501st vs. Hogwarts

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Waiting......................waiting..........

Not as long as we've been waiting for you to watch SW and realise the error of your statements.

🙂

And there it is, the pitiful excuse for an answer.

I'll try again:

Tell me.....How are the Jedi gonna keep from being mind raped by Hermione's "confundus?" How are they gonna attack her when she is 5000 feet away, being protected by Flitwick under a shield charm, surrounded by the OOTP, in a building that is protected by another shield charm like the one that protects Hogwarts? All the while dodging death spells, and a big ass wall of fiendfyre surrounding them?

Genuine question. You gonna answer, or you gonna retreat into your little spite shell?

Pitiful excuse for an answer from a specialist in such posts.

And you'll fail again: It wouldnt' work because it will be precogged as coming and countered by taking out the casters before the cast.

Simples. 🙂

Now it answered it AGAIN, are you keep flaming/mirepresenting/strawmanning away, empty of all logic, intelligence and savvy..?

*Waits for usual kneejerk attempted smart-alec-ing post bereft of real content avoing the problem that all the wizards lie crushed under flaming rubble.*

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Pitiful excuse for an answer from a specialist in such posts.

And you'll fail again: It wouldnt' work because it will be precogged as coming and countered by taking out the casters before the cast.

Simples. 🙂

When the battle begins, Hermione is thousands of feet away. The Jedi cannot cover that distance, get past the shield charm outside, fight past the OOTP, get past the shield charm protecting Hermione, and kill her before she says confundus. Try again.

Precog Schmeecog, it's flimsy at best. Even at 100%, it doesn't help here. Try again.

Now it answered it AGAIN, are you keep flaming/mirepresenting/strawmanning away, empty of all logic, intelligence and savvy..?

*Waits for usual kneejerk attempted smart-alec-ing post bereft of real content avoing the problem that all the wizards lie crushed under flaming rubble.*

Try again or concede.

At 100% precog, the wizard's have 0% chance. 🙂

Even with 100%, Anakin is done, dude. He'll be mind raped and dancing to the oldies before he knows it.

Fiendfyre mops up.

I don't see how fire is going to hurt people in climate controlled airtight suits.

Originally posted by Zampanó
I don't see how fire is going to hurt people in climate controlled airtight suits.

yeah especially since the fire seen onsreen has ever ever been identified as fiendfyre in the first place

Originally posted by Zampanó
I don't see how fire is going to hurt people in climate controlled airtight suits.

The fire is supposed to be very intense and it's the most intense magical fire. I do not see how the plastoid alloy is going to keep from melting very quickly as the 501st screams their last breaths.

I may be being silly, however, as the battle may not even make it that far.

I'm stale on this thread and where it stands.

it's the most intense magical fire.

This has not been confirmed by the movies and, going only by what's been shown/said onscreen, you have no reason to think so.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Its supported because all things, people, spells, air, grund, everything etc in any HP vs SW thread are made of subatomic particles as everything is..
And the force being explained as being a massive energy field that controls and IS everything and it concentrated in some living things.
Anakin was born from/as vergence in this force to be the mechanism that would establish balance between its light and dark side.

So if this living force decides that the part of it that is a certain spell attack, that would hurt one of it's agents with which it is symbiotic, its safe that this force at the behest of its symbiotic user, could disrupt the attack at a sub atomic level, since it controls the very stuff that the attacker and/or attack is made of, since we understand a bit about it works..

Hope that helps.

Where did they even so much as manipulate light, photons, sub atomic pariticles?

In which movie when did they ever manipulate a subatomic particle?

When did they ever manipulate the energy that the harry potter magic is made up of?

If it didn't happen in the movie its not a power avaiable to them.

The muggle repelling spell happened in DH😛1 at least.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Pitiful excuse for an answer from a specialist in such posts.

And you'll fail again: It wouldnt' work because it will be precogged as coming and countered by taking out the casters before the cast.

Simples. 🙂

Now it answered it AGAIN, are you keep flaming/mirepresenting/strawmanning away, empty of all logic, intelligence and savvy..?

*Waits for usual kneejerk attempted smart-alec-ing post bereft of real content avoing the problem that all the wizards lie crushed under flaming rubble.*

Instead balance to the force was acheived with 2 on each side when the light side had so many more users on its side.

No because the dark side was governing then, so all but the most powerful of the Jedi, (Scuse the pun) "In the dark" so to speak..

Balance was only achieved in the end when the one half of the sith were destroyed, the other turned and died, and the last Jedi was dead also.
Luke was a sign of the cycle beginning again.

The darkside was more powerful than the light, but more temporary/unstable. Like its users.

Instead balance to the force was acheived with 2 on each side when the light side had so many more users on its side.

No, the dark side itself was the imbalance. The dark side is a corrupted form of the Force, akin to a cancer. By killing off the Sith, Vader 'cured' the Force and brought it back to its natural state.

Interesting interpritations. But the only sith I recall Anakin killing in the movies was Dooku. Dooku was such an overbalancing aspect that he more than made up for the jedi council minus yoda and the nonjedi that were killed by order 66 and the younglings in the temple?

And Palpatine in ROTJ.

Dooku and Palpatine.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
And Palpatine in ROTJ.

Dooku and Palpatine.

Though the jedi council never struck me as all that bright during episodes 1-3.

Yes those were in the dark times. That was why the Jedi/lightsiders got their asses kicked for those 18 years.

It took two Jedi normally to battle a sith in the prequel days.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
In case you guys forgot, I agreed that Hogwarts cannot stand up to the full might of the 501st, ships included. This is why the thread was altered, to make it not so one sided.

RJ admitting that HP lacks what it takes to put ungimped SWers away, whilst attempting to justify crying to get the thread altered/SW gimped..
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=511844&pagenumber=21

💃 💃 💃

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
RJ admitting that HP lacks what it takes to put ungimped SWers away, whilst attempting to justify crying to get the thread altered/SW gimped..
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=511844&pagenumber=21

💃 💃 💃

I merely pm'd the thread starter and asked for clarification.