he was so above him he should have done it. He had ample time to do so.
So, because a writer doesn't have Odin grow to supersizes then he wasn't going all out? Ridiculous. Odin defeated Seth with less power than he had against Thanos. That's one of the poorest examples I have ever seen.
I guess you want to ignore the tone of this comic and Odin's comments and look to other fights written by other writers to demonstrate what this writer meant.
🙄
Originally posted by Silent MasterI never said otherwise.
Good. then you'll have no need to respond to thisCorrect me if I’m wrong, but since Gungnir doesn’t amp Odin’s power, that just means that Odin was using more of his power after summoning it.
At the end of the day, it was still a un-amped Odin that was winning the fight.