Pre Retcon Beyonder vs Mr Mxyzptlk · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

Doom and Gloom Senior Member

Pre Retcon Beyonder vs Mr Mxyzptlk

outcome?

Xplosive Restricted

Mxy doesn't stand any chance.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Based on feats, he certainly does..

Anyhow, been done.

cloud102 Senior Member

World's Funnest Mxy is the only one I see standing a chance.

xJLxKing Senior Member

Originally posted by cloud102
World's Funnest Mxy is the only one I see standing a chance.

They are all the same

Always, mxy wins because of his incredible, and dumb feats

cloud102 Senior Member

Originally posted by xJLxKing
They are all the same
Always, mxy wins because of his incredible, and dumb feats

Probably, but it was an Elseworld's story. He sort of popped up everywhere, so I guess there is just one Mxy.

LDHZenkai Evergreen Oldboy

There is just one mxy. And pre retcon beyonder hasn't shown any feats different than mxys. mxys were just displayed to be a joke where as his were displayed to put the multiverse in peril. Stalemate

Doom and Gloom Senior Member

I guess Mxy is capable of beating TOAA then

Doom and Gloom Senior Member

Originally posted by Xplosive
Mxy doesn't stand any chance.

At least somebody has it right

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by LDHZenkai
There is just one mxy. And pre retcon beyonder hasn't shown any feats different than mxys. mxys were just displayed to be a joke where as his were displayed to put the multiverse in peril. Stalemate

I agree.

LDHZenkai Evergreen Oldboy

Originally posted by Doom and Gloom
I guess Mxy is capable of beating TOAA then

TOAA isn't in DC so i don't know. The Presence hasn't done anything to stop mxy when him and batmite are destroying universes. And the spectre had absolutely no power to stop EJ. At the end of it Mxy was the one that had to put the universe back the way it was with the spectre watching to make sure he didn't add in his own stuff. And like has been said and argued a thousand times, mxy's feats that he's shown to be able to do are above anyone else in the comic book world. They're just portrayed as jokes and not taken as canon. But when you're doing a versus to ignore his feats and only go by the playful things he does to superman is pretty lame. Especially since theres no indication that the mxy that does stuff in elseworlds or all the other comics is a diff mxy. It's been shown that it's all the same guy and he can just travel to diff comics or wherever b/c he wants to. In my opinion he's too powerful a character to be portrayed in a menacing way so he never is. This makes everyone think he's weak, despite the fact that nothing has been shown to be able to stop him from doing something he wants (outside of the PIS zantanna stripping him of his powers which aren't even magical and shouldn't have been able to be taken away since they're tech based).

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by LDHZenkai
In my opinion he's too powerful a character to be portrayed in a menacing way so he never is.

This holds true much more than not. However, he was portrayed as such in the Mxy Twins.

This is the incarnation that actually showed the ability to retcon specific characters on a whim. The Mxy Twins also took Perry to Emperor Joker's universe (which had supposedly been wiped clean from all existence by both Mxy, and Spectre.) I'd call that another type of retcon as well.

LDHZenkai Evergreen Oldboy

Originally posted by Galan007
This holds true much more than not. However, he was portrayed as such in the Mxy Twins.
This is the incarnation that actually showed the ability to retcon specific characters on a whim. The Mxy Twins also took Perry to Emperor Joker's universe (which had supposedly been wiped clean from all existence by both Mxy, and Spectre.) I'd call that another type of retcon as well.

yea the mxy twns rock. flying around deciding to retcon stuff to make it fit better to their convo.

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!

Originally posted by LDHZenkai
This makes everyone think he's weak, despite the fact that nothing has been shown to be able to stop him from doing something he wants (outside of the PIS zantanna stripping him of his powers which aren't even magical and shouldn't have been able to be taken away since they're tech based).

😖hifty:

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

??

Astner The Ghost Who Walks

Powerscaling is fitting as they all operate on the same kind of power.

Classic Beyonder >> Classic Molecule man, the same way Classic Molecule man >> Captain America

Classic Molecule man > Living Tribunal

Classic Beyonder >> Classic Molecule man > Living Tribunal

The Living Tribunal held two Megaverses in his palm. Whereas Mxyzptlk destroyed a multiverse.

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!

Originally posted by Galan007
??

He said "nothing has been shown to be able to stop him from doing something he wants" ...

Well, Mxy wanted to play. Superman scared him off.

I also have a comic where Kull threatens to beat him up and he concedes...later on, a rabbit one-shots Kull. [/contextleftout]

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Astner
Powerscaling is fitting as they all operate on the same kind of power.
Classic Beyonder >> Classic Molecule man, the same way Classic Molecule man >> Captain America
Classic Molecule man > Living Tribunal
Classic Beyonder >> Classic Molecule man > Living Tribunal
The Living Tribunal held two Megaverses in his palm. Whereas Mxyzptlk destroyed a multiverse.

A+B+C. 👆

Ohh and the 'LT holding twin Megaverses' thing.... Yeah, to my knowledge it was only referenced in one official Marvel bio. Thus, it is non-canon.

😉

Originally posted by Enyalus
He said "nothing has been shown to be able to stop him from doing something he wants" ...
Well, Mxy wanted to play. Superman scared him off.
I also have a comic where Kull threatens to beat him up and he concedes...later on, a rabbit one-shots Kull. [/contextleftout]

That's Mxy's 'usual' character though. I'm sure you don't think lesser characters like those, are truly above him in any way/shape/form?

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!

Originally posted by Galan007
That's Mxy's 'usual' character though. I'm sure you don't think lesser characters like those, are truly above him in any way/shape/form?

Annataz might be. 😈

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Enyalus
Annataz might be. 😈

Except Prime specifically stated that she was not as powerful as Mxy:

Hence the reason I've always viewed her being able to do anything to him, as PIS. biscuits