Storm Troopers vs. Starship Troopers

Started by Rogue Jedi7 pages

Nah, it's not that. What in a human body can stop a laser?

ST use lasers. SST use bullets.

We still do not have an agreement on which armor (ST or SST) can withstand which.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Nah, it's not that. What in a human body can stop a laser?

The body, as scene in the Leia being tagged and it didn't go through her. There are more examples of this.

In the end, both the lasers and bullets kill if they hit a vital area.

im just going by what the movies show us.

the movies show us that the lasers are incapable of going right through people.

so it doesnt matter how impossible that may or may not be, if the movie shows it then that is what happens.

RotJ shows us that storm trooper armor can be penetrated by wooden arrows. Return of the Jedi is primary canon, that's what RotJ shows, so thats how it works.

in my opinion, there isnt really anything to agree on.

Originally posted by Robtard
The body, as scene in the Leia being tagged and it didn't go through her. There are more examples of this.

In the end, both the lasers and bullets kill if they hit a vital area.

this is pretty much what it comes down too. the only exception being that a bullet wound has more side effects if the victim lives, compared to if someone is shot by a stormtroopers blaster. leia was shot by a blaster bolt in the shoulder but was still able to aim a gun well and was up partying a couple hours later, when the death star was destroyed, so the wound wasnt all that bad.

Okay. How about this:

Bullets kill. Lasers kill.

Agreed?

We have no set standard on the armament of the SST or the ST in this scenario.

I'd still like an answer to the anal?

Geez, never mind the laser argument.

Who is the more disciplined?

IMO?

The Starship Troopers are. Brutally trained without remorse.

We have never really had any real movie glimpse of the training of a Storm Trooper.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi

Who is the more disciplined?

Not sure, exactly.

The ST had trouble with ****ing Ewoks. While the SST held their ranks well when being swarmed by the Bugs.

Originally posted by Impediment
IMO?

The Starship Troopers are. Brutally trained without remorse.

We have never really had any real movie glimpse of the training of a Storm Trooper.

I'm talking about in action. I remember a few SST freaking in combat.

A few of the rookies in the first fight did. Later on, they didn't have that problem at all.

There's also the SST part 2. Only watched parts of it, as it was more ridiculous than the first. But the troops were hardened killers.

well if we go by the movies only their equipment and their potency has already been decided for us. and going by the movies only the stormtrooeprs have weaker weaponry and less effective training...

Numbers?

probably the imperials in my opinion.

Be nice to have a close figure. Possible? haermm

SST seem more organized in mass combat, if you ask me. The Bugs are a hardened foe, no? Much more hardened than any Imperial/Rebel enemy with a blaster. The Force is a valuable ally, but to what extent are we talking about here?

The SST showed much more emotion, IMO, because we related to them. The ST are rather ambiguous to the audience since we never see their face or relate to any of them. Most any ST will just fall after a few hits from a blaster.

SST are trained to fight big ass bugs, whereas ST are trained to fights humans. This, plus sheer numbers, advantage ST.

Big Bugs > humans, IMO.

If you want sheer numbers, then the bugs outclass the ST 10 to 1.

And the bugs always had the humans on the run. The only time the bugs didnt have them on the run is when the brain bug was there and Johnny had the nuke.