501st vs. Hogwarts

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Uh huh.

When Part II shows what Fiendfyre looks like, we'll know for certain. If the filmmakers decide to make a huge deal of it, and make it purple with red lightning, we'll know Dumbledore did not use it. Neither the book, nor the movie tell us what Dumbledore did. Plain and simple. If you want to jump to a conclusion without definitive evidence from Crabbe, you go right ahead.

No thanks, I'll stick to what is most logical: what Dumbles used fit 3/3 required traits and was only missing one unrequited trait.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Yup looking bleaker still for the dead wizard now. 😖hifty:

Absolutely useless dead wizards, as they cant cast it.
Precog informed Vader exactly WHEN to attack to avoid it, having seen it coming.

Sure. he'll dodge the fiendfyre, he'll avoid being vanished, he'll avoid being changed into a teacup, he'll avoid dozens of death spells flying at him, AND avoid being mind raped.

Pack it in, dude. Jedi are NO match for Wizards. Nor are Clones. This is curbstomp central, next stop, Anakin's right butt cheek.

You keep saying, yet all evidence points to massive stop of SW>>HP.

Post it then.

Wait, lemmee guess. "We all have!!!!"

Post it again. Quote, copy and paste.

Thought not, bladder full of hot air.

Looking......looking.........looking..........................

Looking..............................

Nope. Not once did I ever give the wizards a power that was not shown in the movies.

More strawspamming?

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Uh huh.

When Part II shows what Fiendfyre looks like, we'll know for certain.

Question. How would the Repello Muggletum charm play out?

They are clearly different shades of orange.

Originally posted by Creshosk

Question. How would the Repello Muggletum charm play out?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
haermm I didn't even bother with that because it will be dismissed.

I'm not entirely sure how that works.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
haermm I didn't even bother with that because it will be dismissed.

Originally posted by Zampanó
I'm confused. What exactly would the charm be used to do? If the characters start in the castle, then a charm preventing muggles from approaching will not do much good. The combatants are already there. I suppose that the tactic could be used to hide corridors from the invaders, but that would do little against such a large force of invaders. Any ambush or attack by the defenders would be mounted against far superior numbers, abysmal odds.

Originally posted by Zampanó
I'm confused. What exactly would the charm be used to do? If the characters start in the castle, then a charm preventing muggles from approaching will not do much good. The combatants are already there. I suppose that the tactic could be used to hide corridors from the invaders, but that would do little against such a large force of invaders. Any ambush or attack by the defenders would be mounted against far superior numbers, abysmal odds.

[i]Originally posted by Luminatus
What would the wizards do with prep anyway? They aren't techno geniuses or military leaders...
But fine. They get 2 hours to prepare for the 501st's arrival.

And the 501st has no prep. They never did. They're just attacking.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Oh right, that whole unsupported the force deflects magic argument.

I'm not entirely sure how that works.

Its supported because all things, people, spells, air, grund, everything etc in any HP vs SW thread are made of subatomic particles as everything is..
And the force being explained as being a massive energy field that controls and IS everything and it concentrated in some living things.
Anakin was born from/as vergence in this force to be the mechanism that would establish balance between its light and dark side.

So if this living force decides that the part of it that is a certain spell attack, that would hurt one of it's agents with which it is symbiotic, its safe that this force at the behest of its symbiotic user, could disrupt the attack at a sub atomic level, since it controls the very stuff that the attacker and/or attack is made of, since we understand a bit about it works..

Hope that helps.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Its supported because all things, people, spells, air, grund, everything etc in any HP vs SW thread are made of subatomic particles as everything is..
And the force being explained as being a massive energy field that controls and IS everything and it concentrated in some living things.
Anakin was born from/as vergence in this force to be the mechanism that would establish balance between its light and dark side.

So if this living force decides that the part of it that is a certain spell attack, that would hurt one of it's agents with which it is symbiotic, its safe that this force at the behest of its symbiotic user, could disrupt the attack at a sub atomic level, since it controls the very stuff that the attacker and/or attack is made of, since we understand a bit about it works..

Hope that helps.

Try again.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
OK then.

Tell me.....How are the Jedi gonna keep from being mind raped by Hermione's "confundus?" How are they gonna attack her when she is 5000 feet away, being protected by Flitwick under a shield charm, surrounded by the OOTP, in a building that is protected by another shield charm like the one that protects Hogwarts? All the while dodging death spells, and a big ass wall of fiendfyre surrounding them?

I can't WAIT to hear your pitiful excuse for an answer.

Waiting......................waiting..........

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
No it doesn't. I already took this argument, ***** slapped it, wrapped it in shit flavored wrapping paper, attached it to your ass, and handed it back to you.

Try again.

You should then have read it instead, maybe. 🙂

Cause you wouldn't have been made of pure fail, then......