Duncan McCloud (Highlander) vs Blade

Started by Rogue Jedi4 pages

I am pretty sure that anyone can chop off his head.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I am pretty sure that anyone can chop off his head.

Na it was stated that only another immortal can kill an immortal. And only by lopping off his head.

Originally posted by omgchos
Na it was stated that only another immortal can kill an immortal. And only by lopping off his head.
So if you or I chop off the head of a highlander? What then?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
So if you or I chop off the head of a highlander? What then?

Thats y i asked if it was incapacitation. Cuz hell always be alive just seperated. Unable to fight anymore.

Originally posted by omgchos
Thats y i asked if it was incapacitation. Cuz hell always be alive just seperated. Unable to fight anymore.
Well thats just as good then haermm "Come 'ere and I'll bite ya!!!"

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Well thats just as good then haermm "Come 'ere and I'll bite ya!!!"

Exactly. Friking black night man, someone should make a thread about him.

Ew.

Originally posted by Mindset
He is physically inferior in every way, how does he have every advantage?

Perhaps not every advantage, but Duncan-

* Is a better, more experienced swordsman (over 400 years expertise)
* Is much more accustomed to battling other skilled swordsman.
* Has the power and skill of every one of his vanquished foes.
* Heals faster.

Some of Duncan's resiliance feats-

* In "Double Jeopardy" Morgan D'Estaing stabs him with a dagger coated in curarae. Duncan still takes his head before 'dying' from the poison.
* In "Duende" Consone stabs him through the chest. Duncan seizes his arm and pushes his sword in deeper(!) then takes his head with a pair of daggers.
* In "Courage," Cullen rams him with a truck and slices the side of his neck. Duncan still wins the fight and beheads Cullen.

Originally posted by omgchos
Na it was stated that only another immortal can kill an immortal. And only by lopping off his head.

Beg your pardon but no. In the first movie Ramirez told Connor "if your head comes away from your neck, it's over." He said nothing about only Immortals could do it.

In "The Hunters," Darius was killed by renegade Watchers (Duncan knew an Immortal couldn't have done it because Darius was killed on holy ground). They nearly killed Fitz via guillotine as well.

In "One Minute to Midnight," Irena and Jacob Galati were beheaded by mortals (Irena was killed by James Horton and Jacob by Jack Shapiro).

Originally posted by chilled monkey
Beg your pardon but no. In the first movie Ramirez told Connor "if your head comes away from your neck, it's over." He said nothing about only Immortals could do it.

In "The Hunters," Darius was beheaded by renegade Watchers (Duncan knew an Immortal couldn't have done it because Darius was killed on holy ground).

In "One Minute to Midnight," Irena and Jacob Galati were beheaded by mortals (Irena was killed by James Horton and Jacob by Jack Shapiro)


Are those televison episodes? I mean your fisrt point is valid. But the other two mean nothing. If they are televison episodes.

Originally posted by omgchos
Are those televison episodes?

Yep. The closing episodes of Season's 1 and 4 respectively.

I mean your fisrt point is valid. But the other two mean nothing. If they are televison episodes.

Why is that? The series is part of overall continuity.

It's still part of the rules. If we could use every show/comic/graphic novel for every vs. thread it would make things too complicated. So only MOVIES can be referenced. It's called the MOVIE VS FORUM for a reason.

Yup, movies only.

technically, immortals just need to get their noggin lobbed off. in Highlander: the raven, the sidecharacter dude cuts this one immortal dude's head off but the quickening goes to Amanda.......then again, sidedude was actually immortal as well.

okay, nevermind 🙁

What if I have a shotgun and I BLOW an immortals head off? Same?

........don't complicate it 😠

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
What if I have a shotgun and I BLOW an immortals head off? Same?

As Ramirez says "if your head comes away from your neck, it's over."

Originally posted by Sado22
technically, immortals just need to get their noggin lobbed off. in Highlander: the raven, the sidecharacter dude cuts this one immortal dude's head off but the quickening goes to Amanda.......then again, sidedude was actually immortal as well.

okay, nevermind

Nick, and he was only a latent Immortal. At that point he hadn't died his first death (that happened in the finale.)

Originally posted by omgchos
It's still part of the rules. If we could use every show/comic/graphic novel for every vs. thread it would make things too complicated. So only MOVIES can be referenced. It's called the MOVIE VS FORUM for a reason.

I see, fair enough.

Duncan is a TV character. 99% of his feats come from TV. That rule doesn't make any sense for characters who originated in TV and starred in dozens of episodes and only had what, two films?