Duncan McCloud (Highlander) vs Blade

Started by Rogue Jedi4 pages

Which one had that guy from Pet Sematary in it, you know, where his head was sewn on and shit?

I would assume you mean the Kurgan.

Ramirez, becuase he was Sean Connery, was able to nearly cut off the Kurgan's head at the ruins back in 16 whatever. Kurgan then had a bunch of Metal Staples holding a massive scar in the 1980s...

That the dude your thinking of...?

'Cause if so: That be the first Highlander movie.

I think its the one you mentioned.

This is pathetically one sided.

From what we have seen. Blades' speed would dizzy Duncan. Duncan uses that slow ass broad sword. Blades strength, agility and skill dwarfs Duncan in all area's...,in my opinion.

Yeah but Christopher Lambert is immortal... Only another immortal can kill him. Therefore blade is fighting a losing battle.

been awhile since I've seen the blade movies but aren't Vampires immortal, blade included?

From what we have seen. Blades' speed would dizzy Duncan. Duncan uses that slow ass broad sword. Blades strength, agility and skill dwarfs Duncan in all area's...,in my opinion.

he uses the fastass katanna more regularly. and he's stronger than Connor's ever been now, esp now that he has Kell's quickening AND connor's.
as for the numbers, it's not duncan's fault that connor was born over a 100 years before him now is it? that's also why connor was "better" than him.

as for Duncan's feats, the entire series is a feat for him. mofo can't even die unless you cut his head off. blade's fast but he aint that skilled and his technique isn't even that impressive if you know something about sword fighting. he just flicks out the sword and it all looks pretty flashy but he isn't actually dong squat with it. duncan on the other hand has proper skill, not just speed. that and 400 years of experience and knowledge of all known and unknown sword fighting styles.

Duncan>Blade

~Sado

Originally posted by jinXed by JaNx
This is pathetically one sided.

From what we have seen. Blades' speed would dizzy Duncan. Duncan uses that slow ass broad sword. Blades strength, agility and skill dwarfs Duncan in all area's...,in my opinion.

Fact.

Originally posted by omgchos
Yeah but Christopher Lambert is immortal... Only another immortal can kill him. Therefore blade is fighting a losing battle.

Are you sure? I've only seen the first two Highlander movie's and from what i remember anyone can kill an immortal by decapitation.

Originally posted by jinXed by JaNx
Are you sure? I've only seen the first two Highlander movie's and from what i remember anyone can kill an immortal by decapitation.
Accurate.

ditto.

Originally posted by Sado22
he uses the fastass katanna more regularly. and he's stronger than Connor's ever been now, esp now that he has Kell's quickening AND connor's.
as for the numbers, it's not duncan's fault that connor was born over a 100 years before him now is it? that's also why connor was "better" than him.

as for Duncan's feats, the entire series is a feat for him. mofo can't even die unless you cut his head off. blade's fast but he aint that skilled and his technique isn't even that impressive if you know something about sword fighting. he just flicks out the sword and it all looks pretty flashy but he isn't actually dong squat with it. duncan on the other hand has proper skill, not just speed. that and 400 years of experience and knowledge of all known and unknown sword fighting styles.

Duncan>Blade

~Sado

I'm not trying to hate on Duncan, partner but Blade is a monster. I know in the movie's the fight choreography is chosen because it looks flashy but thats the goddamn point of blade. He is so fast and strong...,no one can keep up with him. Most of Blades choreography comes from escrimina and kendo but we're not arguing choreography. We're arguing skill. Now granted, Duncan has plenty of it but Blade was just born born with it. He is too fast and powerful. I just don't see it happening. From what i've seen of Duncan in the first two highlander movies, Duncan moved pretty slow, comparatively speaking.

Originally posted by jinXed by JaNx
I'm not trying to hate on Duncan, partner but Blade is a monster. I know in the movie's the fight choreography is chosen because it looks flashy but thats the goddamn point of blade. He is so fast and strong...,no one can keep up with him. Most of Blades choreography comes from escrimina and kendo but we're not arguing choreography. We're arguing skill. Now granted, Duncan has plenty of it but Blade was just born born with it. He is too fast and powerful. I just don't see it happening. From what i've seen of Duncan in the first two highlander movies, Duncan moved pretty slow, comparatively speaking.

You, sir, are correct. Even the "born" part. When Eric Brooks was born, he was "Blade" already in the sense that he was half Vamp, half human, already.

Originally posted by Robtard
The battle he had with the two vampire-ninja types in the being of Blade II was far more impressive and skilled than the Duncan's feats.

Granted, I don't recall much of the Highlander films besides the first one, as I either didn't watch them or only watched parts, as they were complete shit. So enlighten me with a scene from the Highlander films that trumps what Blade has done?

In Highlander: The Source Duncan fights the Guardian, an Immortal with Flash-like super-speed and super-strength (he ripped a man's head off with his bare hands).

In the first fight Duncan held his own quite well and in the second (where Duncan had gained super-speed too) he won.

Here is the first fight-

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1pczH7a5RM

Here is the second-

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zc-HUs53JuE&feature=related

Originally posted by jinXed by JaNx
From what i've seen of Duncan in the first two highlander movies, Duncan moved pretty slow, comparatively speaking.

Duncan wasn't even in the first two movies.

Duncan (played by Adrian Paul who is a real-life martial arts expert) was in the TV series, Highlander: Endgame and Highlander: The Source (the fourth and fifth movies respectively).

Anyway, Blade will put up a great fight but I'd say Duncan wins due to more than four centuries of battling highly trained swordsmen. Plus Duncan heals faster so he won't be slowed down by accumulated minor wounds while Blade will.

Blade stomps.

Blade was getting the better of Dracula in their sword fight and he's like 5,000 years old.

Doooooooooooooooooh. Correct.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u3YLY88-qcs&NR=1

Originally posted by chilled monkey
Duncan wasn't even in the first two movies.

Duncan (played by Adrian Paul who is a real-life martial arts expert) was in the TV series, Highlander: Endgame and Highlander: The Source (the fourth and fifth movies respectively).

Anyway, Blade will put up a great fight but I'd say Duncan wins due to more than four centuries of battling highly trained swordsmen. Plus Duncan heals faster so he won't be slowed down by accumulated minor wounds while Blade will.

Yeah, i know but i assumed that Duncan was bound to the same decree that a highlander dies after decapitation, regardless of how it happens.

You make a good point about Blade being slowed from blood loss but i really don't think Blade would sustain any major injuries. He is just far to fast and agile. I've only seen a few episodes of the Highlander show but from my combined knowledge of the Highlander universe i'm not aware of any Highlander facing a foe as deadly as Blade. I'm also not sure how Duncan would react to Blades incredible Strength. Blade would knock Duncan around like a rag doll.