Classic Thor vs Thanos · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

kgkg Vigilante

Thanos wins 10/10

quanchi112 Disney

Also the first time Thor and Thanos threw down Thanos was much less powerful back then as he was pre' ann death. Thor back then didn't even defeat him with help. Thor has been defeated by much less than Thanos. Thanos is a peer of Odin while he looks down on top tiers.

Avlon Godot Brew#107

Originally posted by Enyalus
I'm not referring to a battle. I'm referring to when In-Betweener was inside of his sphere. He had his full powers while he was inside of them. It took he and Thanos blasting them in order to shatter the fields. He was attempting to keep up with IB's output, and doing a fine job of it.[/B]

Doesn't change the fact that he would still be grossly outmatched in a battle. The blasts don't really mean anything in that case.

Originally posted by Enyalus ...I just posted it. End of the battle, Thanos was uninjured, and Thor was being blasted back with Mjolnir dropped. That was with help.[/B]

Strange. In another thread with Odin and Thanos being discussed in pretty much the exact same scenario, it's being debated that Thanos is an equal to Odin...hmmm.

Originally posted by Enyalus Or Thanos could've matter manipulated Thor, considering he has those abilities. Or mindraped him. Or did his T-Vo-esque thing (Mind Sync Time Warp). Or blasted him with something other than eyebeams...
Thanos didn't use his abilities to their fullest, either. [/B]

Mjolnir > Warlock who at that time was above Thanos durability in terms of matter manip. Mindrape? Perhaps. MSTW? It's only been shown once and it was a specific case if I remember correctly.

Either way, Thor could still get wins if he isn't jobbing. Thanos durability is the biggest threat against a non jobbing Thor.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Avlon
Doesn't change the fact that he would still be grossly outmatched in a battle. The blasts don't really mean anything in that case.
Strange. In another thread with Odin and Thanos being discussed in pretty much the exact same scenario, it's being debated that Thanos is an equal to Odin...hmmm.
Mjolnir > Warlock who at that time was above Thanos durability in terms of matter manip. Mindrape? Perhaps. MSTW? It's only been shown once and it was a specific case if I remember correctly.
Either way, Thor could still get wins if he isn't jobbing. Thanos durability is the biggest threat against a non jobbing Thor.

How can Thor defeat him even though he never has? Who has a nonjobbing Thor defeated on Thanos' level before? Name me a top tier that defeated Thanos on panel in a fair fight.

Avlon Godot Brew#107

Originally posted by quanchi112
How can Thor defeat him even though he never has? Who has a nonjobbing Thor defeated on Thanos' level before? Name me a top tier that defeated Thanos on panel in a fair fight.

Masterson Thor put Thanos down...a Thanos enhanced by the power gem....

Thanos needed a plot device gun to defeat Thor with the same power up...

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!

Originally posted by Avlon
Doesn't change the fact that he would still be grossly outmatched in a battle. The blasts don't really mean anything in that case.

Originally posted by Enyalus
That's only true via Godblast. Prior to his latest upgrades, Thanos' energy output was nearly on par with the In-Betweener.

...That was your initial point. That's what I was addressing.

Originally posted by Avlon
Strange. In another thread with Odin and Thanos being discussed in pretty much the exact same scenario, it's being debated that Thanos is an equal to Odin...hmmm.

Thanos received a massive amp by Death when he was resurrected. That's what he took on Odin with. Also, why you treat me like I'm Quanchi, I don't know. I also don't get what you're wanting to lowball Thanos. You've clearly read some of his stuff. He's a pretty cool character. 😛

And he's got about a 3% chance of losing to classic Thor. I've done the calculations. h1 helped me with 'em, so I know they're correct.

Originally posted by Avlon
Mjolnir > Warlock who at that time was above Thanos durability in terms of matter manip.

...Wha? I'm not sure I got the last sentence. Thanos killed Warlock with one blow prior to Warlock returning. And uh, he returned via Lord Chaos and Master Order's interference (and possible amp), along with being amped by the Soul Gem. Oh, and Thanos being caught off-guard.

Originally posted by Avlon
Mindrape? Perhaps. MSTW? It's only been shown once and it was a specific case if I remember correctly.

Thanos says he's used it before, but that was the first and only time he's used it on panel. He used it against Drax and was shocked that it didn't kill him, merely KO'd him....it had killed everyone else it was used on previously. But we both know Drax was made specifically to combat him, so...that might be why.

Originally posted by Avlon
Either way, Thor could still get wins if he isn't jobbing. Thanos durability is the biggest threat against a non jobbing Thor.

