Mace Windu vs. Gorgon

Started by Battlehammer6 pages

Originally posted by Enyalus
...Anakin was there for the tail end of the battle in the movie...

Anakin dident walk in untill right when mace disarmed palp

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Anakin dident walk in untill right when mace disarmed palp

So, what, exactly is being contradicted? Slight edit, no big deal. As I said, the novel was released first. Reviewed personally by Lucas.

I've also given you two different sources explaining what Vaapad does. Is Mace fast? Hell yeah. Is he faster than Yoda or Sidious on his own? No way in hell. Those two have more force power than anyone besides Anakin. More force = more force to amp speed with, and deeper reserves to sustain it with.

Obi Wan > Sidious

Originally posted by Mindset
Obi Wan > Sidious

Not according to Yoda, who said he wasn't powerful enough to take on the Dark Lord. 馃槢

Originally posted by Enyalus
So, what, exactly is being contradicted? Slight edit, no big deal. As I said, the novel was released first. Reviewed personally by Lucas.

I've also given you two different sources explaining what Vaapad does. Is Mace fast? Hell yeah. Is he faster than Yoda or Sidious on his own? No way in hell. Those two have more force power than anyone besides Anakin. More force = more force to amp speed with, and deeper reserves to sustain it with.

were was it stated that it was reviewed personally by Lucas? Also it straight up controdicts the movie. Movie is the end all be all.

No they don't. For one Mace had the most whatever they had counts, untill arrival of anakin if not mistaken. He also uses his Vaapad to directly increases his speed which is why it name the Vaapad in the first place.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Not according to Yoda, who said he wasn't powerful enough to take on the Dark Lord. 馃槢
Yoda doesn't know anything tbh.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
were was it stated that it was reviewed personally by Lucas? Also it straight up controdicts the movie. Movie is the end all be all.

No they don't. For one Mace had the most whatever they had counts, untill arrival of anakin if not mistaken. He also uses his Vaapad to directly increases his speed which is why it name the Vaapad in the first place.


I already told you.

No. Yoda had the highest midichlorian count prior to Anakin. That's referenced by Qui-Gon in TPM.

Originally posted by Mindset
Yoda doesn't know anything tbh.

馃槀 True.

Originally posted by Enyalus
I already told you.

No. Yoda had the highest midichlorian count prior to Anakin. That's referenced by Qui-Gon in TPM.


yea the author blog........that impossiable to look up to see if it true or not.

In the movie? Becuases I dont recall that at all.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
yea the author blog........that impossiable to look up to see if it true or not.

I already went out of my way to provide you with two pieces of evidence. I'm not digging through his blog to provide you another piece that you'll ignore or explain away.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
In the movie? Becuases I dont recall that at all.

Yes. When Qui-Gon checks Anakin's blood and uploads the results to Obi-Wan on the Queen's spacecraft while they're stranded on Tatooine. Don't tell me you don't recall the "Over 20,00, that's higher than Master Yoda's" comment?

Originally posted by Enyalus

Yes. When Qui-Gon checks Anakin's blood and uploads the results to Obi-Wan on the Queen's spacecraft while they're stranded on Tatooine. Don't tell me you don't recall the "Over 20,00, that's higher than Master Yoda's" comment? [/B]


No not really, nor does that statement indicate that Yoda had the highest count.

Bottom line is that Mace did not have the highest midichlorian count in the Jedi Order at the time, nor will you ever find a source saying he did. If you want to try to prove it, be my guest.

Yoda's was highest. He was the most skilled/powerful in the Force. That's why he was Grandmaster of the Jedi Order for 400 years.