Wizards vs Mutants

Started by Dr Will Hatch40 pages

Wizards vs Mutants

Movie X Men vs everyone at Hogwarts. This includes villains such as the Brotherhood and the Death Eaters.

Well, considering Wizards can kill them with one spell, wizards own.

Really? Wouldn't Xavier do a mind wipe or something?

Dumbledore can surely pull some kind of spell to counter that.

What is he going to do against The Dark Phoenix?

Originally posted by Dr Will Hatch
What is he going to do against The Dark Phoenix?
Avada Kedavra.

Before she disintergrates him? 😉

Gonna be a shitoad of wizards, and the death eaters can apparate and fly around.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Dumbledore can surely pull some kind of spell to counter that.
How would he use a counter spell when his mind is shut down?

facepalmfacepalm

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
facepalmfacepalm
Care to elaborate?

Originally posted by Mindset
How would he use a counter spell when his mind is shut down?
Their minds will never be shut down. Occlumency.

Wtf is occlumency?

It means you can block telepathic attacks. I think Xaviers telepathy is stronger than any occlumency shown in the movies or books for that matter, but we can't know for sure.

It is a basic Wizard power, not really a spell.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occlumency#Legilimency_and_Occlumency

[edit] Legilimency and Occlumency
Legilimency is the magical skill of extracting feelings and memories from another person's mind — a form of magical "telepathy" (although Snape, an able practitioner of the art, dismisses the colloquial term as a drastic oversimplification). It also allows one to convey visions or memories to another person, whether real or imaginary. A witch or wizard possessing this skill is called a Legilimens, and can, for example, detect lies and deceit in another person, witness memories in another person's past, or "plant" false visions in another's mind.

The counter-skill to Legilimency is Occlumency (and its user, known as an Occlumens), by which one can compartmentalise one's emotions, or prevent a Legilimens from discovering thoughts or memories which contradict one's spoken words or actions.

Voldemort, Snape, and Dumbledore are all known to be quite skilled in Legilimency and Occlumency. Throughout the books, Snape is repeatedly said to be highly skilled in Occlumency. Voldemort is said to be the master of Legilimency by Snape, as he, in almost all cases, immediately knows during conversations if someone lies to him.

The skills are first mentioned in Order of the Phoenix, (though Harry gets the impression before that Snape can read minds) wherein Snape is instructed by Dumbledore to give Harry lessons in Occlumency. Whether as a result of negligence in Snape's instruction, or poor aptitude on Harry's part, Harry never made any progress in the skill, and as a result he was lured by Voldemort through a carefully calculated vision he falsely believed to be real. Only once has Harry managed to overcome Snape with the use of Occlumency, in Order of the Phoenix.[14] During the lesson, Harry notices that the Dementors become fainter and Snape becomes clearer.

Bellatrix Lestrange, Draco Malfoy, Narcissa Malfoy and Barty Crouch Jr may also have some skill in Occlumency, since Bellatrix was said to have taught Draco to shield his thoughts from Snape[HP6] and Narcissa's treachery is not detected when Voldemort asks her to check Harry's pulse after he has seemingly killed him.[HP7]

Legilimency and Occlumency are not part of the normal curriculum at Hogwarts, and most students would graduate without learning them. They seem to be considered a more advanced form of magic.

That would in no way prevent them from getting their minds shut down, all that does is possibly stop Xavier from reading their minds.

No, it shields ones mind from outside influence.

Edit: Legilimency and Occlumency are not part of the normal curriculum at Hogwarts, and most students would graduate without learning them. They seem to be considered a more advanced form of magic.

No, it shields it from certain outside influences, not all.

It even tells use which things it protects it from.

The wizards get their minds shut down.

You seriously can not even compare their "telepathy" to Xaviers, not even close in scope and power.

Xavier works on a psychic plane and can take on an astral form. He has home field advantage.