He's above Thor in durability, in strength, and as the IB example shows, in power output as well barring a Godblast. If he does pull the Godblast out, I certainly think it will injure Thanos and/or break through his shields. Whether it would injure him enough to give Thor an advantage and allow him the chance to win, is up in the air...

Thanos is clearly above top tier. That's been evident throughout his career. So he's not going to simply lose to top tiers for the majority. Especially after all of his upgrades and with his tech/shields in play.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Avlon
Masterson Thor put Thanos down...a Thanos enhanced by the power gem....
Thanos needed a plot device gun to defeat Thor with the same power up...

Thanos lowered his abilities to give the heroes in general a chance. He wasn't just facing Thor too by the way. Thor knocked him back, but then again so did Spiderman. Thanos defeated Thor with and without the power gem. Thanos wins at the end of the day while Thor doesn't. 🙂

Kris Blaze Restricted

Honestly.

What's keeping Thor from flying up and absorbing all of Thanos energy/releasing it back at him? It's easy to absorb energy with Mjolnir, and it doesn't redirect but AMPLIFIES the energy.

Philosophía "The devil made me do it"

The fact that you're not the one writing it.

Kris Blaze Restricted

Originally posted by Philosophía
The fact that you're not the one writing it.

Or am I? 😖hifty:

Uxas Khan Senior Member

Thanos would probably kill thor in a non pis/cis enviroment.

celestialdemon Down from the Upside

Thanos wins.

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
What's keeping Thor from flying up and absorbing all of Thanos energy/releasing it back at him? It's easy to absorb energy with Mjolnir, and it doesn't redirect but AMPLIFIES the energy.

Given that Thanos is also an energy manipulator, I'm doubting that Mjolnir would be able to do that...

That's like suggesting Quasar can drain the Odinforce out of Mjolnir when they fight.

Kris Blaze Restricted

Originally posted by Enyalus
Given that Thanos is also an energy manipulator, I'm doubting that Mjolnir would be able to do that...
That's like suggesting Quasar can drain the Odinforce out of Mjolnir when they fight.

How?

Thor's already done it :/

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
How?
Thor's already done it :/

Oh, are you talking about absorbing Thanos' energy blasts if/when he fires at him?

You made it sound like Mjolnir was gonna go up and absorb Thanos' life energies out of his body. 😐

Kris Blaze Restricted

Originally posted by Enyalus
Oh, are you talking about absorbing Thanos' energy blasts if/when he fires at him?
You made it sound like Mjolnir was gonna go up and absorb Thanos' life energies out of his body. 😐

Aaah.

Well he can do that too. He just wouldn't get an opportunity to. There's no reason to believe Thor can't drain his soul.

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Aaah.
Well he can do that too. He just wouldn't get an opportunity to. There's no reason to believe Thor can't drain his soul.

Oh come on, man. 😛

And, if you recall, even when Thor did absorb his blast and redirected it back at the Thanos clone x100 fold, the clone was blown backwards, but got up afterwards without a scratch on him.

I don't recall him being amped at that point in time by any artifacts, either.

Avlon Godot Brew#107

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thanos lowered his abilities to give the heroes in general a chance. He wasn't just facing Thor too by the way. Thor knocked him back, but then again so did Spiderman. Thanos defeated Thor with and without the power gem. Thanos wins at the end of the day while Thor doesn't. 🙂

He turned off his cosmic awareness...not his power.

And thanks for bringing up spidey. 😂

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Aaah.
Well he can do that too. He just wouldn't get an opportunity to. There's no reason to believe Thor can't drain his soul.

Like when Warlock did it to one of his clones?

I wonder if that would work with the original considering his servitude to death herself.

Enyalus MALE DOMINANCE!!!

Originally posted by Avlon
He turned off his cosmic awareness...not his power.
And thanks for bringing up spidey. 😂

That was an extremely retarded showing. I have no idea why Starlin did that. Six issues before that (Thanos Quest 1), he went toe-to-toe with Champion wielding the Power Gem, unamped. And held his own.

Starlin's waaay inconsistant. It was either PIS or Thanos lowered his power to make it a more interesting show for Lady Death to see.

Kris Blaze Restricted

Originally posted by Enyalus
Oh come on, man. 😛
And, if you recall, even when Thor did absorb his blast and redirected it back at the Thanos clone x100 fold, the clone was blown backwards, but got up afterwards without a scratch on him.
I don't recall him being amped at that point in time by any artifacts, either.

Without a scratch on him? He was still sent back. Besides, the damage that Thanos' otufit takes really seems to vary.