Thor vs Thanos

Started by OneDumbG033 pages

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
So, then are you saying that lack of Odin sleep in any one of this fights means he wasn't exerting himself? Is that your new statement?
Don't put words into my mouth. Not only have you not read the circumstances behind those scans, you've completely misunderstood the point I was asserting by posting those scans. The point is this: We have seen Odin going all-out before. And none of the aspects present in those fights was present in his fight against Thanos. Thus Odin was holding back against Thanos.

Each of those scans depict Odin going all-out, because he either: (i) goes into Odin-sleep; (ii) states he is going all-out; (iii) uses desperate maneuvers such as absorbing all the power of Asgard; or (iv) outright dies in a cataclysmic battle. What don't you get? How else do you quantify when Odin is not holding back? If you don't want to rely on Odin going into his Odinsleep, or the existence of collateral damage, or his statements, or his desperate maneuvers or his actual deaths, you have no other fight by Odin that could legitimately be characterized as Odin not holding back his power. The only other fights you have are Odin's outright curbstomping of Mangog, Annihilus, Loki, Absorbing Man and Thanos' fight.

The cogency of your argument is eminently revealed by the switch in your argumentation tactics. A switch which involves nothing more than ignoring every fight that Odin has, which clearly is not a curbstomp in his favor. By such fallacious logic, you hope to cut off any comparison to Thanos' fight that would suggest Odin wasn't going all out. That's not logic or argumentation. It's a loser.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Don't put words into my mouth. Not only have you not read the circumstances behind those scans, you've completely misunderstood the point I was asserting by posting those scans. The point is this: We have seen Odin going all-out before. And none of the aspects present in those fights was present in his fight against Thanos. Thus Odin was holding back against Thanos.

Each of those scans depict Odin going all-out, because he either: (i) goes into Odin-sleep; (ii) states he is going all-out; (iii) uses desperate maneuvers such as absorbing all the power of Asgard; or (iv) outright dies in a cataclysmic battle. What don't you get? How else do you quantify when Odin is not holding back? If you don't want to rely on Odin going into his Odinsleep, or the existence of collateral damage, or his statements, or his desperate maneuvers or his actual deaths, you have no other fight by Odin that could legitimately be characterized as Odin not holding back his power. The only other fights you have are Odin's outright curbstomping of Mangog, Annihilus, Loki, Absorbing Man and Thanos' fight.

The cogency of your argument is eminently revealed by the switch in your argumentation tactics. A switch which involves nothing more than ignoring every fight that Odin has, which clearly is not a curbstomp in his favor. By such fallacious logic, you hope to cut off any comparison to Thanos' fight that would suggest Odin wasn't going all out. That's not logic or argumentation. It's a loser.

so you say odin was holding back in the fight with thanos...so why cant i say the same for thanos...he was walked through odins blast to grab his weapon...im gonna say that could be a good reason why he was injured like he was.

Didnt odin say he has not faced anybody like that in eons...i wanna say he wanst holding back...it looks like thanos is trying to show that he can take odins best and still stand

thanos takes thor

It is clear that Thanos is hella durable against blasts under Galactus level. Thor's only chance would be to smash him with Mjolnir.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Odin looked more powerful against Seth than anyone he ever faced affecting the multiverse. By his logic then he held back against the Celestials.
not at all.

odin and co. put all their collective power and souls' into the destroyer, then that suit was slagged...and odin died.

and then later the two sentient cubes kubik and kosmos stated that their power was multiversal, yet the celestials still tea bag them with ease.

one celestial is beyond multiversal in power.

ok.

Current Thor get smashed

Thor with the D.A. kill Thanos

Originally posted by psycho gundam
not at all.

odin and co. put all their collective power and souls' into the destroyer, then that suit was slagged...and odin died.

and then later the two sentient cubes kubik and kosmos stated that their power was multiversal, yet the celestials still tea bag them with ease.

one celestial is beyond multiversal in power.

Multiversal and what not is all fine and dandy but it doesn't mean one with multiversal feats can't be beat by one with multiversal feats.

That's my point. The Celestials have never affected the multiverse as far as I am aware but can beat very powerful beings into the dirt.

I loved issue 300 of Thor by the way. I miss classic asgard.

Originally posted by bbrem123
so you say odin was holding back in the fight with thanos...so why cant i say the same for thanos...he was walked through odins blast to grab his weapon...im gonna say that could be a good reason why he was injured like he was.

Didnt odin say he has not faced anybody like that in eons...i wanna say he wanst holding back...it looks like thanos is trying to show that he can take odins best and still stand

thanos takes thor

👆